I kind of love when Record Club does this—touching on what is truly a piece of present-day pop culture, but maybe like two weeks too late to actually participate in the plugged-in online-cultivated think-piece cottage industry that is erected during those few days after its release. Instead of actively participating in the Twitter hashtagging and subtweet arguments—an activity that truly makes me uncomfortable to even consider at this point—we get to instead survey the ruins, and pick up the pieces, with much hindsight. Reviewing Olivia Rodrigo's SOUR feels almost like I'm a fire marshal, sifting through the soot, trying to figure out what exactly happened here. Did Olivia Rodrigo really set fire to and burn down this entire motherfucker?
Under some blackened rubble, I find what appears to be an AARP membership card, which speaks to a general question that arises when someone like me listens to someone like Olivia Rodrigo: should I be listening to this music? Is SOUR made for me? Or am I too X, Y, or Z to really "get" it? These questions span far beyond the confines of this specific Olivia Rodrigo album, but they are questions that absolutely got thrown around a couple weeks ago, after SOUR dropped.
An example: Am I too old for this? I did see a lot of tweets that were basically like "Me, a 32-year-old, listening to Olivia Rodrigo" and then a picture of a senior citizen. Though exaggerated for internet points, I think the hesitancy is valid. No one wants to be the "cool" teacher who is all up to date on the high school students' gossip. It's weird. Also, it could lead to actual crimes, as shown by La Salle University Masque alumnus Chris Serpentine. Imagine being in your mid-30s and listening to Rodrigo sing about high school drama, and actually relating to it. I can't imagine it, but then again I could also never imagine being a grown-ass adult teacher and making out with a high school senior in my office. Am I saying that liking SOUR is criminal? Unlike Chris Serpentine's actions, no, it is not. Am I saying that Chris Serpentine, patriarch of the Old Money branch of the Masque Family Tree, loves SOUR? Almost assuredly, and so take that as you will. Dude is probably thanking his lucky stars he doesn't have to listen to "drivers license" from a jail cell.
I didn't intend for that tangent to end up here (it's all good, there's no way any Masque shit-stirrers that occasionally frequent PoYB would have the balls to meet me in the comments and defend Chris Serpentine), but it really does touch on how uncomfortable someone in my position might feel in enjoying an album such as this. I have a few gray hairs, my knees are creaky, I am old. Probably too old to appreciate SOUR any deeper than the surface level musical catchiness of it all.
Which, I mean, SOUR is catchy as shit, both in pop-punk mode and in new-age-indie-ish-ballad mode, and if you wanna just scroll down to the bottom of this review right now, you'll see a good mark (and could possibly avoid some unnecessary equivocating while you're at it). But that's not interesting to me when I'm thinking about Olivia Rodrigo. The interesting part is the friction between why I should like this and why I shouldn't like this. The idea of "age-appropriate music" is just one example.
And even the age thing might not necessarily be as cut-and-dry as the relating-to-this-music-makes-you-like-a-pedophile-teacher hyperbole thing. I went back and read what I wrote about Taylor Swift's "betty" last year, and sure enough, I used the word: I "related" to it. Sheesh. Nothing on SOUR has made me tear up the way I do when I listen to "betty," but I think in both cases, there needs to be some distancing on my/our part in order to make it appropriate.
For real, let's be honest: can I relate to any of the stories on SOUR? I can name two. Both "traitor" and "deja vu" feature love-triangle-esque scenarios that I could directly connect to scenarios that I found myself in at one point in my life, waaaaay back in the day. But "relate" is probably the wrong word there, ya know? "Relate" has to be in the present tense, and that certainly ain't the case with whatever college drama I'm sifting through in my head right now. I'm at least eleven years removed from living out anything that Olivia Rodrigo is going through currently. Maybe the difference is "I know these emotions are valid because I experienced them long ago" versus "I know these emotions are valid because I am experiencing them now." The emotions that Olivia Rodrigo is experiencing are pure-grade eighteen-year-old shit, and so all the tweeting about being "too old" for this is really just people being insecure about being perceived as "immature," as relating to emotions that are literally immature, all of it just fronting for your internet audience, so that they could never misinterpret your love of SOUR—that it's all about the hooks, baby, and certainly not the emotions expressed on it, because you left them behind long ago, believe you me. I am not an exception to the idea that our generation has a deep-seeded desire to seem "cool" online, seeing as how I myself am writing a whole heck of a lot of words about Olivia Rodrigo, currently, on a blog.
Let's not ignore the fact that it's not just about age, either. When I said that I was involved in scenarios similar to those sung about in "traitor" and "deja vu," it's important to note that I am connecting my past experiences to the villains in these songs. Throughout basically every single one of the eleven tracks on SOUR, we find Olivia Rodrigo confronting her feelings about the fact that her ex-boyfriend is now with another girl. But she is pretty careful to always lay the blame at the feet of the ex, and not this new girl whom he is currently seeing. Which is important! Men are pigs! I'm acknowledging this! Though Rodrigo never really expresses empathy for the new girl (at least not to the levels achieved by Fiona Apple, whose Fetch the Bolt Cutters touched on this subject with a similar nuance), the anger is absolutely never misdirected. I guess the reason I bring all this up is that there is another level to my hesitancy to getting really into SOUR. More so than the fact that I am 32 years old, there's the fact that I am also a cis/hetero male. Is this music for me?
Then there's the fact that being invested in this album, truly invested, requires some investment in the real life of Olivia Rodrigo. As noted above, she does seem to be spending a whole lot of emotional currency in response to a breakup. Pam asked me twelve hours before I wrote this review whether these stories were true, whether Rodrigo really is going through some ex-related drama. My answer: I think? Like, I know she is a Disney star, and she acts on that High School Musical TV show (that in actuality can't possibly be as good as its premise, right?!), and she dated one of the guys on that show, and they are no longer dating. Even these bare-bones details are only known to me because I read a weekly pop-related column on Stereogum every Monday afternoon, and they wrote about Rodrigo when "drivers license" was blowing up. Have I followed any of the celebrity gossip in the past few months since? Absolutely not. Is this music for me?
I mean, I guess some heat has to be generated from the questions surrounding the truth or fiction of these songs, right? I'm not interested, but I acknowledge its existence. It's kinda like how Lemonade made you wonder what was really happening behind Beyoncé's very expensive (and possibly slave-labor-made) doors. Am I of the opinion that any marital conflict between her and Jay-Z was fabricated to sell more records? Fuck yeah I am. But I'm also not gonna pretend that even a fictional account of one billionaire cheating on another billionaire and having the second billionaire expose his ass on a global scale doesn't at least pique my interest a tiny bit. I think it's interesting that the most popular album in the country right now could possibly be about one person, and I think it's interesting to ponder how that one person might feel about all this. But I'm sure as shit not gonna pick up a copy of People Magazine and find out.
But let's dig a little deeper into that subject of "authenticity," shall we? Not knowing whether Olivia Rodrigo is singing truth or fiction generates interest, but would knowing for sure that she is singing fiction make any difference whatsoever? Or even say if she really did get hurt by some guy, but it turns out that she didn't actually go through some of these feelings—her ex isn't repeating the same date nights, she no longer feels any ill will toward the breakup, she can actually parallel park no problem—and it turns out she is just leaning on the subject because that's an easier path to creating a truly good pop album, would you feel burned? Betrayed?
I'm speaking hypothetically, of course, because I wouldn't even recognized her unbedazzled face on the street, let alone purport to know anything about her love life, but say that all the lurid details did come out: I honestly wouldn't care. In fact, I'll go the opposite way, and say that young female musicians are unfairly bagged down with an expectation of being "authentic" in the first place. Like, I see the phrase "industry plant" all the time on message boards, and it always seems to be applied to artists like Olivia Rodrigo—young and female. As if someone of like her couldn't POSSIBLY be this competent with both the music and the emotional lyricism. It's so interesting that Ashlee Simpson was mentioned by our album-picker this week, because man, what an infamous and complicated example of this particular brand of sexism (and of course, I gave into it during my Simpson review, and probably underrated the album slightly due to it).
It's one thing to acknowledge that a musician comes from privilege, but it might be wise to acknowledge the fact that a popular musician who doesn't come from privilege is rare. It's impossible to make it this far as a musician without the financial backing of your parents. The music industry is just not designed these days to allow an artist to escape poverty without help, regardless of talent. You can criticize this all you want—and I have, and I will—but from where I'm standing, I only hear this argument when it comes to artists like Olivia Rodrigo. Of course she's only out there debuting at #1 with her first single because of her contacts at Disney. Of course! Because that's the only way anyone can make any of this shit work!
I may have gotten off-track again, I dunno. Sorry. I think I'm just trying to generate a little bit more excitement on my own part, or else otherwise I'll have to fall back on "this is a really well-made pop album that I found catchy," and I find that opinion to be pretty mundane. Even within that mundane opinion, though, we can probably find a good note to end on—the fact that this is a "pop album," and the ever-changing definition of that phrase.
It's something I feel like I've talked about in at least three previous reviews, but the idea of "pop" as a genre is endlessly fascinating to me. It's such a fucking chameleon. It's literally just short for "popular," and so it could literally mean anything. So to describe music as "pop" is really more of a way of describing the tastes of your general music listener than the music itself. Speaking as someone whose own personal tastes rarely line up with what is ostensibly "popular," I find plenty of interest in the idea that an artist could create music that hits both my mark and the general population's mark simultaneously.
Not that this is exactly my type of music, but man, it's gotten a lot closer than a LOT of the other pop in the past few years. I mean, a lot of the slower stuff is pretty good, maybe even pretty great occasionally—e.g. I responded to Sean's review a few months back with an email that read "'drivers license' suuuuucks" but after listening to it about 78 times this week, I actually quite like it now. And sure, the songs at the end really let the slow tempos spiral out of control, and I occasionally don't even realize that the album is over.
But the occasional dips into comparatively harder pop-punk are the songs that really get me going. I like "brutal" a lot, but I'm mainly talking about "good 4 u" here. "good 4 u" is a no-doubter in terms of best songs of the year so far. Most incredibly, at least to me, is the fact that this song was literally the most popular song in America last week (this week it's RC alum BTS, much less interesting IMO but YMMV). It's a bit disorienting to me whenever this happens, and not that it's even happened more than like a few times a decade—that my favorite song of the week was America's favorite song too. I struggle so much with the notion that what is "popular" is actually dog shit, and I end up asking "How do people like this so much?" until I'm blue in the face (see: Post Malone). So, I don't know, I guess seeing a worthy song sitting atop the charts gives me some... comfort, I guess? That America, as riddled with flaws as it is, doesn't get everything wrong?
That's really just another way of asking the question of the week, though: Is this music made for me? Pop-punk outliers notwithstanding, I think the answer is probably No. I'm too old, too male, too disconnected from popular music. But I'm too disconnected from the Twitterverse to care as well, and that's to my benefit. Reviewing Olivia Rodrigo's SOUR just a few milliseconds after it leaves the very center of the cultural zeitgeist means that I don't have to pick a side. I can acknowledge that I am not the intended audience. I can sidestep any problems with my general enjoyment of it. And I can press repeat, guilt-free. Much better to be the fire marshal than the arsonist.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment