Friday, April 30, 2021

From Under the Cork Tree, Joe


The idea that there is certain music I listened to at age sixteen and certain music I didn't listen to at age sixteen isn't necessarily unique to music listeners in general, and it's an idea that I've hashed and rehashed on this blog too many times already, including these hallowed Record Club halls specifically. So let's not do that again. We get it, brah—you were a fucking anti-emo snob, you are older now, you are freed from the burden of what "being cool" means, if it ever meant anything at all. Go forth and listen to Fall Out Boy like the rest of us.

I was reading a book about Radiohead's Kid A this week, and it happened to quote a particularly scathing Nick Hornby (the High Fidelity guy) review of the album, and it coincidentally attacked this idea of "being sixteen" from a different angle. Here is the except (originally from The New Yorker, October 2000; emphasis mine):
You have to work at albums like Kid A. You have to sit at home night after night and give yourself over to the paranoid millennial atmosphere as you try to decipher elliptical snatches of lyrics and puzzle out how the titles might refer to the songs. In other words, you have to be sixteen. Anyone old enough to vote may find that he has competing demands for his time—a relationship, say, or a job, or buying food, or listening to another CD he picked up on the same day. He may also find himself shouting at the CD player, "Shut up! You’re supposed to be a pop group!" (The music critics who love Kid A, one suspects, love it because their job forces them to consume music as a sixteen-year-old would. Don't trust any of them.) I suspect that people who have been listening to rock music for decades will have exhausted the fund of trust they once might have had for "challenging" albums. Kid A demands the patience of the devoted; both patience and devotion become scarcer commodities once you start picking up a paycheck.
Aside from being a shitty take on Kid A (which is not the greatest album of the aughts but is certainly much better than Hornby gave it credit for), and a pretty lazy take at that (and also, probably accidentally touching on the true reason why an average of 2.5 people participate in Record Club on any given week), I think this might, in a rather oblique way, touch on the general truth that there are certain albums that you can only truly appreciate at age sixteen, and if you try to get in on the fun after that age, you might find it impossible. I wonder if From Under the Cork Tree is one of those albums.

Okay, so the first like twelve times I listened to this album, it did absolutely nothing for me. I connected more with Pete Wentz via an Us Magazine article, in which he talks about that weird sense of losing your identity when you have a kid, than anything from this album. Eventually, I came to appreciate the pop/punk/emo hybrid that was prevalent in the mid-aughts ("Sugar, We're Goin Down Swinging" peaked at #6 on the Billboard Hot 100), because, I dunno, it's fun? A truth I could only learn in my 30s, apparently, that this type of music fucking slaps. But it still wasn't really hitting me deep down, ya know?

As Nick Hornby snarkily states, maybe I needed to get in touch with my sixteen-year-old self in order to become a true music critic. And so I listened to From Under the Cork Tree as a sixteen-year-old. It's harder than it sounds! It's tough to remember that sense of passion, the type that would inspire empathy with such lines as "I swear I'd burn this city down to show you the light," the type that you can only feel at age sixteen. It's kind of uncomfortable! It would be like going back and reading old Xanga posts. No one wants to do that shit. No album is worth that.

Because Nick Hornby was ultimately wrong when it comes to sixteen-year-olds—there's much more to being sixteen than a willingness to participate in the art of the album. There is also a potent mix of being inexperienced and a burning desire to be anything but. You get older, you gain more life experience, and you can't really unring the bell. You can't go back to being inexperienced. It doesn't fit well.

That's not to say that everyone is going to approach Fall Out Boy in the same way. There are plenty of people who are going to listen to From Under the Cork Tree and instantly be transported back to 2005, with Discmans on school buses, sitting next to your unspoken crush. This album, then, can be used as a bridge back to that time, if you want it to. If there are more than two Record Club reviews this week (unknown as of this writing), then this is why—From Under the Cork Tree was an album that people listened to back then, and sincerely enjoy listening to it now specifically because of that. And that's possibly the only reason.

(Look, we're about to wrap up here, so let's take one quick break and say that this week's deep listen of Fall Out Boy finally got me to look up what the fuck they meant by "I'll be your number one with a bullet." I assumed "with a bullet" was a widely used idiom, but apparently it's actually pretty specific. Billboard used to indicate "quickly rising songs" on the chart by putting a little picture of a bullet next to the song's title. So when Patrick Stump sings "I'll be your number one with a bullet," he's saying that he's going to be the most important person in your life, and it's going to happen really quickly. The idiom was popularized when whiny protagonist Rob says it in High Fidelity, because apparently everything is coming back to Nick Hornby this week.)

I'm usually pretty jealous when I listen to an album now that was very popular when I was sixteen but that I refused to listen to or enjoy when I was sixteen. I feel like I'm missing out on at least one layer of any potential enjoyment in the album. Because it's a very good album, very solid, lots of fun, catchy songs, and I wouldn't mind enjoying it even more. But then again, do I really want that? Do I really want the songs of Fall Out Boy soundtracking memories from when I was sixteen? Do I want to even remember age sixteen?

The very best I can do is try to be a sixteen-year-old as old man Nick Hornby imagines them—as someone who cares deeply about the music (even though we all know that music isn't the only thing that sixteen-year-olds have way too much time to think about). Just know that I can't possibly recommend this album to anyone; if you're the type of person who would actually benefit from the recommendation, then you know about the album already, and probably already unabashedly love it.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

No comments: