It's impossible for me to write a totally objective review of any Weird Al album. I've been sold ever since my cousin played Running with Scissors for me back in 1999. One of the first concerts I can remember buying a ticket for was Weird Al at the Keswick Theater. Weird Al was played at my bachelor party for reasons that deserve no further explanation. Nevertheless, though I am far from a neutral party, I cannot pass up an opportunity to talk about Mandatory Fun, which in all likelihood is the last full-length album we'll get from "Weird Al" Yankovic.
Mandatory Fun works for me on two levels. First, the album is funny as hell. Weird Al's humor has always had two defining characteristics: constantly escalating absurdity and an obsessive attention to detail. Both are what have distinguished Weird Al from other song parodists through the years, and both are present in spades on Mandatory Fun. "Tacky" alone provides a new joke about shitty, annoying, or otherwise cringeworthy behavior in nearly every line of the song, including the chorus. Upon first listen, "My Own Eyes" is indistinguishable from any regular Foo Fighters song; it's only given away by Al's high-pitched vocals and the insanity of the lyrics. "Foil" starts as an enjoyable, if unambitious, tribute to kitchenware before suddenly shifting into full-blown lunacy without ever changing the subject matter. "Mission Statement" is not laugh-out-loud funny, but succeeds by committing to the bit, pushing boring corporate jargon through a Crosby, Stills & Nash-style guitar riff and vocals until the whole situation becomes so silly that it's funny again. And in my opinion, "Word Crimes" not only far exceeds the song it's parodying, but could legitimately serve as a study aid to middle school English students.
To be fair, not every song on Mandatory Fun is an instant classic. "Sports Song" is fine as the logical conclusion of every ironic "I love sportsball!" joke I made in high school, but is way too broad to induce the laughter that "Tacky" or "Foil" drew out so easily. To casual listeners, "Inactive" may suffer because it's a parody of an Imagine Dragons song, but to die-hard fans "Inactive" comes off as a mere rehash of the underachiever-and-proud-of-it ethos Al perfected in "Fat" and "Couch Potato." The same issue plagues "First World Problems," a technically proficient facsimile of a Pixies song that is unable to escape the shadow of "Why Does This Always Happen to Me?," Al's underrated tribute to the entitlement and causal sociopathy of the average ugly American.
In my opinion, the song on Mandatory Fun that most perfectly combines Al's meticulous work ethic and trademark weirdness is the album's finale, "Jackson Park Express." Who but Weird Al could write, record and release a nine-minute Cat Stevens-style epic yarn in the year 2014? And who but Weird Al could have the narrator of the story fantasize about falling in love with a woman on a city bus, selling the woman his Hewlitt-Parkard printer, breaking into SeaWorld, and finally wearing his new love's skin over his skin, "but not in a creepy way?"
But beyond its humor, Mandatory Fun works on a second level as a time capsule for the year of pop culture it was released in. Listening to "Handy" was the first time I had thought about the existence of Iggy Azalea since at least 2015. In light of the entirely predictable backlash against Robin Thicke, "Word Crimes" may be the last acceptable reason to play the instrumentation from "Blurred Lines." The standard medley "Now That's What I Call Polka!" provides a fun little intermission halfway through the album and also an accordion-heavy portal into what we as a nation were listening to in 2014. But the song that struck me hardest in the nostalgia center was "Foil." Not only because I heard Lorde on the radio hundreds of times while working night shift from 2013-14, but because the hard left turn the song takes into tin-foil hat territory harkens back to a simpler time when conspiracy theories like black helicopters and the New World Order were silly distractions and not the basis for a mob to storm the Capitol.
(I love 2018's "Hamilton Polka," but my favorite Weird Al polka medley is the "Angry White Boy Polka" on 2003's Poodle Hat. I dare you to listen to Weird Al's cheerful cover of "Last Resort" and "Chop Suey" and not crack a smile.)
Weird Al said after Mandatory Fun's release that he intends to stick to singles and EPs in order to produce music faster. Consequently, Mandatory Fun is probably the last traditional album he'll ever put out. If this is his last full album, I'm glad he went out on a high note. I would hesitate to call it Weird Al's "masterpiece," because it's not a perfect album, and in a larger sense calling Mandatory Fun a masterpiece implicitly devalues the rest of Al's astonishing 40-year career. However, I can guarantee that you will have fun listening to it, whether you want to or not.

No comments:
Post a Comment