During our week in Wildwood, I was made aware—in between heated discussions about nü-metal—that there was a theory floating around the internet that Hagrid is actually a Death Eater. This theory is codswallop, in my opinion. I have neither the time nor the blogging energy these days to match the author of this theory, so my objections will be (relatively) brief.
This goes beyond my love of Hagrid as a character, and the empathy I find for him above most other Harry Potter characters. Yes, there is an emotional kinship between me and this fictional, lovable oaf who does similarly stupid things when he's drunk, but if it were truly revealed that it was all a ruse and that he was in league with Voldemort, then I'd take the gut punch but keep standing. Wouldn't give my theoretical son the middle name "Rubeus Hagrid" (probably moot at this point), but I'd accept it as fact—IF it were true. I have a willingness to believe truth, if it is indeed true, even if it goes against my "beliefs."
This goes beyond any criticisms of confirmation bias on the author's part, even though if I had more time, we could go through it step by step and show that the author of this theory shows complete disregard for Occam's razor. By his own admittance, he comes up with a theory, and then runs through the entire series looking for evidence to back up that theory. Simple explanations are eschewed in favor of convoluted hypotheticals. Saying Hagrid is a Death Eater is akin to saying the earth is flat, because the type of evidence used is the same.
I mean, let's just take, as an example, the "evidence" from Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone. I'm quoting directly from the essay here:
- Magical abilities Hagrid uses which are otherwise only known by high-level Death Eaters or extremely talented wizards and witches.
- Disregard to and participation in cruelty to Muggles, as well as a casual approach to Azkaban-level offenses.
- Subtle manipulations of Harry which put him into private contact with Voldemort on multiple occasions.
- Passing private information regarding security directly to Voldemort.
It's not hard to see how these conclusions were made with the theory of "Hagrid is a Death Eater!" in mind. It's also not hard to see how these conclusions are wrong.
Hagrid is "too talented" and is thus a Death Eater? How about the fact that we are seeing his magic from Harry's point of view, and the POV of the beginning of the first book is of an eleven-year-old who has never seen magic before? "Cruelty to Muggles" makes it seem like he is a felon—we're talking specifically about cruelty toward caretakers who kept their adopted nephew locked in a closet for eleven years! Voldemort's henchman would've rewarded the Dursleys' behavior, not punished it! "Manipulating" Harry into meeting Voldemort? C'mon man. Harry chose to use the information that Hagrid let slip. It was his choice. If Voldemort is using Hagrid to manipulate Harry, than how could Voldy possibly know at this point how foolhardy Harry was? Seems like a tall bet to me. And "passing information to Voldemort"? If he's passing information, then why not just pass the goddamn Sorcerer's Stone itself?!
Do you see how fragile this "evidence" is? All you have to do is pull the thread a tiny little bit, and the whole fucking house of cards falls down. The author of this theory is not interested in pulling any threads, however. He is simply interested in selectively pulling facts and twisting them to serve his own batshit theory. It's the worst case of confirmation bias I've seen since a bunch of trump-worshiping terrorists murdered a police officer on the Capitol steps.
But like I said, my feelings go beyond the specific evidence that the author presents, and whether it holds up in the argument or not (again: it doesn't hold up). No, I'll go beyond that and say that my problem with this theory is that it completely disregards the central point of the Harry Potter series. The most important theme of Harry Potter would be utterly null and void if this theory were true. In saying that Hagrid is a Death Eater, than you are admitting that you completely misunderstand what Harry Potter is even about.
The best way to approach this is to go back to that final duel at the end of the Battle of Hogwarts. Harry Potter and Tom Riddle, their wands pointed at each other. (Puke on Your Birthday has already explained this scene.) Riddle is all like "Potter, you lose!" and Harry says something along the lines of: "You are wrong, and you are wrong here, now, specifically because you do not understand the power of love."
It is only by loving other people that we are able to trust them. Through love, we are able to see the goodness, or badness, in people. When we see goodness, we are able to give and receive trust. That forms a bond. Someone like Voldemort, who is focused solely on power, and knows fucking nothing of love, is thoroughly incapable of making such assessments. This directly and indirectly leads to his downfall—because he did not love, he was completely ignorant of Snape's true allegiances, and so on and so on.
On the other end of the spectrum is Dumbledore. Albus understands love so completely that he is able to entrust the fate of the entire Wizarding World in the hands of a group of seventeen-year-olds. Dumbledore's love is so clear that he is able to see Snape's emotional core, and see that he is ultimately motivated by love himself, and it is that bond that ultimately proves the strongest, i.e. Dumbledore's trust in Snape pays off when Snape sacrifices himself, yadda yadda you know the deal if you're still reading at this point.
But so then think about it in how this undeniable truth completely rejects any bullshit theory like "Hagrid was a Death Eater." If it is true that love wins, and if it is true that Dumbledore turns love into trust and is ultimately vindicated, then what, we're supposed to also believe that Dumbledore was wrong about his total trust in Rubeus Hagrid? We're supposed to believe that Dumbledore was bamboozled by this fucking Death Eater for decades?
I'm not saying that it would be unheard of for someone to get burned by being too loving and too trusting. I'm not talking about the world in general here, because I know that the world we live in is, for the most part, a harsh and unloving world filled with powerful people who take advantage of the masses too stupid to see it. But I'm not talking about our world. I'm talking about Harry Potter's world.
And in this world, in these amazing books, the truth is underlined time and time again: Love wins. Love is worth it. Love is champion. To believe that Hagrid is a Death Eater is to not believe that love wins. If you believe that Hagrid is a Death Eater, then you don't believe in Harry Potter.

No comments:
Post a Comment