For whatever reason—COVID boredom, I dunno—I made a list of 200 movies that I had never seen before, and I'm spending a few years watching those movies in alphabetical order, and then writing about them.
Cloverfield
2008
A conversation between Joe and Drew A*******, via email.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Joe: A lot of these films on my list were put there because I am aware of and interested in the "hook" of the film (but just lacked the motivation to finally just sit down and watch it). So for Cloverfield, I wasn't flying in blind. I knew it was a found-footage "horror" (maybe? or monster thriller to be specific?) film. I wouldn't have put the film on my list if that didn't sound like something I'd be interested in.
It was, and I watched it, and I guess the question then becomes: was Cloverfield able to take what I thought was a good idea, and turn it into a good / palatable / worthwhile film? Having now watched it, I can unequivocally state: I liked it.
Now, when you chose this movie to discuss with me, you had your doubts about whether it would "hold up" (having seen it closer to its 2008 release), so we can start by just asking you a few questions in that vein. Did you like Cloverfield in 2008 (or whenever)? Do you still feel that way after having rewatched it? Why / why not / and so on.
I'm almost hoping you didn't like it, so we can argue about that, but if you like it as much as I did (probably gonna give it a 3.5/5 unless you can convince me in either direction), we'll have some other shit to discuss too.
Drew: So the other day I rewatched Cloverfield for the first time since seeing it in theaters in 2008. Back then, I would say I REALLY liked it. Leading up to it, this film was an EVENT. There was so much hype around it because the marketing was so mysterious. The first trailer played in front of Transformers (2007), which I also saw in theaters. It was just a 30-second clip of the Statue of Liberty's head getting blasted into the streets of New York. It cut to black and then just said a date: 1-18-08. There was no title. The Transformers audience screamed. People didn’t even find out that it was called "Cloverfield" until a week before its release because theater marquees had to say SOMETHING. I remember everyone just calling it "one-eighteen-oh-eight." Even "Cloverfield" was so vague no one could piece together what it meant. Is this Godzilla? Cthulhu? Something original? J.J. Abrams produced it after all, who had recently set a new bar for keeping audiences guessing with Lost.
Anyway, you bet your ass my friends and I saw it opening night at midnight at my hometown movie theater. The movie was intense, but I guess the biggest surprise was the fact that (SPOILERS!) there were thousands of little, bloodthirsty alien spores falling off of the big one, which was kept hidden from the marketing. I liked how you almost never get a clear image of the monster. And there was a minuscule moment in the last shot when they go to Coney Island where you can see something plummet from the sky into the ocean. Only like two people in the theater caught it when I saw it, so I found out about it later online.
Looking back thirteen years later, I like it slightly less than I did the first time around. I think my qualm with it in hindsight is that it's a found-footage movie, but at the same time it still feels like a blockbuster. There's a ton of CGI, sexy 20-somethings, lavish set pieces... Sure, the camera is shaky (shaky enough that a friend of mine had to put his head between his knees with motion sickness), and they occasionally do some sloppy intercuts with other footage on the "tape" that we're watching. But I know this is fiction—this obviously isn’t a tape someone found in Central Park. Granted, any fantasy film has the challenge of making us suspend disbelief, but admittedly Cloverfield didn't always do it for me.
Weirdly, my bias is based on the fact that I can't help but compare it to a much, much better found footage film: The Blair Witch Project. Kind of a curveball, but how can anyone make a found-footage film and not think about the best found-footage film ever made? BWP was a hundred times more mysterious, more real, more of a cultural phenomenon than Cloverfield was because PEOPLE. THOUGHT. THE. FOOTAGE. WAS. REAL. BWP was so rough, so obscure, so lo-fi, that you really feel like this is a tape someone found in the woods. BWP had completely unknown improv actors, whereas Cloverfield had Janis Ian from Mean Girls. BWP is even supernatural—they had the burden of portraying something otherworldly and they still made people believe the Blair Witch (or SOMETHING) stalked these kids. Cloverfield is presented as found-footage, but of course nothing like that has ever happened or will ever happen. It didn't need to be found-footage. It was a gimmick. It was fun at times, but a similar story could have been told without the Jason-Bourne-handheld cinematography. Cloverfield leaves a little to the imagination, but should have left much more in the shadows IMO.
I don’t know... it's a very weird gripe that I only really felt watching it years later as an adult. It was intense in theaters as a teenager, but I can't help but think that if this was in theaters now, while I'm 30-years-old, I honestly would probably just skip it entirely. Or at least think it was cheesy. I didn't hate it though! It’s only like 80 minutes, which is the right amount of time. It certainly does not overstay its welcome. Director Matt Reeves and screenwriter Drew Goddard have both gone on to helm some excellent projects. And this was T.J. Miller's FIRST role ever! He's kind of a dick now, but at the time he stole the show. I'd love to see how they filmed around him—everyone talks to his character as if he's holding the camera, but apparently it was almost entirely shot by a professional cinematographer. So, was T.J. Miller just standing next to the camera guy? Were some of his lines added in post-production? I really thought they did a great job with his POV.
Anyway, you gave it a 3.5/5, I’ll give it a near equivalent 6.8/10. Good, but not great. DO YOU AGREE OR DISAGREE????? And what do you think "Cloverfield" actually means? I know what it means. I'm just curious if you do as well.
Joe: Drunk blogging is the best blogging.
I dunno man, I think I half-agree with you about the whole "movie magic" aspect of Cloverfield. I liked the conceit a lot, that the camera is supposed to be taping something normal and real, and then all of a sudden, something supernatural happens. The first half of the movie was bonkers great, in my opinion, just the right amount of surreal (the "what if this happened in real life" aspect), The second half lagged a little bit, but I think only because the motivation for these characters to enter the chaos instead of flee it strained credibility (gotta save a girl!!!! c'mon). I mean, I get that it had to happen, because the camera is following Rob, and so this is the way that we as the audience can get the full monster experience. Still, though, if what I loved about this movie is the fact that it portrayed what would actually happen if a Godzilla attacked a city like Philadelphia, then a character doing something that I don't think anyone would actually do in that situation kind of takes me out of it.
So really, I guess our complaints are not really the same, and that probably has more to do with our respective tolerances for "cheesiness" in movies. If a movie wants to pretend that a monster is attacking a populated urban area and we're along for the ride, count me in.
I definitely enjoyed The Blair Witch Project comparison, and don't think it's a curveball at all, seeing as how these two films are probably the most popular found-footage films of all time (I was gonna say "only popular," but there are a few other ringers on the Wikipedia page that I haven't seen yet and might be up there in terms of popularity), on top of the fact that the Never Seen It column covered BWP a few months ago.
But probably the most interesting comparison, in my opinion, is the marketing that you mentioned, and how these two films sort of represent a beginning and an end of a particular period in American entertainment. I remember in my BWP research reading about all the different little things that the filmmakers did to build the "world" of the Blair Witch, mostly online. We're probably talking Geocities-type websites, featuring fake "police reports" about the actors being "missing, presumed dead," that kind of thing. Wikipedia states that it was probably the first film to ever be primarily marketed over the internet.
And I thought it was interesting that Cloverfield had a somewhat similar marketing strategy, though obviously on a bit larger of a scale—as you mentioned, the mystery of it building the anticipation. But I'm also talking about the online aspect of it. There were MySpace pages for all the main characters that mysteriously stopped updating on 1/18/08. There were online puzzle-type websites featuring a fictional Japanese drink company that was filled with "clues" to give answers about the film. All this shit.
Now, not being plugged-in at the time of either of these films' releases, I wasn't personally privy to any of this. But I will say that by the end of '08, I started a Twitter account, and in the decade-plus since, shit like Twitter has completely reshaped how we consume entertainment. Everything is hyped up like Cloverfield was, via the internet. Superhero movies not only get trailers, but teaser trailers, and those teaser trailers are "trending," and entertainment blogs dissect every little fucking thing, so much so that and sense of "mystery" that was cultivated by BWP and Cloverfield can simply not exist anymore, at least not in the same way.
