Thursday, April 8, 2021

Song of the Day: "Unpleasant Breakfast"


"Unpleasant Breakfast"
The Hold Steady
from Open Door Policy
2021

You should first know that I've been listening to a lot of the Hold Steady's new album since it came out about a month and a half ago. I've listened to it enough to know that it's going to end up in my Top Five Albums of 2021, possibly nipping at #1 (depending on how the rest of the year goes). But you already would have assumed that, knowing how I feel about the Hold Steady.

What we're actually here today to discuss is a really interesting point that our sister blog Fatter, Older brought up a month ago. Here's the blog post. I'm not addressing the whole thing—I've already expressed my disdain for point #4 in the comments, and re:#2, the subject of Separation Sunday vs. Boys and Girls in America is an important one but not necessarily a unique one. No, let's talk about Journey.

Are the Hold Steady following the same path as Journey? Jeez, it's a scary thought. And I should say first off that Nate indicates he is not making such an argument, that the Journey comparison "doesn't apply" to the Hold Steady. But I'm here to ask—what if we applied it anyway? Does it work? Hopefully not!

Such a comparison would shake me to my core, because Journey sucks ass, right? I mean, I know that's not an unequivocal fact, and more of an opinion shared by anyone younger than Boomer-aged. It's an opinion that has a basis in fact—Journey hasn't released good music either: 1) ever, or 2) since whatever their big hits in the early '80s, "Don't Stop Believin'" and... other stuff I guess?

And yet they still exist, and they still prosper, and they can still command large ticket sales even if their entire career and livelihood is based around a song that is now officially 40 years old. The assumption, if I can extrapolate from my own (and other fatter/older) opinions, is that Journey are a bunch of has-beens, and their fans in 2021 are a bunch of fucking suckers.

The fear is that I, as a Hold Steady fan, am just another sucker of a different color. If you asked me my opinion about the Hold Steady in 2021, I'd say that, yeah, sure, they "peaked" with their best album/songs in the mid-'00s, but their output since has been more than worthy of admiration. I won't say that Open Door Policy will ever be as good as Boys and Girls in America, but it's a lot closer than it has any right to be. But: am I just as delusional as a Journey fan? Do I love latter-day HS albums because I loved their earlier output so goddamn much?

I think it might be worth trying to figure out whether Journey fans actually like/liked latter-day Journey albums. If they were poorly reviewed and received, then we can probably rest a bit easier. But if there are a bunch of Journey fans going around saying "Generations is almost as good as Escape!!", then maybe we should start getting worried that I'm falling into the same trap.

I'm not gonna go too deep into it, but I clicked around RateYourMusic.com's Journey page for a little bit. 2008's Revelation actually has a higher score than Escape (the one with the big hits), by a few hundredths of a point, but only about a quarter of the number of reviews. Reading through the reviews, a lot of them are like "Journey in 2008, it's better than expected," which to me seems like a low bar to cross.

But isn't that the same bar that the Hold Steady is crossing in 2021? There might be plenty of people today saying "Hey, Open Door Policy was much better than it had any right to be." To my ears, it cleared the hurdle and then some, but maybe I'm just hearing what I want to hear, I don't know.

I think you also have to consider the fact that Journey, at its peak, was exponentially more popular than the Hold Steady at its own respective peak. Even if you don't know who sings it, every single person on earth knows "Don't Stop Believin'." If I wore my Hold Steady T-shirt to work and polled 50 coworkers, there would maybe be one who had even heard of them, and that's a big assumption. So there's not as much pressure to put out quality material for Journey, because even a middling new release isn't going to shed a significant amount of fans. A (theoretical) disappointing Hold Steady album might convince a larger percentage of their respective fan base to tune out. Because (and I have no evidence to back this up) the fans of the Hold Steady are more likely to take new music into their opinions about the band; Journey's fans have known the score for decades, and are much less concerned.

I'm also thinking about generational changes. There had to have been critical champions of Journey in their heyday, just as there were for the Hold Steady in theirs. But Journey's heyday was 40 years ago, and so a lot of those critical champions are no longer writing about music (or dead). The critics that I grew up with were fans of Hold Steady, and still are. So they—like me—are going to be a lot more effusive toward a new Hold Steady record today. We may not know whether the Hold Steady is anything like Journey for another twenty years—assuming that we can go to Union Transfer in 2041 and see Craig Finn and the boys bash out "Constructive Summer" at that point still.

The final point I'll touch on is the point where Fatter, Older and PoYB diverge furthest in their Hold Steady takes. "Journey being the band that, when I was coming up as a teen, served as the example of past-their-prime rockers serving an aging audience their youth right back to them." The implication being that the Hold Steady either is or could be something like that too, and that would be pretty sad if it was / ever were the case.

However, I think the magic of the Hold Steady has always been that they've been that band, purposefully, since their inception. Journey was the same age as their audience when they had the audacity to claim they'd never stop believin'. The Hold Steady was always a little older, a little wiser than their audience. They served the audience's youth right back to them while the audience was young, and the fact that we are getting older (and fatter) shouldn't mean that we have to hold that against the band. Journey needed to turn into that type of band to survive, and we see that as pathetic; the Hold Steady were never not that band, and so we see their service-to-youth as an asset.

Really, any change in opinion regarding the Hold Steady says more about us and our growing aversion to the very idea of "nostalgia" than it does about the band themselves. In the Hold Steady, I see consistency. They have always been, to me, the band that was able to allude to the fact that I was living "the best years of my life" before I even came to that conclusion myself. And regardless of the general consensus of Open Door Policy being that it's good or great or amazing or whatever, I think the Hold Steady deserve the golden parachute landing anyway.

Like Nate, I grew up resenting classic rock bands such as Journey. But now that my fear of becoming a fanboy of an aging band has come to pass, and a comparison to Journey fans looks more warranted year after year, I am finding that there is a comfort in that too. I know what I like. And if liking one of my favorite bands and loving their new output means that generations younger than me will come to resent me for it, than I accept the decision.

No comments: