Friday, June 11, 2021

SOUR, Melissa


SOUR, by Olivia Rodrigo, is as lower case as her song titles. Okay, that’s a little harsh, but it does remind me why I ask creative writing students to think beyond the lower case in their stories and poetry—it makes it seem like the writing is all unimportant and blobbed together. In this case, blobbed together about one dude breaking Olivia’s heart. We all know, by the end of this album, this was truly an all-caps romance to her.

Let it be known, I am an old fart, and this album may be too close to what I deal with as a high school teacher. Within the first seconds of "brutal," I agreed that this was brutal to listen to. The whining of a seventeen-year-old is just not doing it for me. Come at me, Gen-Z, but others have done this genre better. Y'all remember Alanis Morissette? Back in my day, she was the most jaded heart around.

Ok, I might be back onboard (parts hair in the middle) with "traitor" and "drivers license." Here we get the soulful, indie voice that makes this kind of lyrical "sadness" work.

But truly déjà vu in nature, "deja vu" had me back on the "can we get new content" train again. When she calls this dude out for doing the same activities with his new gal, as he did with Olivia, I am both intrigued and laughing. How dare this bastard rewatch episodes of GLEE with ANYONE ELSE? Also, the true déjà vu is hearing about how shitty this dude was.
 
I like the angry sounds of "good 4 u" and the spelling of the title, but same dude, same heartbreak. I like the sweet sound of "enough for you" (why isn't this "for" a 4?), but the lyrics hit real cray level when she says she read all his self-help books so he thinks she's smart. What? Why? What is this teen boy reading? Does he really dig Brené Brown? Is he in Oprah's book club like me? Olivia really lays him out for all to see. At one point she congratulates him for going to therapy, but that feels backhanded after all the songs about him being a dick. I don't know that I'm here for this dragging.

I guess, overall, I want this to be more mature—which it won't be because she's so young. "happier" and "jealousy, jealousy" just continue to make me less engaged in the music and more wanting for the musical experience. Older gals have done this same thing and I am HERE FOR IT (see: Beyoncé's Lemonade Album or anything Adele). Again, I am an elderly lady and I recognize that.

Overall, I get it. This album, lyrically, holds a mirror up to the things about my past self that I don't like. I too can harp on experiences, situations, and people. I too have worn makeup and looked for compliments. So maybe my bias against it comes from not wanting to have THAT conversation again in my old age. But, I also wish we could talk about something else with some more interesting music.

Seventeen-year-old me gives this album a 10 out of 10 and will fall asleep crying to these songs. Elder me gives it a 6 out of 10 and will fall asleep crying because my back hurts and I can't find my dentures.

No comments: