Lost and Gone Forever's prevailing theme is, well, loss. Throughout its eleven songs, Guster finds itself focusing on stories of endings, closures, resolution, grief. And while each specific song paints its own story, if you take them all together, then it becomes evident that Guster is really talking about themselves and their own career arc. After Lost and Gone Forever, Guster would never return to the chill, auxiliary percussion, hacky-sack-on-the-quad-infused sound. Future albums would find them leveling up (within the scope of indie rock), layering the music and creating a more muscular sound overall. Guster, then, is aware of the upcoming transition, and takes an album to say goodbye to the sound that they first came into the world making. The Guster as we knew it in 1999, on this album, is lost and gone forever.
Oh yeah, I totally stole that theory. Read about on some other fucking blog that deigned to write a 20th anniversary piece on Lost and Gone Forever a couple years ago. Sounds pretty good, eh? It's certainly a theory that I'm interested in. I like my bands self-aware, and I like the idea of creating nostalgia for something that isn't even completely gone yet. So if I was a Guster fan, I'd probably be formulating such a theory myself. But I'm not really a Guster fan. Not that I don't like them—this is a really good album, y'all—I just have never been interested enough to dig in, if that makes sense.
I have crossed paths with Guster at least twice in my life in a quasi-significant way, though. The first was in high school, when their song "Amsterdam" was blowing up (again, I mean "blowing up" in an indie rock context—it's all relative), and PoYB contributor Mike brought 'em up in the context of "Songs Our Band Should Play." The years are slipping by at an alarming rate, so I am sorry to report that I cannot even remember whether our band—Burholme—ended up playing "Amsterdam" in concert at any point. Like all songs that Mike and Kev brought to the table during those years in my parents' garage, I held them at arm's length—I was still in the process of figuring out my own musical identity, and was defensive about it—and yet I'm finding years later that all those songs have carved their own little niches into my heart anyway.
Plus, I was pretty intrigued by Guster's live rendition of "Amsterdam"—as described by Mike, who only told the truth like 80% of the time in high school, but this has been verified by YouTube this week—in which all the band members would switch instruments and play a noticeably-on-purpose inferior version of what was then their biggest hit. (Due to a political correctness that I wholeheartedly support, we shall now refer to this onstage maneuver as an "Amsterdam Fire Drill," as opposed to what fans referred to it as at the time.) I liked the idea of a band fucking around on stage, especially during those years in my life when I was on the stage myself. Guster did the Amsterdam Fire Drill in the same way we were pulling the Taking Back Sunday bait-and-switch on all the Roman Catholic HS heavy metal fans packing their battle of the bands. I felt a kinship with Guster, even if I wasn't interested in exploring their actual music.
The second my life intersected with Guster's tunes was during the few weeks I attempted to get the ill-fated "Beerito CD Club" off the ground. I guess this could be considered a precursor to PoYB's Record Club, though it functioned differently and lacked the written aspect. "Beerito" was the moniker for the weekly Thursday beer+burrito+movie hangout at Maeve's NoLibs apartment. My idea was for everyone to burn an album onto a CD every week, and add it to the collection we kept at Maeve's, exchanging it for one you hadn't heard yet. Add a CD, take a CD, that kind of thing. It was short-lived, but only because we were at the very tail end of laptops even having CD-ROM drives at all, and already a few years past CD players being the standard in cars.
And so while I did end up adding most of the CDs to the box, there were at least a few other participants. And I was able to discover at least two albums from this exercise. The first was the Old 97's' Fight Songs (as provided by PoYB contributor Frank). The second was Guster's Ganging Up on the Sun, provided by—you guessed it—Melissa, who also chose Lost and Gone Forever as this week's AotW. So it's kind of a full-circle thing this week, I guess. (Sidenote: pretty sure Hannah added a Britney Spears album to the box too, but even I have my limits.)
Again, not that I fell in love with Guster after listening to Ganging Up on the Sun that week, or during any other sporadically listen between 2014 and now. Like my dalliances with "Amsterdam" seven or eight years earlier, the prevailing reaction was mostly: "This is nice." And it is! But it never was, and still isn't, something that I'm going to all-caps-and-italics LOVE.
I will say that, because of the above experiences, I've always had a soft spot for Guster. Despite the similarities to a band like O.A.R., whom I have expressed disdain for in the past, I feel like Guster is just quirky and unassuming enough that they escape that ire. They seem to not take themselves too seriously. Starting as a three-bros-and-a-bongo operation at Tufts says to me that they were as surprised as anyone else when they achieved even a tiny measure of success. Call it humility, maybe. Or if you disagree, blame it on the fact that I still know next to nothing about this band.
And if that's something that I've always sensed but never really knew why, then Lost and Gone Forever is clearly where it all falls into place. The problems I have with Ganging Up on the Sun—a little too cutesy at times, a little too close to being an acoustic-bro-Coldplay-lite—are not evident at all on their preceding album. Their reputation with all the bongos or whatever is true if you listen to Lost and Gone Forever, and, at least to my ears, it fits them like a glove.
Look, if that same reputation sounds corny to your ears, then I don't blame you. If you asked me in 2007 or 2014 what I thought about Guster, then I may have been a little reluctant to tell you that I liked them. It just doesn't seem like "my" kind of band, ya feel me? But here in my 30s, I'm comfortable enough to just admit that hooks are king. If an album is catchy, then I'll probably profess my admiration for it, regardless of the band behind it or their alleged reputation. Lame? Bro-y? Music for white private school kids? I don't give a fuck anymore, yo. Give me hooks. (Exceptions? Sure. But Guster is not an exception.)
The countdown-chorus on "Barrel of a Gun," the falsetto on "All the Way Up to Heaven," the relatively-anthemic buildup of "Happier" (a song that is apparently Guster's go-to concert-closing song), the bongo-forward head-nodder "I Spy," the pitch-jumping "Two Points for Honesty," the singalong fa fa fa fa fa fa fa fa of "Fa Fa"—all of this shit has been taking up residence in my head all week, and I'm not tired of any of it yet.
From what I knew in the past, and what I learned this week, this seems to be the speed that Guster works in best. Chill and catchy. This will never, ever be enough for me to get on the proverbial mountaintop and shout Guster's name, but it's more than enough to make me happy. I look back of the past decade and a half, and I'm realizing that there really has never been a time when Guster has made me unhappy. I may not love the band, but I love being happy. I was happy this week.
And if Lost and Gone Forever really is about endings and about closure, then mark me as the dumbest Guster fan on earth, because to me, it finally felt like a beginning.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment