Monday, April 12, 2021

Never Seen It, #44 of 200: The Deer Hunter

Welcome to Never Seen It, where we're watching 200 movies from an alphabetical list, all of which I've never seen before (hence the name). In my opinion, it's probably time to start getting serious about this project... then again, it is Oscar season. Okay, on April 26th, I swear I'm going to get serious about this project.


The Deer Hunter
1978

This is probably going to be one of those Never Seen It entries in which I piece together paragraphs about what I liked and paragraphs about what I didn't like, which seems pedestrian to me, but I'll do it anyway because I have nothing really unique to add to the general conversation about this 43-year-old movie that hasn't already been discussed before today. I mean, I could also tack on the obligatory "here's what I expected, and here's how it did / did not match those expectations," which seems not only pedestrian but also self-centered (which is worse). Then again, if you didn't come to Puke on Your Birthday to read Joe K***'s essays about me me me, then why exactly are you here? (Answer: to learn the correct spelling of yoghurt.)

What I expected out of The Deer Hunter was some macho treatise on war. That's what I always expect when I watch a war movie, honestly—lots of explosions and MEN being MANLY MEN and lots of shooting 'em up because it's BADASS and so on—even though I can't say I've seen enough war movies that are like this that my expectations would even be logical. Like, clearly the Venn Diagram of people with the means to create a major motion picture and people who support the military industrial complex is two completely separate circles.

I dunno, maybe setting up unreasonably low expectations for a film such as The Deer Hunter is my way of manufacturing a scenario in which I like the movie a lot more than I ever thought I would. If I think that there's no way I'm going to like a three-hour film in the "war drama" category, then it's much more likely that I'm going to like it, because there's very little chance it won't greatly exceed those expectations. Suffice it to say: I really liked The Deer Hunter.

It's not even enough to explain my appreciation for the film by saying that it "wasn't a typical war movie." My enjoyment more stemmed from the weird truth that The Deer Hunter was barely a war movie at all. The "war" aspect of it—i.e. scenes that specifically took place in a war zone setting (specifically Vietnam)—took up only about a third of the film's runtime, and overall seemed a lot less integral to The Deer Hunter than all the scenes that took place before and after.

To be clear, I appreciated this unique structure of the film. I loved that we spent so much time with the characters prior to being shipped off to war. The second most popular argument about The Deer Hunter I've seen online (we'll get to the most popular argument at some point) is whether it was necessary to spend 51 minutes following the group of guys through their bender of a wedding reception. I'm less concerned with whether it was "necessary"—though, sure, I'll argue it was necessary to get a sense of who these guys were, so that we could see who they became after the war—and more concerned with whether it was enjoyable to watch. It was. I could've watched a three-hour wedding sequence, honestly.

And that's even considering the fact that it was made quite obvious what the movie was hoping to achieve with this extended prologue. I wasn't watching the first hour of The Deer Hunter thinking that this was going to be a fun romp through the lives of a rowdy group of friends in the suburbs of Pittsburgh. It was made very explicit that the shoe was going to drop eventually. See, for instance, the almost eye-roll-inducing scene when the new bride and groom are drinking the cup together, and the priest says "If nothing spills, you'll have luck for the rest of your life," and the camera zooms in super-close on drops of red wine hitting the bride's dress.

Still, despite its obviousness, I was content to hang out with these characters for as long as they'd have me, and to me, that makes a film great. Another example might be that long coastal scene toward the end of the prologue, when the camera is zoomed out real far, and the guys are messing around with their buddy John, doing the thing where they say "get in!" and then drive away when he reaches for the door handle. Some people might consider such a scene "unnecessary." Some people might see it and know that later on, the same thing is going to happen, but it's going to feel a lot more juvenile because it's happening after the horrors of war have changed our characters. I found myself part of the latter group for sure, but I also was just happy to see these guys happy and goofing around for as long as possible.

When the good times ended, they ended abruptly. I mean, it was literally a smash cut from the guys drinking one last beer together at the bar to U.S. soldiers blowing up of young children with a grenade. The whiplash was intentional, and effective. It may have been obvious that the shoe was going to drop, but man, that shoe hit hard.

So that was interesting. Also interesting was the fact that the war scenes were not ones you'd typically see in this kind of movie. There was no talk of military strategy. There were no orders from chains of command. If "heroics" were performed, then they were of the grimmest variety. Basically, the whole deal with the guys in 'Nam is that they are captured by the Viet Cong, who force them to participate in a game of Russian Roulette.

Here's where I kind of lose a fraction of interest in The Deer Hunter, especially when the guys survive but Nick is so shell-shocked by what he's been through that he continues to voluntarily play Russian Roulette as an extended form of suicide. It's such an over-the-top "game"—pointing a gun at your head while crowds of screaming people bet on your survival—that it kind of takes one out of the film at times. Anything to do with Russian Roulette lacks the gravitas of everything that is going on back in Clairton, Pennsylvania.

I know, I know, Russian Roulette is a metaphor, man. It's supposed to symbolize how violence in general during the Vietnam War was also senseless and unnecessary, and yet we asked our young men to participate anyway. Director Michael Cimino has gone on record in saying that the metaphor is so important that film isn't really even about the Vietnam War at all, but more about how gruesome rituals force us to change as we grow up. I get it, and I understand that The Deer Hunter's main source of conflict and change comes from the characters' unwilling participation in the ritual, but I'm just saying that I think it was a bit too extreme and nonsensical for it to truly be effective.

I am not saying that The Deer Hunter would've been more effective if it was content to forget about Nick as opposed to following up on his roulette adventures (mostly because I am not a filmmaker and have no say in the matter), but I will say that I definitely appreciated a lot more the quiet pain of Michael when he returned from war. The slow, sad courtship with Linda, the inability to reconnect with his old pals, the fact that he never seems to take off his military uniform, it all adds up to the fact that Mike is irrevocably changed by his experiences.

The Deer Hunter does a wonderful job portraying all this, and giving life to that old idea that "things will never be the same." No one reading this has ever been in overseas combat (I'm assuming), but we've all been in situations where we return home from some life-changing event, only to find that home feels different, somehow. You've changed, you've outgrown where you came from. It's a weird feeling! And this film does a really good job of showing that depressing realization. Whether you thought that the world's saddest rendition of "God Bless America" was ironic or sincere (my 2021 instincts tell me that it can't possibly be the latter), it definitely lays it plain that all of these characters feel it too—nothing will ever be the same.

So I guess if I were to sum up my feelings about The Deer Hunter, I'd say that I really like it despite the fact that I found the central literary device to be a bit too preposterous for my personal tastes, and that I more liked it because of all the beautiful melancholy that our characters found around the margins of that device. The film did an excellent job of making it seem like these were real, relatable people, living in a real town, living out a very real sorrow, even though, yes, everything changed because some of them were forced to point a gun to their own heads and pull the trigger. I am a very forgiving movie critic, and I found enough to love in the Clairton scenes that I can easily forgive anything happening in the Vietnam scenes. Good movie.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Who's Involved

I try to make it a habit of avoiding reading anything about a movie before I sit down to watch it, even basic information like the cast and crew involved. Honestly, it makes the opening credits kind of exciting for me, like: "Holy shit, he's in this?" and so on. I also get pretty excited when I do not recognize the director's name, because 1) I have no expectations, unlike, say, a Scorsese, and 2) I know that I'm gonna be able to learn about this guy (or girl!) afterward, and see what else he had in store for audiences (especially if I liked the movie and want to watch more).

So I was pretty disappointed to learn that Michael Cimino doesn't seem to have much else worth watching. I mean, I could probably see myself watching Heaven's Gate at some point, which I learned today was the follow-up to Deer Hunter and an infamous box office bomb, pretty much ruining Cimino's career. I wouldn't mind seeing whether it lives up to the anti-hype, or if it was unfairly maligned in its time. But yeah man, it's a bummer that he has apparently never repeated his breakout film's success.

I did know that DeNiro was in this film, so that wasn't a surprise. Here's a surprise, though (and it's going to sound silly, because I've actually seen a lot of DeNiro movies at this point): this was probably the first time I've ever seen this actor perform and go "goddamn, he is a good actor." I know that plenty of people think that he is a generational talent, but The Deer Hunter was the first time I felt that, you know? He was just on a different level here.

That I didn't feel that way about Christopher Walken, who is the only actor to win an Oscar for The Deer Hunter, I think speaks more to what he was working with than his talents. I've already gone through my feelings about the Russian Roulette thing from a plot perspective, and I can imagine it was tough to act through all that nonsense. The Academy obviously felt that he did a better job than I felt, though, so what the fuck do I know?

I'll also say that I Meryl Streep's subpar performance had to do with her role than her abilities as an actor—the character of Linda was a bit undercooked, in my opinion. I am far less familiar with Meryl Streep than I am with DeNiro and Walken, and maybe it's because I only know Streep as the "elder statesman" that she is today, but her performance as Linda seemed a little... light? I dunno. I always picture Streep as being grounded and wizened with age (I guess is the best way to put it), and it felt weird watching this young, somewhat airy performance. This will be more interesting to talk about when I watch The Devil Wears Prada in a few weeks.

Here's a piece of trivia that movie buffs will already be aware of: John Cazale, who plays Stan in this film, only acted in five movies before he succumbed to cancer, and all five of those films were nominated for Best Picture at the Oscars (three of them won, including this one). The Deer Hunter was his final film (and in fact, they had to shoot all his scenes first just in case). The role of Stan isn't nearly as weighty as The Godfather's Fredo, but he still does a great job here. It's a shame that such a career was cut so short.
 
~~~~~~~~~~~
 
Does It Hold Up?
 
There's a pretty obvious aspect of this film that I'll admit, I didn't even think about as I was watching it, which is more of a failure on my part than a failure of The Deer Hunter. Apparently this was pretty hotly contested at the time, and is just as contested now when discussing the film—does The Deer Hunter's portrayal of the North Vietnamese constitute as racism?
 
Forgetting about whether I even have the right to see both sides of this, I do indeed see both sides of this. On the one hand, North Vietnamese characters are definitely portrayed, both specific and in groups, as sadistic killers, to the point of parody. That's for both the soldier in war, and the civilians cheering on Nick's volunteered participation—if you're a N. Vietnamese character in this film, you are bloodthirsty and violent and cheer death, and yeah, I could see how that would be racist.

On the other hand, I don't even think that you could call anyone of Vietnamese descent a "character" in this film at all. Everyone's participation in the game of Russian Roulette is all part of the overarching metaphor that the film is attempting to make—war is senseless, life is senseless, this shit can change you. The Deer Hunter gives no character shading to any Vietnamese characters because that's not really the point the film is trying to make. It's not trying to say that the North Vietnamese are a violent people, because it's not saying anything about the North Vietnamese at all.

Now, if you want to take issue with the fact that it was the North Vietnamese culture that was chosen as a backdrop to these violent, intense interactions, whereas it really could've been anyone or anything, then I guess I can't argue with you. Especially because there was no reason for it other than the fact that the U.S. had just pulled out of the war five years prior to the movie's release, so it was still on everyone's mind. Like, there's no historical accuracy in saying that the Viet Cong or the North Vietnamese have ever played Russian Roulette, traditionally, at all. (Cimino claimed at one point he had newspaper clippings that proved this did happen during the Vietnam War, but he never backed that claim up, and it smells like bullshit.)

The last point is probably what set people off originally—since this never actually happened, then it's perceived as racist that this very specific backdrop was chosen for this violent activity. I get it. I am of the overall inclination to allow people to express their grievances when it comes to art and the portrayal of cultures and races and peoples. To even be able to watch this movie and not think about any of this once is a sure sign of my own privilege.

So I say this tepidly and only to make my own opinion clear—I think calling The Deer Hunter "racist" is completely missing the point of this work of fiction. But I also acknowledge that I am a straight white male and so what the fuck right do I have to say about any of this otherwise, and etc.

~~~~~~~~~~~~

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Is Despicable Me's depiction of Minions another act of racism? Stay tuned to find out, right here on Puke on Your Birthday.

No comments: