Friday, January 22, 2021

BE, Joe


I have not seen the latest installment of Disney's COVID-quarantine-inspired sing-along TV special, but reports from Willow and Martha (and Pam) have indicated that BTS takes part in that special, singing the Disney classic "[no idea, not looking it up]," and coming off as quite affable. I have no reason to dispute this report. BTS come from a long lineage of boy bands whose members' personalities are either genuinely jubilant/charitable or carefully marketed as such, and I obviously have no problem with this either. If the "bad boy" image is exhausting, then the "good boys" image is refreshing. Out with Bieber, in with BTS.

And if you feel like I've wasted my opening graf with generalities that shouldn't have to be explained, then I probably agree, but that's only because I'm just killing time before I have to talk about the specific songs, for which there isn't much substance. Pretty fluffy boilerplate 2020s pop music that was clearly put together hastily during a concert-halting (i.e. money-making-machine-halting) pandemic. Lots of the lyrics—if you are the type to comb through any of the translations on genius.com—touch on already-cliché pandemic-inspired emotions, e.g. in "Fly to My Room" the anti-2020 meme-isms of "Somebody turn back the clock / The entire year got stolen," shit you've seen on your TL since April.

Not that I'm necessarily immune to BTS' charms. I like pop music as much as the next jabroni. I've indulged in my fair share of "2020 was the worst!"isms in the past ten months. I don't have much to complain about when it comes to BE. Yeah, it doesn't move pop music forward in any innovative or refreshing way, but does it have to? Yeah, it's catchy in a clearly manufactured way, but isn't all pop? Yeah, it indulges in hackneyed pop conventions like adding clear hip hop flourishes in and around the songs, but, like, compared to the boy bands I grew up with at least, it's kind of new, I guess? In this specific context?

We're barreling toward one of those conclusions where I state something like "this album is fine for what it is but doesn't do much to move my needle" or whatever, so let's stop cold to talk about "Skit," killing the momentum in the same way BTS does on BE. "Skit" sucks. Any sub-30-minute album that indulges in a three-minute spoken-word field recording sucks, and doubly so if you need to do extra work to figure out what they are talking about, and triply so if you discover that what they are blabbering on about in the middle of the goddamn album is a spirited conversation about how successful they themselves are. I get that BTS would be excited about being the first all-Korean group to hit #1 on the Billboard Hot 100—they should be! But, I mean, I probably don't need to hear about it in a song? And it's not even like BTS are out here inventing new ways to lack humility. I know for a fact that the original boy band, the Beatles, did all kinds of shit like this, sending actual vinyl records to fan club members that featured spoken-word messages from the Beatles themselves. Indulgent and inessential, in my opinion (but not in the opinion of Andre Gardner on WMGK's "Breakfast with the Beatles" Sunday morning radio program that I listened to growing up). But still, the Beatles weren't leaving these messages in the middle of fucking Magical Mystery Tour. They were optional appendices to the canon. The only option BTS gives me is to get up out of my seat and press "skip" on the iPod.

Anyways, this album is fine for what it is but doesn't do much to move my needle. Maybe the exception is "Dynamite," the aforementioned #1 hit single. There is nothing revolutionary about this song, but it's been well over a year since I've gotten drunk at a wedding and danced, so hearing "Dynamite" and clearly picturing such a scenario might classify this as revolutionary in its own way. The song might paint BTS as the Korean Black Eyed Peas and it might feature possibly the worst key change I've ever heard on tape, but goddamn it, it gets me tapping my feet regardless. I can at least make sense of this song's popularity (unlike the other sad-girl Lorde/Billie/Bridgers spotify-core bullshit that is ruling the charts this current week). "Dynamite" accomplishes what all pop music should—gets in your head, makes you happier than you were before you heard it. Faint praise, but praise nonetheless.

Okay, but so that leaves one good-to-great song, one unforgivably trite non-song, and then like 20-odd minutes of mostly forgettable, bland pop music 101. I've listened to plenty of actively bad albums in Record Club, and this ain't one of them. But BTS avoids being bad by being mostly vacuous. If you want my completely unwarranted opinion, then I'll suppose that this is the exact reason why BTS are so goddamn popular. Put in a blender this very banal, shallow pop music, add on top of that the fact that the lyrics could mean anything to those of us who are uni-lingual, and then add too the fact that the artists are young, happy, nice, probably cute to many young music consumers, and then hit blend, and out pops out a product that you can apply to any listening need. Millions of people like BTS because of this. It's like loving bread because you can make so many different sandwiches.

And who could be so heartless as to actively dislike something that could be compared to bread? No one needs that kind of anger right now. Let's just enjoy BTS for what it is, and move on. I wish them well in their continued success both at home and abroad.

GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5

No comments: