Sunday, December 4, 2022

Advent Calendar: December 4th



Hard pressed to name my favorite Christmas song of all time, I'd probably say "Jingle Bell Rock" as performed by Dr. Teeth and the Electric Mayhem. I don't know if that counts, since it's never seen a traditional release on streaming or physical media. I also acknowledge that my feelings regarding this version of the modern Christmas standard are inextricably linked to my love of A Muppet Family Christmas; I would love the Electric Mayhem's music in any context, but I don't know if this song would be my favorite Christmas song if it were in a vacuum.

Here's something important, though, and it's honestly the reason I am here today talking about Dr. Teeth in the first place: if their version of "Jingle Bell Rock" did see an official release on streaming platforms, then I would press the importance of the "artist" being listed as "Dr. Teeth and the Electric Mayhem." This is one of my pet peeves that I feel extremely strongly about, if you'll allow me another paragraph or two to explain before I leave you to the rest of your day.

My argument is in favor of the accredited artist being listed as the fictional character who is performing the song, and is against the recent practice of listing the actor who is giving voice to said character. In other words, some jabronis would argue that this version of "Jingle Bell Rock" should have the listed artist of: "Jim Henson, Frank Oz, Jerry Nelson, Richard Hunt, and David Goelz." These performers did indeed give voice to Dr. Teeth, Animal, Floyd, Janice, and Zoot, respectively, in A Muppet Family Christmas.

But I say that the standard should be the artist listed as the performer, and in this case the performers are technically Dr. Teeth and the Electric Mayhem. If you listen to "Rainbow Connection," for instance, then yes, Kermit the Frog is listed as the artist. Good, good. On the other hand, if you listen to any random Disney song on streaming, then it's going to list the voice actors who are voicing the characters singing the songs. E.g. "I've Got a Dream" from Tangled has the artist listed as: "Brad Garrett, Jeffrey Tambor, Mandy Moore and Zachary Levi." No! Boo! It should be listed as "Hook Hand Thug, Big Nose Thug, Rapunzel, and Flynn Rider."

If you think I'm being crazy, then look to any other fucking song outside of children's entertainment. Look at, I dunno, "Thot Shit" by Megan Thee Stallion. What, you thought "Megan Thee Stallion" is her actual name? Hell no. It's a stage name, just like "Dr. Teeth" is a stage name for Jim Henson. Think about how utterly fucking ridiculous it would seem if you queued up "Thot Shit" and you saw that the artist of that song was listed as "Megan Pete." Right?!

Ignoring the fact that Megan Thee Stallion's birth name is even sillier than "Dr. Teeth," you have to admit that it is and has always been the standard to list the artist of any song or album as the artistic name chosen by that artist for themselves. And I don't understand why companies like Disney seem determined to break that sacred pact. Let the fictional characters speak for themselves, I say! Bah humbug!

No comments: