Wednesday, August 4, 2021

Never Seen It, #53 of 200: Doctor Zhivago

I made a list one time of a bunch of movies I had never seen before. I'm still going through the list in alphabetical order. I do want to mention, though, that I'm starting grad school in less than a month, and there is a very good chance that I won't have time to write 2500 words for every movie I watch. Instead of shelving the project, I'm just gonna cut down on the words. Each movie post will be around 200 words maybe? Is that okay? I'd rather keep watching movies instead of forgetting about the whole thing, ya know? Anyways, here's the next one, and it is short. Irony, maybe, seeing as this is the second-longest movie I've watched for Never Seen It so far. But so it goes.

Also, you may have noticed that I fucked up, and thought that this movie was titled "Dr. Zhivago," as in the abbreviation for "doctor," which affected its place alphabetically. WHOOPS. I'll refer to it here by its correct title, but won't be changing the error on the list.


Doctor Zhivago
1965
David Lean

Fuck, man. Movies over three hours are tough. Obviously this says more about me and my generation's short attention span than it does the movie itself, but it doesn't make my opinion any less true: this was tough. Hence my taking over a month to get around to it.

Not that it was bad. I was pretty engaged throughout most of its runtime. I thought the performances were more than adequate, and occasionally even moving (though is it just me, or do leading ladies rarely get a chance to show their true chops in pre-1970s movies?). The setting—a frigid 1910s Russia—was specific and interesting. As a whole, this three hour and twenty minute movie—complete with a goddamn overture and intermission!—held together a lot better than it had any right to.

And that's true even with the concession that Doctor Zhivago was one of those movies where a lot of things happened, but it never seemed to go anywhere. If that makes sense. The scope is grand and the narrative is vast, but I occasionally felt like the passengers on that packed mid-movie train—not knowing exactly where we were going, and somewhat indifferent to the destination anyway.

I would be lying if I didn't say that the biggest disappointment was not liking it nearly as much as David Lean's other two films from this project so far, The Bridge on the River Kwai and Brief Encounter. Though the films don't necessarily share that many qualities, it is actually possible—and maybe even critically important—to compare them in a few key ways.

If you asked me one reason why I like The Bridge on the River Kwai, then I would say that it was because it felt like a vast, complex movie, but found a genuine thrill in collapsing every thread together into a singular stunning climax. Something about the way that you gained sympathy for all of these different characters, and then were smacked in the face at the end because you forgot that, despite your change of heart, these characters were still in conflict with one another. So with Doctor Zhivago, you similarly have a long movie presented on a grand scale, but then... I dunno, empathy is kind of static, and the interesting things in the margins stay in the margins, and the movie offers a somewhat anti-climactic conclusion?

If you asked me one reason why I liked Brief Encounter, then I would say that it was because I felt like the movie was able to capture internal emotional conflict—especially when it comes to romance and infidelity and the desire for the "other," etc.—better than maybe any movie ever has. We are fully immersed in a very flawed central character. So with Doctor Zhivago, you similarly have this story of a man who ostensibly has a big heart and makes the conscious decision to spread that love between two partners, and then... I dunno, they never really make a point of that, but just kind of leave it at "so Zhivago is going to be cheating on his wife finally, I guess," and then later, his wife saying "I met the other woman and I admit she seemed nice"? What?

If you are looking at Doctor Zhivago in the general, then these two quips might seem insignificant. But I'm looking at Doctor Zhivago compared to two specific films, helmed by the same director, films that I consider very, very special at this point. And in that specific comparison, Zhivago totally and utterly drops the ball. Maybe it's unfair to say "I didn't like this movie because it didn't explicitly cater to exactly the things that I liked about previous movies," but I can't help it. I was disappointed.

Maybe this is your first Lean film. Maybe you are coming into the movie completely free of preconceived notions. If you are, and you are able to hold your pee till at least intermission, than hey, who knows man, you might really like this one. I thought it was pretty decent in a general sense, and rather disappointing compared to what I've already seen.

GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Gotta convince Pam to watch Dreamgirls soon, because she'll fucking murder me if I watch it without her.

No comments: