Tuesday, December 22, 2020

Never Seen It, #26 of 200: Brief Encounter

I'm working my way through an alphabetical list of 200 movies I've never seen before. That list is HERE, and the next movie is below.


Brief Encounter
1945

Two things you should know right from the start (and don't worry, this introduction won't be as embarrassing as last week's). First, this might've been the best movie I've seen for Never Seen It so far. I'm not joking. Though there isn't a "twist" or whatever, you'll definitely be spoiled if you read this essay, so why not just watch it first? It's on YouTube, and it's 87 minutes long. No excuses! Second, due to the subject matter of this film, I'm going to have to hold the cards a little closer to my chest than I usually do. Get me drunk in person and I'll talk your ear off with specifics about what I'm going to allude to below, but there has to be a limit as to what personal details I will share on a public blog, and Brief Encounter forces me to acknowledge that limit and abide by it.
 
Like all faithful Old Hollywood films, Brief Encounter is structured like a play, in that there is a "stage" that the characters mostly stick to, and the perspective is simple, i.e. all the focus is on the motivations and journeys of our main characters. Another way to put it is that Brief Encounter is one of those movies that could be a play if it wanted to be. And, of course, like many Old Hollywood films, it actually was based on a play, written by Noel Coward, who later wrote the screenplay and produced the film. Without having seen the play itself, I can imagine that there weren't many changes necessary in the transition to screen. I love movies like this.

Brief Encounter is directed by David Lean, whose Bridge on the River Kwai was featured in this column only a couple weeks ago. On the one hand, these two films are wildly different experiences, with one being an epic war drama, and one being an intimate romantic drama. On the other hand, I can easily make the connection emotionally—both films expertly build up to stunningly tense conclusions. It's just that River Kwai's climax was literally explosive, whereas Brief Encounter's climax was an internal implosion. Both kept me on the edge of my seat, though in quite different ways.

So let's talk about how we reached that climax a bit. Brief Encounter is about the whirlwind romance of Laura (Celia Johnson) and Alec (Trevor Howard), and what happens when both parties come to understand that the romance is forbidden and can never be fulfilled. You see, both Laura and Alec are married, but after finding each other at a train station and subsequently falling in love, they both realize that maybe there was a hidden longing for something more. They brought out a passion in each other that had previously rested in the shadows of marriages that—at least on Laura's end, since hers is the only home life we get to explore—are nice and pleasant and stuffy and boring.

If this movie had been made in the decades after the 1940s, perhaps things would've turned out differently, but in 1945, divorce was still frowned upon. Laura's passion for Alec was matched perhaps only in her vivid fear of being ostracized from society for her infidelities. It is in this friction, this internal struggle, between Laura's desires, between being caught up in the wild longing for another and being grounded enough to know that it would absolutely topple her life to give in, it's this friction that gives Brief Encounter life.

I think the most interesting thing about Laura's internal struggle is the fact that her husband, Fred, seems like a pretty genial and kindhearted fellow, at least from what we see of him throughout the movie. You can tell that he cares deeply about Laura, even if he might not show it while he's doing his crosswords. Brief Encounter would be infinitely smaller of a movie if Fred was a heel, like many romantic comedy villains tend to be (like Hugh Grant last week, basically). But he wasn't. He was portrayed as a good husband. And I find that absolutely fascinating.

It's an idea that I've been fascinated with for a long time, if we're being honest. Think back to the reasons I described in my unending appreciation for Peter Campbell. Here is a man who gets everything he wanted—a beautiful wife, a cute daughter, a successful career, a stable home—and is then horrified to find that he still feels broken inside. To anyone else, he has the perfect life, but it becomes apparent to him that he may never conquer the demons that reside inside of him and cause him to forget all that he has.

The similarities between Laura and Pete Campbell are striking. A loving husband, two great (albeit perhaps a bit whiny) kids, a large suburban home, time off to attend the movies, and with all that, a sinking feeling that, for some reason, it's not enough. The only difference between the two characters is how they respond to those unavoidable feelings. Pete lashes out and implodes certain aspects of his life. Laura, on the other hand, backs away from the edge and manages to hold on tight just long enough. Pete, in other words, would've jumped in front of the train if he could. Laura is able to stay put.

I'll speak as generally as I can here—I can empathize, not really with the specifics, but with the general hits one's self-esteem can take when you come to find pain and sadness in what should be a perfect life. You start to wonder whether a day's worth of sadness is a reflection on the life you lead, or if it's something more sinister. Maybe you start to wonder whether there really is something wrong with you, that you could possibly feel this demoralized within the scope of all this should-be happiness.
 
It's a disconcerting feeling, but I've felt it for sure. And I want to tell you that Brief Encounter captures that feeling perfectly. Near the end of the film, when Alec leaves Laura's life forever, and the camera goes Dutch and closes in on the look on Laura's face as stands there on the train platform and the train's lights rush by her and the look on her face is that of wide-eyed terror for what is and what could've been and what will never be—that's the feeling.

I'm trembling just writing about it, honestly. Connecting so intimately with a movie character has never, not fucking ever, been such a gut-punch to me. To find such a vivid impression of some deep-seeded emotional devastation within myself reflected in a goddamn black-and-white British romance drama from 1945 was a real stunner, and perhaps speaks more closely to the idea that there are more of us out there than I originally thought.

Anyways, I don't mean to imply that there's been infidelity in my life that has caused me such painfully specific feelings of love and loss. I only mean to say that some emotions are tall and terrible and transcend the details. Hopefully, too, these emotions are brief (as the title indicates). Both Laura and Pete found that, after they went through their heavy shit, they could return home to the loving arms of those waiting for them. And of course, I've felt that too. Pain is 99% perspective.

And yet, there remains that 1% in the back of your mind, that knowledge that you remain broken no matter whose arms embrace you. It's important to remember that Fred welcomes Laura home from "wherever you've been," but it's so difficult for me to remember it too. All I can picture is the look on Celia Johnson's face as the train passed. If my phone had switched to selfie mode in that moment, I would've still seen the same face staring back at me.

GRADE: 5 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Our third romance movie in a row, Brokeback Mountain, might prove that there is much yet to discuss on the topic.

2 comments:

sunny said...

I'd never seen this before but watched it tonight (thanks for the link!) - and that was a great watch.

Your analysis of the feeling portrayed (...when you come to find pain and sadness in what should be a perfect life...) is accurate. Fred being a pretty good ('undelicate') husband adds to this sentiment of a "good life." It's an interesting one because it's hardly universal, but very widespread, and something that (even though the stigma of divorce has lessened in 70 yrs) still drives shameful feelings in such a way a lot of people can't talk about it -- voiceover in ones head, like Laura's, might be it.

Also nice to see folks think the Donald Duck cartoon is better than the feature after. Some things never change.

Joe K said...

Dude, I'm so glad you were able to watch it. I'm still shocked about how good this was. Maybe I will make more of an effort to provide links in the future, especially if they are easily streamed.