Well, here we are at the start of the 200th week of Record Club. I think there is enough data from these past 199 weeks' worth of reviews to construct what we'll call the RECORD CLUB ALGORITHM.
Basically, I combed through all 959 reviews that have been written for Record Club so far, and I made a list of every musical artist that was ever mentioned in any review. View the spreadsheet HERE.
Basically, I combed through all 959 reviews that have been written for Record Club so far, and I made a list of every musical artist that was ever mentioned in any review. View the spreadsheet HERE.
I didn't include mentions of the artist who made the album, obviously. I didn't include mentions of an artist if they were involved in the making of the album in any way, like a feature, or in reference to a production credit, or anything like that. I didn't count any RC alumni, whether they had been made a part of RC when the review was written at that point or not. I didn't count any artist who is ineligible for Record Club currently (basically any alum, plus the Beatles). I didn't count any artist who is technically eligible but whom I felt uncomfortable with the prospect of covering in Record Club ("cancelled" if you want to call it that, though it's really more of a personal choice on my part—anyone from R. Kelly to Arcade Fire to Michael Jackson).
Minus those exceptions, I counted 914 separate mentions of artists. I put them in chronological order. Then, in a separate list, I grouped together artists. I also made a third list grouped together by writer. But it's that second list that I'm using for the next few weeks. Through this algorithm, we answer the question: which artists have been mentioned the most by the Record Club writers over the past 199 weeks?
This week, we are doing the second place winner. Next week will be the third place winner (on a tiebreaker). Then finally, the week before Christmas, we'll do the artist who has been mentioned the most times in reviews since Record Club began. (You can count them yourself on the spreadsheet if you want to be spoiled, I don't mind.)
When I think "algorithm," I think about a computer program answering the prompt "If you like THIS, then you'll probably like THAT," based on totally arbitrary metrics. The Record Club Algorithm is answering the prompt by giving you the artists that you've mentioned the most times in reviews. It might not ACTUALLY be true that if you like these 199 RC artists, then you'll like today's artist, but that's the what the algorithm is telling you, so listen up, pals.
Read all the reviews at the archives, check out the goals for one of the last times, and then continue on below to see what the algorithm has in store today. Happy 200, everybody.
Week 200 — November 27-December 3, 2022
What we're listening to this week (according to the RC algorithm):
ARTIST: Taylor Swift
RECORD CLUB REVIEWS THAT HAVE MENTIONED TAYLOR SWIFT AND HAVE THUS INFORMED THE ALGORITHM TO CHOOSE TAYLOR SWIFT THIS WEEK: Nate's 1000 gecs review, Joe's Push Back review, Rachel's Walk Through Fire review, Joe's SOUR review, Rachel's SOUR review, Joe's Masterpiece Theatre review, Rachel's 30 review, Rachel's Humble Quest review, Joe's Dance Fever review, Jeff's Purgatory review, Joe's Deadpan Love review, Nate's Return of Saturn review.
RECORD CLUB REVIEWS THAT HAVE MENTIONED TAYLOR SWIFT AND HAVE THUS INFORMED THE ALGORITHM TO CHOOSE TAYLOR SWIFT THIS WEEK: Nate's 1000 gecs review, Joe's Push Back review, Rachel's Walk Through Fire review, Joe's SOUR review, Rachel's SOUR review, Joe's Masterpiece Theatre review, Rachel's 30 review, Rachel's Humble Quest review, Joe's Dance Fever review, Jeff's Purgatory review, Joe's Deadpan Love review, Nate's Return of Saturn review.
RELEASED: October 21, 2022
LOCATION: West Reading, PA
WHAT GENRE IS THIS: Pop
TRACKLIST:
TRACKLIST:
- Lavender Haze
- Maroon
- Anti-Hero
- Snow on the Beach
- You're on Your Own, Kid
- Midnight Rain
- Question...?
- Vigilante Shit
- Bejeweled
- Labyrinth
- Karma
- Sweet Nothing
- Mastermind
LENGTH: 44:02
WHERE TO LISTEN FOR FREE: YouTube
READING SOME SHIT, #1: Our PoYB Taylor Swift correspondent Rachel S. shares this transcribed excerpt from a podcast about Taylor Swift. There's some pretty salient points made about Swift's "image" in our culture.
READING SOME SHIT, #2: Here's an embarrassingly obsessive feature on Vox that "explains" every song on Midnights.
RECORD CLUB ALBUM ON THE DAY THAT THIS ALBUM WAS RELEASED: OK to Go by Virginia Coalition, with reviews from Joe, Pam, Nate, Sunny, and Sam (with Zach's face on the side of a milk carton).
RECORD CLUB ALBUM ON THE DAY THAT THIS ALBUM WAS RELEASED: OK to Go by Virginia Coalition, with reviews from Joe, Pam, Nate, Sunny, and Sam (with Zach's face on the side of a milk carton).
PREVIOUSLY ON RECORD CLUB: There's probably a lot to write about in this section. Though RC has never covered a Taylor Swift album before, Swift seems to have her hands in a lot of different corners of the pop music world, so there are going to be plenty of connections to albums we have covered.
Just off the top of my head, I recall that "1 step forward, 3 steps back" on Olivia Rodrigo's SOUR has a Swift writing credit, since it interpolates Swift's song "New Year's Day." And then also Cautious Clay's big claim to fame is that he had one of his songs interpolated by Taylor Swift on one of hers. Nothing wrong with sharing music is everyone gets the proper credit, and the great pop machine tends to share a lot between its many cogs and gears. Also: Taylor Swift featured on a song by John Mayer one time, though I feel like somebody might have mentioned that in their Mayer review, I forget.
Jack Antonoff is the co-writer and co-producer for the entire album, and this is certainly not the first time his name has popped up in this club (and I'm not even talking about his 2021 Grammy co-winner Aaron Dessner, he of the National, who did the lion's share of the work over Antonoff for Swift's folklore and evermore, but who is relegated to a single bonus track for Midnights). Antonoff has credits on a few Record Club albums, including the aforementioned SOUR. He co-wrote and produced the Chicks' Gaslighter and Florence + the Machine's Dance Fever. He also produced a couple songs in 2022 that feature no less than four RC alumni—Diana Ross and Tame Impala doing the original song "Turn Up the Sunshine," and Tierra Whack covering Fleetwood Mac's "Black Magic Woman," both for that goddamn Minions soundtrack. Not to mention that Antonoff's first Billboard #1, fun.'s "We Are Young," features Janelle Monáe (I totally forgot about this until now).
Plenty of other people get credits on Midnights. There's Sounwave, who had previously produced a song featuring EarthGang. There's Lana Del Rey, who features in "Snow on the Beach." This isn't even the first time we've heard Del Rey's voice on an RC album; she was featured on "Woman" way back in Week 3, on Cat Power's Wanderer. There's Randy Merrill, who's also been the mastering engineer for RC artists Harry Styles, Adele, Maren Morris, BTS, and Olivia Rodrigo. There's Serban Ghenea, who's also done the mixing for RC artists Destiny's Child, Miley Cyrus, lizard person Demi Lovato, Weezer, BTS, Kelly Clarkson, and Dave Matthews Band.
Just off the top of my head, I recall that "1 step forward, 3 steps back" on Olivia Rodrigo's SOUR has a Swift writing credit, since it interpolates Swift's song "New Year's Day." And then also Cautious Clay's big claim to fame is that he had one of his songs interpolated by Taylor Swift on one of hers. Nothing wrong with sharing music is everyone gets the proper credit, and the great pop machine tends to share a lot between its many cogs and gears. Also: Taylor Swift featured on a song by John Mayer one time, though I feel like somebody might have mentioned that in their Mayer review, I forget.
Jack Antonoff is the co-writer and co-producer for the entire album, and this is certainly not the first time his name has popped up in this club (and I'm not even talking about his 2021 Grammy co-winner Aaron Dessner, he of the National, who did the lion's share of the work over Antonoff for Swift's folklore and evermore, but who is relegated to a single bonus track for Midnights). Antonoff has credits on a few Record Club albums, including the aforementioned SOUR. He co-wrote and produced the Chicks' Gaslighter and Florence + the Machine's Dance Fever. He also produced a couple songs in 2022 that feature no less than four RC alumni—Diana Ross and Tame Impala doing the original song "Turn Up the Sunshine," and Tierra Whack covering Fleetwood Mac's "Black Magic Woman," both for that goddamn Minions soundtrack. Not to mention that Antonoff's first Billboard #1, fun.'s "We Are Young," features Janelle Monáe (I totally forgot about this until now).
Plenty of other people get credits on Midnights. There's Sounwave, who had previously produced a song featuring EarthGang. There's Lana Del Rey, who features in "Snow on the Beach." This isn't even the first time we've heard Del Rey's voice on an RC album; she was featured on "Woman" way back in Week 3, on Cat Power's Wanderer. There's Randy Merrill, who's also been the mastering engineer for RC artists Harry Styles, Adele, Maren Morris, BTS, and Olivia Rodrigo. There's Serban Ghenea, who's also done the mixing for RC artists Destiny's Child, Miley Cyrus, lizard person Demi Lovato, Weezer, BTS, Kelly Clarkson, and Dave Matthews Band.
There's Zoë Kravitz, who starred in Big Little Lies. That show's theme song was written by Michael Kiwanuka. That show also stars Laura Dern (who's in a video for a Midnights song) and Nicole Kidman (who starred in the 2018 film Boy Erased, which also featured Joe Alwyn, who receives a writing credit on this album for "Sweet Nothing," under his pseudonym "William Bowery" (he's also dating Swift)). Poor Reese Witherspoon, who is first-billed in Big Little Lies, but has nothing to do with Taylor Swift... unless you count the fact that Witherspoon's book club's most famous pick was Where the Crawdads Sing, which was just released as a film adaptation, featuring a new Swift song that might just net her an Oscar.
Okay, that's enough. You get it. Taylor Swift is finally here in Record Club. We've mentioned her a bunch, and we've been in her orbit forever. Now let's listen.
Happy listening, fam! Have a great week!

1 comment:
Finally, PoYB enters the field of data science
Post a Comment