I think there's plenty of criticisms to be lobbed toward Marianas Trench, based on what I heard this week. I also think that the band does a good enough job defending themselves against those criticisms that I can't hate them, even though, on the surface, this is absolutely a band that I would typically hate.
This is a pop band. Sure, there are guitars and bass and drums, and the members of the band actually play those instruments, and write their own songs, but at the end of the day, there is barely any difference between Marianas Trench and, say, a BTS-type group.
The defense against this criticism is two-fold. One, as we've already discussed numerous times over the past two and half years, any issues I have with "pop" as a construct have more to do with me than with the artists themselves. There is no substance here. It's all bright, clean fluff. But then you might be inclined to ask why I need substance. Do I? Or is that just pretension masked as music criticism?
Two, if this is pop, and if pop ultimately means nothing, and if this really is all a facade, then at least Marianas Trench seem to be aware of it. Opening track "Masterpiece Theatre I" finds frontman Josh Ramsay belting the chorus: "But this is just a part I portray." It's like when someone shows up to a Halloween party with a shitty costume on, but they acknowledge that it's shitty, and join in the mockery because it deserves to be mocked. There is no Jim Halpert smugness here; Marianas Trench are corny as fuck, and they know it. They are in on the joke. That's endearing, if nothing else.
Though I might sound like a broken record saying it, I'm gonna make the point anyway: at least half of this is very catchy. I think that's the ultimate defense of anyone who wants to claim that this is a shitty album. Bring all the personal baggage you want to this affair, but the ultimate defense is the hooks. (Sidenote: this is ultimately why I will never fucking understand the popularity of Post Malone's music—for real, where are the fucking hooks, man?)
I can stomach all the other bullshit if it's catchy. I'm not saying that's all there is, and indeed, if an album is just hooks surrounded by empty algorithm posturing, then I can't say it's a "good" album, either. But I'd rather have an album that's 50% catchy made by fools than an album that's 0% catchy meticulously made by an acclaimed genius artist. It's like when I get acid reflux—I know that Tums are gonna make me a little nauseous, but being a little nauseous is much better than burping fire.
But yes, okay, there is a lot to stomach here.
In the Tums column: y'all know I like a good treatise on toxic nostalgia in pop-punk form, and "Acadia" scratches the itch; the four-on-the-floor chorus of "All to Myself" is good stuff; "Cross My Heart," despite absolutely being the type of single that would get me to walk all the way across a room just to turn the radio dial away from Radio 104.5, eventually won me over; "Sing Sing" is a close enough approximation of something like Fall Out Boy that I rolled my eyes and enjoyed it in equal measures; "Celebrity Status" is not a good song, per se, but it was at least satisfying to understand Mariana Trench's place in the pop continuum, i.e. this could totally be a Taylor Swift song from the late '10s with a few small changes.
In the acid reflux column: plenty of shitty, not-catchy songs all over Masterpiece Theatre; "Good to You" is mawkish bullshit, and proves that Marianas Trench only has one lane that works; "Lover Dearest" is an absolutely snooze of a penultimate song, and does not adhere to the old performer standby of "leave 'em wanting more"; I honestly don't think I've hated anything on this earth more than the "ooo-way-ooo-way-ooo" chorus of "Beside You," it just completely fucking crosses the line from fun-corny to torturous-syrupy dreck; does this band really believe that they deserved a motherfucking encore with the completely superfluous "Masterpiece Theatre III," or were they just getting an early start on the whole trend of "remix versions" of pop songs that are so prevalent today?
Ultimately, the Tums win in a photo finish. But if I'm taking this many Tums, then maybe I should just change my diet.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment