I made the mistake of visiting the man's Instagram page. Seeing a picture of Cautious Clay holding his album Deadpan Love and talking about how much work and love he put into creating his first album just about made me the saddest person on earth. Because there is nothing sadder than a human being doing something that they clearly love and also being bad at that thing.
A harsh opinion for sure. Is it a fair opinion? I don't know, probably not. As always, you can blame it on me if you need to. I don't "get it" or whatever. That's fine. If we were being objective, I would try to explain Cautious Clay in a way that acknowledged the fact that a lot of people really enjoy this kind of thing. But I don't believe in objectivity in music criticism. I'm trying to get better at not feeding the impulse to undercut my opinions when I find that they are skewing negative.
When I hate something, I try to hide behind objectivity. These are real people creating something that, in their minds, adds to the general health and welfare of the human race. I'm a pissant and I don't want to be the pre-ratatouille Anton Ego who moves through art like a vampire, sucking the worth out of a well-meaning piece of work for sport.
Complicating the proceedings is the fact that most weeks of Record Club begin with a friend saying that they already really like this music that they are sharing with the rest of the group. Me saying that, no, that music actually sucks, without being insulting about it, is a really hard needle to thread, especially as someone who loves my friends and is so incredibly thankful when one of them deigns to share a piece of their happiness with a miserable shitbird like myself.
Complicating the proceedings is the fact that most weeks of Record Club begin with a friend saying that they already really like this music that they are sharing with the rest of the group. Me saying that, no, that music actually sucks, without being insulting about it, is a really hard needle to thread, especially as someone who loves my friends and is so incredibly thankful when one of them deigns to share a piece of their happiness with a miserable shitbird like myself.
So while I don't want to be a coward this week and make any equivocations—I did not like Deadpan Love very much—I do think that the temperate-skewing-potent dislike I felt throughout this past week is worth exploring. A shortcut in this process would be insulting to all those involved in the machinations that led me to spending the week with Cautious Clay.
The easiest way to explain it is to talk about the "algorithm," and what that means exactly. There are two ways of looking at that term. The first is algorithm as a function. I already discussed this in the OK Go review. There exists in the digital universe a grand tracking system that tracks everything about you, all the data that exists in the 1s and 0s that spawn from your clicks and likes, and formulates an equation that is able to at least somewhat accurately predict what type of music you'll want to listen to next. If you're listening to this, then the algorithm will be able to tell you to listen to that.
The other way to describe the term is algorithm as an aesthetic, and it is this second definition that I use to describe Cautious Clay's album. I tend to use "algorithm" as a quasi-synonym for "bland," basically. A computer can't actually know what you want to listen to, because it isn't sentient (hopefully!). But in attempting to compute what you want to listen to anyway, it more often than not ends up just providing watered down bullshit versions of the music that you're already familiar with. Streaming services like Spotify use an algorithm to create "personalize playlists just for you," which are "based on your listening habits," and these playlists are a barren wasteland for art. It's so bad that millions of people are out there listening to bands that don't even fucking exist because they are so accustomed to being spoon-fed this generic, algorithm-induced sound.
So when someone like Cautious Clay is described as having "music for the algorithm," then it's not talking about the literal act of predicting music listening behavior. It is actually designed as an critique. Cautious Clay's music is so generic that it could be (and most likely is) featured on a Spotify algorithm "personalized" playlist.
There's a significant chance that I am using this description as a fancy way of saying that the songs from Deadpan Love just aren't landing with me, and if that's the case, then I'm sorry for wasting your time. Like, what does "this song sounds generic" even mean? All music begins to sound the same together anyway, right? That could be a "me" thing again. If I've never heard a low-key bedroom-style R&B song before, then maybe Deadpan Love is sounding fresh to my ears. But that's not where I'm at. I've heard enough of this cheap, mass-produced hip-hop-inflected pop music to know that nothing about this—not a single goddamn second of this album—sounds new in any sense of the word. Thus: generic.
I don't harbor any suspicions that Cautious Clay is purposefully out there trying to dupe his fans. When he says on Instagram that he put his heart and soul into creating Deadpan Love, I believe him. But what this means is that he put everything he had into his art, and this is what transpired. That just about breaks my heart.
Again: who the fuck am I; at least he is creating something he himself enjoys; etc. etc. Plus, the dude is getting a small portion of Taylor Swift's significantly large paycheck from that one songwriting credit, so if anyone is going to cry that some shit blog called his music "generic" then he can cry all the way to the bank.
And also: maybe we should consider that last point to be the ultimate point of this whole endeavor. Maybe there is a place for mundanity in music. After all, Cautious Clay created a generic song, and the biggest pop star on the planet used that song to create something all her own, something that was not generic ("London Boy" is still bad, but it ain't generic). Maybe that's what Clay is doing on Deadpan Love, consciously attempting to recreate that success by making more of the most generic shit imaginable and hoping that it magically morphs via the Great Pop Music Machine into something unique, thus padding Clay's wallet in the process.
I wondered if this was the case with Vulfpeck a few months ago, and I think it could apply here, theoretically. I still don't like it—it feels a lot more like that first definition of "algorithm," like music should exist to serve some capitalistic function—but I get that it exists. It makes sense, logically. Think about how much money Stevie Wonder has in his bank account just from prominent samples in '90s hits "Gangsta's Paradise" and "Wild Wild West" alone. It makes sense that people would try to reverse engineer that success, creating bland music in service of a hypothetical future sampling. I fucking despise the idea of it—those fake Spotify bands make me sick to my fucking stomach—but I understand the thought process. The ideal with music is that it aspires to be art; the reality with music is that it has always been run by uncreative bloodsucking money men who will cut any corner necessary to make a buck, art be damned.
I'm not saying Cautious Clay is definitely a bloodsucking vampire, even though I've alluded to it twice now. I'm just saying it's a possibility, and it would at least explain the existence of such a vapid display of anti-talent.
At the end of the day, I think there is a better way to more gently make my opinions clear, without hurling any more unwarranted insults. I can couch my dislike in a compliment. Here it is: I think what the song "Roots" has to say is interesting, and I'm glad the song exists. "Roots" is ostensibly about a relationship that is ending, but what it's actually about how difficult it is to admit that two people are not right for each other. I think there are better ways to handle the topic musically, but I can't deny that it got me thinking about that truth, about how we strive for human connection all our lives and sometimes it's just not possible.
Really, the best thing it did was give me an out when it came to Deadpan Love. Here is my permission slip. It's okay to not connect with anything Cautious Clay is doing musically or personally here. Sometimes things just don't work out. "You say you're gonna leave / gotta clean house." I am definitely going to leave; I am definitely going to clean house. And that's okay! Me and Cautious Clay were not meant for each other! Let us both do our best to accept this and to move on.
Usually, when I find myself not connecting with a Record Club album, I'll spend a whole day, either Tuesday or Wednesday, playing it over and over and over. I had to do that one day this week. I tried. Hours wasted, though. I might as well have been listening to Willow's white noise machine. That's what happens when you're part of the algorithm.
GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment