Friday, February 5, 2021

OK Human, Joe


And then we were all in some large room in the ER at some unknown hospital, me and countless others, some I knew and some I didn't. Most of us were in formal attire. I noticed that my friend ***** was there. I hadn't spoken to her in three years. She was wearing a black cocktail dress, her hair styled like Holly Golightly, her eyeliner slightly smeared from crying or laughing or who knows what. I asked her about her girlfriend. She didn't respond. I asked her about her parents. She alluded to the fact that her dad had recently passed. She told me that she didn't feel comfortable talking to me about it. I figured as much. I had feared this for a while. Joe K*** had fallen out of favor, ever since the incident at the ***** with ***** in *****er 20**. She wasn't even involved. A friend of a victim. And yet still hated me. Rightly so.

This was all a dream, by the way. One part of a dream, really, squished between a scene in which I'm watching Casablanca with my sister because it's her favorite movie for some reason and a scene in which the nurses try telling me that they are going to adopt Willow and I'm saying no no no no. And it was pretty clear to me what the relevant part of the dream, the dear old friend who clearly disdained me now, meant, as I reflected, in the still of the morning, doing some mental dream journaling, on the final morning of my life of waking up without a Weezer song stuck in my head (maybe).

I don't need a therapist to tell me that I care deeply about what other people think of me. That I'd still be worried that a social misdeed from three years ago would be more than even an emotional blip on the psyche of someone I sincerely haven't spoken to in three years should prove that. I'm not even saying that I'm "special" because of this. I assume that the majority of people in America care about other people's opinions of them whether they care to admit it in an album review or not.

But I wonder sometimes what it would be like to truly not care. To not care and to do so publicly. I wonder, in other words, what it would be like to be Rivers Cuomo.

I know this is a losing game, the whole "I wonder what it's like in this artist's head" thing, but with a band like Weezer, it's literally the most engaging thing about them. I am utterly fascinated with the idea of a band being so successful by being so embarrassingly bad for such a large majority of their existence. Does Weezer do this on purpose? Does Cuomo just simply not "have it" any longer? Some combination of the two? These are important questions, and sometimes asking them is a lot more enjoyable then actually listening to a Weezer album.

Credit where it's due, and on OK Human, it's due exactly twice. One: it's pretty clear at this point that, no matter the earned reputation of being lame, embarrassing, corny, whatever, this band can still write a hook. If all you care about is catchiness, then OK Human is your album of the year. Like I alluded to above, I've been singing tracks from this album in my head all week, whether I want to or not. But most of the time, I felt like George Costanza singing "Master of the House"—you're singing it and questioning why the fuck you are singing it, simultaneously. Catchiness can a blessing, and it can be a curse.

Two: while OK Human is bad, just like more than half of Weezer's albums are bad, credit to the band for at least always finding new and interesting ways to be bad. The conceit on OK Human: no electric guitar; it's been replaced by a 38-piece orchestra. I claimed in 2019 that "classical music elements can take decent rock music and make it essential," and boy, do I find it truly fascinating that Weezer can put egg on my face so thoroughly. For real. Whether it's an exasperating covers album, a much-too-literal album cover, a "we're good again" fake-out, a song that immediately drains any good will from that fake-out, just a straight up no-holds-barred awful album for no reason, dalliances with hip hop—I mean, look, this is a long list of truly terrible music, but no one is ever going accuse Weezer of being stale or same-y. I might hate most of the music, but I appreciate—maybe even love—the fact that they are so goddamn engaging in their acts of terribleness.

Okay, the credit has been paid, so now let's dig into what is so "bad" about OK Human. Honestly, for all the talk about Weezer keeping me on their toes with new and interesting sounds, my turn-offs are the same turn-offs that I've been struggling with for well over a decade with this band: the lyrics are just so cringe-worthy and off-putting that I can barely stand them sometimes. I hate them. I hate the obviousness and laziness of them. The tired 1984 reference in "Grapes of Wrath," the stale reference to Zoom in "Playing My Piano," the cliché complaints of screentime in "Screens," the humiliating metaphor of "Bird with a Broken Wing," do you need me to continue? I guess this is similar to the issue I had with Cheekface last week, in that some of the references are too specific / meme-ish, but at least Cheekface was halfway clever about it.

And that's not even mentioning all the times that Cuomo couldn't even come up with lyrics, and instead decided to fill the hooks with various permutations of "woah-oh." "Aloo Gobi"'s big hook is "Walking down Montana / woah-oh." The first verse of "Here Comes the Rain" has two filler woahs. "Playing My Piano" has too many to count. It's fucking lazy bullshit, and I hate it. 

I hate it. It's catchy, which makes me hate it even more, because such delicious hooks are absolutely wasted with such shitty lyrics. I hate it. I hate Rivers Cuomo. I HATE him.

But again, clearly he doesn't mind the hate. This man has been operating under these circumstances for most of his career. He doesn't fucking care! Like he says in "All My Favorite Songs," he "fall[s] in love with everyone who hates [him]." And coming from someone who just about implodes over even the speculation that someone hates him, I can say that I find this behavior worthy of discussion, and it's the reason—the only reason—why I can't stop listening to Weezer.
 
I just can't get over the fact that they release this bullshit so often and manage to keep me intrigued every single time, for reasons that are completely opposite than the reasons I typically keep coming back to certain music. It's worse than watching a trainwreck; it's more like watching a person slit someone's throat and then surgically cut their body into pieces. There's no mystery, you know exactly what your doing as a spectator, and yet, still, you can't look away.

Key lyrics, from "Grapes of Wrath": "I just don't care / I just don't care." These are careless, dull lyrics sung by one of the only men on earth who could sing such a lyric and make me actually believe them. If I ever pretend like I could sing along and mean the lyrics too, then all I need do is remember what my dream was trying to warn me otherwise: I care. I care. Oh god, I care.

GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5

No comments: