Steal all of the songs you wanna steal HERE.
"Convinced I'm Wrong"
Polar Bear Club
from Sometimes Things Just Disappear
2008
We do a lot of self-mythologizing on this blog, but maybe the problem with that is that not all the stories that we remember were as exciting, preposterous, or legendary as we need them to be to fuel the retelling. That's okay. The retelling is the fun part. It doesn't necessarily have to be that crazy of a night for you to hold onto the memory. The beauty is why you remember it, and how you relay the story to those who were or were not there to witness it firsthand.
Something like a banner being stolen from a college off-campus house is not what you'd call an uncommon occurrence. Shit's stolen from college flophouses every day. It's the reason I had a padlock on my bedroom door when I lived in one. But under the right circumstances, that theft can become the stuff of lore.
Those circumstances? Well, first, the victim of the theft has to be an important person in your life, and he has to be notorious for overreacting in public settings (i.e. social media). Second, the theft has to be a true mystery, because the solution to the mystery and how that solution came to be is also part of the lore. Third, random happenstance a decade later needs to underline the memory, mark it as important, by total accident.
Let us know explore these circumstances in specifics. Let us now tell the tale of Kev's Stolen Polar Bear Club Banner.
To set the scene: during the 2010-2011 academic year at La Salle University, four young men lived in an off-campus house colloquially known as "Woodstock." It was called this because the house was located on North Philadelphia's Woodstock Street. We were not the only house on the block populated with Lasallian students, but I didn't party at any of the other houses often enough that we needed a better clarifying nomenclature.
One of those young men was Kev, who requires no introduction on PoYB, as he is a constant presence on this blog (despite not being a contributor). A relatively important thing to note here is that Kev was not, and has never been, a student at La Salle University. He just wanted to move out of his parents house after getting a full-time job, and decided that the best way to do that was to move into a college house with some friends. This adds to the humor of the situation, in my opinion.
We decorated the home as any young adults might—random movie posters, school newspaper clippings, knickknacks from thrift stores, a gigantic painting of Dwyer dressed a pirate, you know, the usual adornments of not-quite-yet-adults who are male and who are renting the place temporarily. One of the crown jewels was Kev's Polar Bear Club banner. PBC was an emo band from the late '00s and early '10s that Kev (and Dave, and Mike, etc.) liked a lot. The poster was in the style of the classic Pabst Blue Ribbon logo. This elevated the banner from cool (depending on how you felt about the band) to THE COOLEST. We liked beer, and this was a banner alluding to that fact.
We decorated the home as any young adults might—random movie posters, school newspaper clippings, knickknacks from thrift stores, a gigantic painting of Dwyer dressed a pirate, you know, the usual adornments of not-quite-yet-adults who are male and who are renting the place temporarily. One of the crown jewels was Kev's Polar Bear Club banner. PBC was an emo band from the late '00s and early '10s that Kev (and Dave, and Mike, etc.) liked a lot. The poster was in the style of the classic Pabst Blue Ribbon logo. This elevated the banner from cool (depending on how you felt about the band) to THE COOLEST. We liked beer, and this was a banner alluding to that fact.
We had parties most weekends, as young rent-paying college-aged drinkers are wont to do. It's tough to remember all the parties, since it's been so long and it's not like we were trying to remember that much on those particular nights anyway. I'd say that, for the most part, we knew the people entering our house for a party. These were our friends, or at the very least friends-of-friends. These weren't open-house, five-dollars-a-cup affairs. Just friends hanging out, drinking beers, hiding from the cops, all that good stuff.
So I guess it was slightly less understandable when something went missing around the house, since these were our friends—the people we cared about—committing the petty crime. I'll grant Kev that; injustice hurts, no matter the size. But at the same time—and maybe this is just the weight of perspective and maturity speaking—it's also kind of funny, when an incident like this occurs. It's not like anyone ever broke into a locked bedroom and stole cash out of the sock drawer. This was basically a house decoration we're talking about. It would be akin to stealing a potted plant. Wrong? Sure. Worth getting upset over? I don't know. Probably not.
Well, Kev being Kev, of course got very upset about it:
![]() |
| click to enlarge |
Gotta love the all-caps Facebook timeline yelling. The thing that confuses me the most about this is the timestamp. I could've sworn this happened earlier in the year, but Facebook is claiming that it occurred toward the very end of the year, in April 2011. Though maybe I'm conflating two different incidents. Was there something earlier in the year? Wasn't the Miley Cyrus poster stolen too? If it was, I don't remember how that one was resolved, or if it ever was (though don't worry, it too lives on in memory).
No, Kev is not wrong in being upset that his favorite Polar Bear Club banner was stolen out of the house in which he resided. But because of the infamous Facebook status, there was also much merriment and ball-busting made out of the matter. By going over the top with it, Kev turned a shitty situation into a hilarious situation. It's the reason we're still talking about it today.
But I couldn't for the life of me remember who had performed the actual stealing the banner. The memory of an angry Kev on the internet was clouding my memory about how the mystery was solved. For some reason, I thought that maybe PoYB contributor Rachel C. has something do with it. I couldn't remember specifics, but I had an inkling that it was connected to her crew in some way, possibly her cohort Jill N. (though maybe I just thought that because I've always said Jill looks like Miley Cyrus, so maybe that's me conflating the two stories again). I reached out.
Rachel: "I remember the incident and both of us being implicated, but it was definitely neither of us. Mostly going off of memory that we never had the stolen banner hanging anywhere or talked about it amongst us or our friends. I remember the drama though! ... I can ask Jill, but I really don't remember taking this. Especially because Kev's room was like locked or off limits during parties? Or maybe I'm misremembering."
I'm glad I'm not the only one who is starting to have trouble remembering shit that happened back in college. I do have to clarify one thing at this point, though. I do not remember if Kev's door was locked during parties or at all. (I have to assume no, since there was a separate running joke in the house in which Kev would find a very specific piece of trash, like this little strip of plastic or something, under his pillow every day, and he would get frustrated and throw the piece of debris into the hallway, and every day I would find this piece of debris and place it back under his pillow.) But I specifically remember that the Polar Bear Club banner was hung in the hallway, not a bedroom.
Okay, so, it was time to ask Kev about it, here in 2022. Kev, who stole the PBC banner?
Kev: "I think her name was Emily? I'd know the last name if I heard it."Joe: "P*********?"Kev: "That's it. I caught her because she had it in the background of one of her Facebook pictures back then. Then it 'showed up' folded in a plastic Fresh Grocer bag in our bathroom closet."
I fucking love it. Like, knowing how Kev reacts to this type of thing, just imagine his reaction when he saw that FB picture. Just picture him eight Miller Lite indented cans deep going fucking apoplectic. It's very amusing. And it's also very amusing to picture Emily sneaking back into the house to return the banner, after Kev had banned her.
The next step was to reach out to Emily P., of course. This proved a little tricky, since I hadn't seen her in at least nine years. I remember running into her when I was working a Zipcar event at Drexel, but radio silence since then. I reached out to Rachel C. again. It doesn't sound like they hang around together too often anymore either, but Rachel had enough mutual contacts that she was able to give me a list of potential phone numbers.
(I should sneak in another clarification here: there have been a few Emilys mentioned on this blog throughout the years, but as far as I remember, this is a completely separate Emily. The Emily in question here is not, for instance, the Emily that succinctly summed up the very idea of blogging in one cutting comment.)
One of the numbers worked! I tried to be delicate about it, because the very act of communicating about this specific subject after all the many years that have passed was... very weird. I acknowledged that from the start of our conversation. I apologized for reaching out about a subject so dumb that I wouldn't have been surprised had been completely ignored.
Emily was game for a while to answer some questions. I have reprinted our brief text exchange below (edited for clarity and to hold back one of my cards that I will reveal farther down in this blog post):
Joe: "So I write a lot as a hobby, just throw shit on a blog. Nothing crazy, no books or anything like that. So this exchange is low key. [I've been thinking recently about how] I should write about the whole story about when Kev got his banner stolen. I asked Kev and he said you were involved in this. Haha. Not asking in an accusatory was [sic]. Definitely being lighthearted here. It's sincerely one of my funniest memories from that year. But I want to get the side of the alleged perpetrator of this crime!"Emily: "LMAO!!! Oh geez... that is too funny. God, I know it was me and Jill, and we thought we were hilarious."Joe: "Remember anything specific about the process? Just a cool banner to steal or something more than that?"Emily: "Let me think about it. I think we stole it because there was a vendetta between Kev and Jill. I do remember Kev being soooooo unusually upset about us stealing it."Joe: "To your second point, haha yes he was livid. That's what made it so funny. Here's his FB status the next day: [shared the pic from above].Emily: "That is so funny. I was trying to find the picture that he saw of us on Facebook that let him know we took it."Joe: "But wait, what was the vendetta between him and Jill?"Emily: "I think it started as drunken banter that was meaningless. I'm trying to go deep in my memory archives."Joe: "Let me know if you find the picture though! That is hilarious that he saw a pic of it on Facebook. Did he contact you when he saw it or something?"Emily: "Yea! So Jill and I posted a picture of us in our dorm sometime later and the banner was unknowingly in the background. He commented on the picture basically accusing us stealing it (which we did)."Joe: "I love the fact that you stole it and hung it up in your own dorm room."Emily: "I remember we were banned from the house and we were trying to find ways to bring it back in the house without him knowing."Joe: "Didn't it end up in our bathroom or something?"
And that was the last I heard from Emily. Look, did I want to eventually get a look at that picture with the PBC banner in the background? Sure. Did I want to learn as much as I could from probably the most important figure in this story? Of course. But I'm also well aware of the fact that texting someone about a dumb incident that happened a decade ago, one that nobody can remember fully, is kind of a bother! I refuse to be a pain in the ass, even under blogging circumstances. This will most likely be the final time I ever talk with Emily, unless life has something else in store in the distant future. If there is a random run-in at a supermarket in the year 2047, you can bet your ass I'm going to bring up the PBC banner.
Because coincidences happen. They happen all the time. Sometimes people conflate the idea of "coincidence" with the idea of "fate," and I get it. You want to believe that there is meaning in this world, that our lives aren't just made up of an endless series of random occurrences. Telling stories about times gone by is one way that we attempt the precious alchemy of happenstance into legend. It's what I'm attempting now, even though I know that it's all random, that, in the general scope of our lives, one minor theft doesn't account for much.
And yet, you tell me if this really was random, or if it was fate: late in December 2021, the official Pabst Blue Ribbon Twitter account posted this tweet:
![]() |
| click to enlarge |
The tweet hit me like a fucking bullet to the skull. It came out of nowhere. It's not like I follow PBR on Twitter or whatever. This was just a random promoted tweet. And here they were, the official online marketing arm of Pabst Blue Ribbon, tweeting the pun "sometimes things just disabeer" with a picture of the very same banner that had disappeared from our home a decade previous.
I had no idea how to react to this. I thought that I must be going crazy, because each scenario was more preposterous than the last. What, was this particular banner notorious for being stolen out of off-campus houses all over the nation? Was the Woodstock House privy to just one incident in a long line of PBC banner thefts? Or did we know the person who ran the PBR account? Did Kev get a new job, having finally gotten sick of the insurance career that afforded him a spot in Woodstock in the first place? Did Jill hack into the account and post this tweet in a brilliant move in her and Kev's still-ongoing chess match of wits? Am I having a stroke?
The only reasonable course of action I could think of taking was direct messaging Pabst Blue Ribbon and asking them about the tweet. Was it fate that led them to tweet what they tweeted? Because it was tough to imagine a coincidence this large.
No response, obviously. But that didn't deter me. I needed to know what the fuck is happening here. The next course of action is probably the one I should have taken in 2010, when Kev so liked a band that he spent probably too much money on a banner to proclaim his fandom. Here in 2022, I listened to Polar Bear Club for the very first time in my life.
Well... I'm sure I already ruined the punchline at the beginning of this blog post, but hopefully I've rambled on enough that you forgot about it or didn't even notice at all. In looking up which album I should start with, there was a general consensus that their 2008 debut album was the right place to begin. The name of that album? Sometimes Things Just Disappear.
Ugh! Pabst Blue Ribbon wasn't referencing the theft of the banner at all! They were just referencing the name of the goddamn Polar Bear Club album! What disappointment. What a logical, simple, motherfucking disappointing answer.
It's always disappointing, to be pulled back to earth in the realization that life really is just a series of random occurrences. It's scary to consider, and listening to Polar Bear Club has made me consider it more than anything has in quite some time. Life has no true meaning, we're all just stumbling through it. Some of us are stumbling drunkenly, stealing shit off walls, and some of us are writing words in all capital letters on social media, and some of us are just twiddling our thumbs, thinking about times gone by, but we're all stuck here in this randomized simulation we call "being human."
So when I laugh about the time Kev's PBC banner was stolen from the Woodstock House, I'm not laughing at how it all came together into the perfect joke. I'm instead laughing into the void. I'm laughing at the random series of events that led us to remember such an indiscriminate incident in our previous lives. I'm laughing at experiencing this joy despite the fact that it doesn't mean anything in the long run. It's all chaos and confusion, and yet we are still here. We have not disappeared. We remember.
I just texted Kev again. It's moving day for him. By my count, this will be the third or fourth time he's changed his living situation and location since we all moved out of Woodstock. (Kev did not know that PBC had an album called Sometimes Things Just Disappear, by the way, some fucking fan!) I ask him about the Polar Bear Club banner. I'm wondering if it'll make the cut in his new abode, especially now that he will be living with a woman who is not his mother for the first time in his life.
Kev: "Yes. It's the centerpiece above our bed."
I will infer that this loving piece of sarcasm actually means that the Polar Bear Club banner is once again lost. Whether its whereabouts are known or not, whether its in a cardboard box somewhere or it's been thrown out in the trash or misplaced or purposefully placed under a pillow or once again stolen by Emily P., the point remains the same: the banner is gone from our lives. It's gone because it doesn't actually have meaning. It's just a random item that existed and then didn't exist and then existed again and then kept giving us some laughs as we remembered. It doesn't have meaning, because nothing has meaning.
And you know what? That's okay. If everything is meaningless, then that's all the more reason to laugh about it.


No comments:
Post a Comment