I have been feeling wary about TS meeting RC. I am feeling the need to pre-emptively defend Taylor. I'm trying to fight the urge!
Sam Sanders deftly dove into "the problem" with Taylor Swift on Into It and why, despite her MASSIVE success, she still draws so much ire. So many eye rolls. I myself used to! That whole Tom Hiddleston era with the celebrity bff stage squad? Come on! But once I got over the Taylor persona and just listened to the music, I was hooked. "Out of the Woods" was my Swiftie gateway drug (or getaway car, your pick).
Yes, she does have very obvious perfectionism and desire to maintain a very specific media image. Okay? Seems like part of the job, tbh. And who cares if she has boyfriends and writes about them? Isn't that Drake's whole career too? All of her albums are massive hits and her new tour brought TICKETMASTER to its knees with an investigation by the DOJ. And yet.
I have a theory. Her fanbase is young women, queer folks, and teen girls. And who has ever taken them seriously? Easy to dismiss, right? I mean, even in the write up for this week's album, a song-by-song analysis was called "embarrassingly obsessive." Hm. Pitchfork has a whole section of the website dedicated to this. Here's one on Frank Ocean on Genius. Again, what's the problem with Taylor?
(This isn't to say she hasn't been problematic in the past. No one that famous gets by unscathed. Also, it's perfectly fine if you don't like her music. I just think sometimes it's worth examining why. Have we learned nothing from Britney?)
I also really, really agreed with Ann Powers' take on Into It. In essence, Taylor is still seen as that naïve teen girl forever in our minds because she is an adult woman without children. She's not—we're not—taken as seriously as our peers who give birth. So maybe the reason I'm tired of defending Taylor Swift is because I'm tired of defending myself. (heavy!)
And that's what Taylor's music is about. The self. Sometimes with a wink, but often earnestly confessional. So let's dive into the music itself, shall we? (Though it's extremely apropos to just talk about the person Taylor before even going into the album.)
Truth be told, Midnights sits right in the middle of Swift's oeuvre, where Red, folklore, and 1989 *shimmer* right at the top. It took me like three or four listens to really get hooked. A few tracks are absolute sleepy skips. Will it be one I return to, or more of a periphery listen like Lover and Reputation? Hm. Time will tell. But I'm not ashamed to say that this will certainly show up on my Spotify Wrapped. It's incredibly freeing. (Teen scene kid Rachel would be so embarrassed!!!).
Midnights is not without its bright spots. The leading single "Anti-Hero" is, as culturista Bowen Yang would say, her thesis statement. If you're a fan, a listener, a reader, then you know she likes to address her perceived public persona. That supposedly cunningly crafted one. "Anti-Hero" swallows all the narratives around her whole and spits it back—not in the face of her "haters," (they gonna hate, hate, hate), but in her own reflection. "I'm the problem, it's me," keeps all of us up at night, Taylor. Though it's "pierced through the heart but never killed" that's been sitting with me lately.
I've also been enjoying "Maroon" and "the lips I used to call home." Oof, a line for the broken-hearts club (always her finest wheelhouse). I'll even dabble in some "Vigilante Shit" if I'm feeling saucy (a sure kitschy callback to the Reputation-era Tayla). But, oh how I've fallen all the way into "Mastermind." Here is where the Jack Antonoff of it all really pays off—and Taylor gives us both a wink and a true confessional. It's the center of the Venn Diagram of what she does best.
Some of the best (and one of the absolute worst—more on that in a moment) comes in at 3 AM (the bonus tracks, ICYMI). This is where all the sad dads (myself included) who followed Aaron Dessner of The National over into the Swiftiverse via folklore and evermore will find themselves. "The Great War" was made for them, for us. "Would've, Could've, Should've" is where I'd love Taylor to keep going musically. It's all the pulsing broodiness of the Dessner-made folklore but with just enough pop-forward feel. Bonus: fuck John Mayer! Side bar: I sincerely can't wait to see hordes of Swifties at the next National concert. What a thought!
Now, 3 AM is also where the most embarrassing lyric of the whole album lives (à la all of "Welcome to New York" and "Hey kids, spelling is fun!" via "You Need to Calm Down"). A line that makes me shrink and go, "Come on Taylor, you're making this hard for me to defend. Lay off the cornball." This time around it's, "Sit quiet by my side in the shade / And not the kind that's thrown / I mean, the kind under where a tree has grown." Taylor, you're better than this. The rest of the album, at least lyrically, proves it.
All in all, Midnights could have gone a little bigger, brighter. It felt like a half-step back from the trajectory of her latest albums. Jack Antonoff's hand didn't pay off as much as it used to. But the parts that shine really, really do. And thank god, Ed Sheeran was nowhere to be found on this one. He's such a snooze.
In closing, love or hate her, she was fucking right about K*nye.

No comments:
Post a Comment