So that's what I mean by the two movies being the beginning/end of that brief period of time. It was nine- or ten-year period when the internet was used enough that things could "go viral," but not yet so oversaturated and overcommercialized that "going viral" didn't fucking mean anything anymore. So maybe it's possible that this is what you are referring to, or implying, by saying that you wouldn't have enjoyed it as much now as you did then—I'll argue it doesn't have anything to do with age, and has everything to do with how the mass-entertainment complex currently functions, compared to 2008, and compared to 1999.
Anyways, T.J. Miller is a violent sexual criminal, right? But besides all that, it was definitely surprising seeing him pop up in this, and then have such a pivotal role. How grating you find Hud's "comedic relief" probably hinges on how grating you find Miller himself. Me, I could give or take it. (You were right that 80 minutes was the perfect length, for the reasons you mention, and also because more than 80 minutes of T.J. Miller would've crossed a line). You did inspire me to do like the most cursory of googling as far as his camerawork in the film. According to one interview, he filmed about one-third of the film himself. Definitely interesting though to think about, especially since me and Sunny talked about that some for Children of Men, a movie with insane long takes that required the cameraman to be on top of his game.
Otherwise, what do we think of the acting? I know you were a little dismissive, and I kind of am too. I am a big Ben Feldman fan, and was disappointed that he didn't have more to work with. Thought Rob was okay, and most of my qualms have more to do with the aforementioned absurd motivations of the characters than the acting itself. Was a big fan of Jessica Lucas in the mid-'00s One-Season Wonder Life As We Know It (also starring Kelly Osbourne!), so I was surprised to see her here and to learn that apparently this is her most famous role, and not some soap opera that apparently only I watched.
But maybe focusing on the acting is beside the point. Maybe the whole point was the mystery of it all. You were right that the movie succeeds because the monster is barely featured. In fact, I'll say that the part when we get a closeup of the monster right before he eats T.J. Miller is the worst part, despite the fact that it is a monster eating T.J. Miller. I'm even less interested in the extraneous "world building" that happened online (apparently that Japanese soda company sent a monkey into space, and that is what is crashing into the ocean at Coney Island?!). I don't care enough to know. I'd rather be left in the dark, because that's where the fun is.
So in that vein, I'll ask: have you ever seen any of the "sequels"? I have not seen 10 Cloverfield Lane or The Cloverfield Paradox. I am interested in seeing the former at some point, so for real no spoilers please, but I did kind of glance over how these movies are connected, and it seems pretty weak. I do like the idea of different movies being part of some overarching universe—like, I'm definitely interested in the MCU in theory, if not at all in practice—but I don't know if that's enough for me to get invested in the "Cloverfield Universe."
And yeah, I read that "Cloverfield" was: 1) the in-world government file name for the "incident that occurred in NYC on 1/18/08," and 2) the name of the street of Bad Robot's production company or some shit. I'm probably interested in this kind of stuff the same way I was interested Lost's Dharma Initiative... like, kind of, I guess? But I find all of J.J. Abrams' "mystery boxes" to be somewhat secondary to the characters, the story, that kind of stuff. Or else we'll find ourselves making this type of video for Cloverfield. But I'd love to hear if you are a big MYSTERY BOX THEORY fan.
Drew: Great point(s). Perhaps Cloverfield is the last entry in that films could still be marketed creatively online. It would be impossible to achieve that level of intrigue nowadays, wouldn't it? Hell, most modern trailers spoil the entire fucking movie.
Anyway, acting-wise I thought everyone did okay. Although weirdly, I think Rob, our main character, was the most forgettable of all of them. And I really didn’t give two shits about his relationship with Beth. Mike Vogel, who plays Rob's brother Jason, is someone I first saw in The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003), and I always thought he deserved a bigger career. Apparently he was the second choice for Captain America and only lost it to Chris Evans because he was too short or something... I did notice Ben Feldman played Beth’s new man—do we ever find out what happens to him? He must have been with Beth in the apartment building, so he died, right? Theo Rossi was also at the party, and he’s had a better career than half the main cast.
And I have seen 10 Cloverfield Lane—I really liked it! I won't spoil it, but it's worth a watch. And it came out eight years after the first movie, so no one was expecting it. I skipped Paradox, mainly because the reviews weren't good.
As far as the mystery box theory goes, I think it can sometimes be a great tool to keep the audience guessing, but I also think it has limits. Like eventually people are going to be reaching for clues and easter eggs that simply aren't there. J.J Abrams is the king of the mystery box, but he tried to slip those tendencies in Star Wars when he directed Episodes VII and IX (*tangent alert*) and I wasn't feeling it. We know nothing about who Rey is and how she fits into the story, so people were coming up with these elaborate theories about which original Star Wars characters she HAD to be related to, and it was so lame. Everyone expected a big mystery because of how Abrams tells his stories, and it backfired. In a nutshell, the mystery box works for the right project, but can be wrong for others.
Joe: Ben Feldman died on the way back to his home planet; oh shit I'm just reading now that Mike Vogel is a hometown boy, grew up in the same county as my Rockledge, PA; I haven't seen a new Star Wars movie since 2002.
But to wrap up, let's kind of zoom out a little bit. We can nitpick all day (and should, because it's fun), but I'm interested in your overall opinion of Cloverfield's value. Is this a movie worth remembering? Does it add anything to the idea of "film" as an idea? Or is it just a fun but forgettable little thing? Would you recommend it to anyone? Or just some people specifically? I've only been watching like 50% of the movies on the list with Pam these days, and I skipped this one with her, mainly because she has concerns whenever a movie could be "scary." But is that a decision worth regretting? Would someone with no motivation to watch this (not even blog-related motivation!) find value in this?
That might be the same question asked in like six different ways, but you get what I'm trying to ask.
Drew: Is it a movie you NEED to see before you die? Probably not. Is it worth a watch if you have 80 minutes? Absolutely. It benefited from the hype leading up to it, and while it didn't spawn a massively successful franchise, it's something different.
And it's only PG-13, it's not that scary! Maybe "intense," but not terrifying. I would recommend it to anyone who can handle a move shot with a relentlessly shaky camera. Seriously, some people HATE that stuff because it gives them motion sickness (and it can be hard to know what you're supposed to be looking at). I think it deserves to be remembered as a unique experiment, and there probably won't be anything made or marketed like it again any time soon (that's a compliment).
It was, and I watched it, and I guess the question then becomes: was Cloverfield able to take what I thought was a good idea, and turn it into a good / palatable / worthwhile film? Having now watched it, I can unequivocally state: I liked it.
Now, when you chose this movie to discuss with me, you had your doubts about whether it would "hold up" (having seen it closer to its 2008 release), so we can start by just asking you a few questions in that vein. Did you like Cloverfield in 2008 (or whenever)? Do you still feel that way after having rewatched it? Why / why not / and so on.
I'm almost hoping you didn't like it, so we can argue about that, but if you like it as much as I did (probably gonna give it a 3.5/5 unless you can convince me in either direction), we'll have some other shit to discuss too.
Drew: So the other day I rewatched Cloverfield for the first time since seeing it in theaters in 2008. Back then, I would say I REALLY liked it. Leading up to it, this film was an EVENT. There was so much hype around it because the marketing was so mysterious. The first trailer played in front of Transformers (2007), which I also saw in theaters. It was just a 30-second clip of the Statue of Liberty's head getting blasted into the streets of New York. It cut to black and then just said a date: 1-18-08. There was no title. The Transformers audience screamed. People didn’t even find out that it was called "Cloverfield" until a week before its release because theater marquees had to say SOMETHING. I remember everyone just calling it "one-eighteen-oh-eight." Even "Cloverfield" was so vague no one could piece together what it meant. Is this Godzilla? Cthulhu? Something original? J.J. Abrams produced it after all, who had recently set a new bar for keeping audiences guessing with Lost.
Anyway, you bet your ass my friends and I saw it opening night at midnight at my hometown movie theater. The movie was intense, but I guess the biggest surprise was the fact that (SPOILERS!) there were thousands of little, bloodthirsty alien spores falling off of the big one, which was kept hidden from the marketing. I liked how you almost never get a clear image of the monster. And there was a minuscule moment in the last shot when they go to Coney Island where you can see something plummet from the sky into the ocean. Only like two people in the theater caught it when I saw it, so I found out about it later online.
Looking back thirteen years later, I like it slightly less than I did the first time around. I think my qualm with it in hindsight is that it's a found-footage movie, but at the same time it still feels like a blockbuster. There's a ton of CGI, sexy 20-somethings, lavish set pieces... Sure, the camera is shaky (shaky enough that a friend of mine had to put his head between his knees with motion sickness), and they occasionally do some sloppy intercuts with other footage on the "tape" that we're watching. But I know this is fiction—this obviously isn’t a tape someone found in Central Park. Granted, any fantasy film has the challenge of making us suspend disbelief, but admittedly Cloverfield didn't always do it for me.
Weirdly, my bias is based on the fact that I can't help but compare it to a much, much better found footage film: The Blair Witch Project. Kind of a curveball, but how can anyone make a found-footage film and not think about the best found-footage film ever made? BWP was a hundred times more mysterious, more real, more of a cultural phenomenon than Cloverfield was because PEOPLE. THOUGHT. THE. FOOTAGE. WAS. REAL. BWP was so rough, so obscure, so lo-fi, that you really feel like this is a tape someone found in the woods. BWP had completely unknown improv actors, whereas Cloverfield had Janis Ian from Mean Girls. BWP is even supernatural—they had the burden of portraying something otherworldly and they still made people believe the Blair Witch (or SOMETHING) stalked these kids. Cloverfield is presented as found-footage, but of course nothing like that has ever happened or will ever happen. It didn't need to be found-footage. It was a gimmick. It was fun at times, but a similar story could have been told without the Jason-Bourne-handheld cinematography. Cloverfield leaves a little to the imagination, but should have left much more in the shadows IMO.
I don’t know... it's a very weird gripe that I only really felt watching it years later as an adult. It was intense in theaters as a teenager, but I can't help but think that if this was in theaters now, while I'm 30-years-old, I honestly would probably just skip it entirely. Or at least think it was cheesy. I didn't hate it though! It’s only like 80 minutes, which is the right amount of time. It certainly does not overstay its welcome. Director Matt Reeves and screenwriter Drew Goddard have both gone on to helm some excellent projects. And this was T.J. Miller's FIRST role ever! He's kind of a dick now, but at the time he stole the show. I'd love to see how they filmed around him—everyone talks to his character as if he's holding the camera, but apparently it was almost entirely shot by a professional cinematographer. So, was T.J. Miller just standing next to the camera guy? Were some of his lines added in post-production? I really thought they did a great job with his POV.
Anyway, you gave it a 3.5/5, I’ll give it a near equivalent 6.8/10. Good, but not great. DO YOU AGREE OR DISAGREE????? And what do you think "Cloverfield" actually means? I know what it means. I'm just curious if you do as well.
Joe: Drunk blogging is the best blogging.
I dunno man, I think I half-agree with you about the whole "movie magic" aspect of Cloverfield. I liked the conceit a lot, that the camera is supposed to be taping something normal and real, and then all of a sudden, something supernatural happens. The first half of the movie was bonkers great, in my opinion, just the right amount of surreal (the "what if this happened in real life" aspect), The second half lagged a little bit, but I think only because the motivation for these characters to enter the chaos instead of flee it strained credibility (gotta save a girl!!!! c'mon). I mean, I get that it had to happen, because the camera is following Rob, and so this is the way that we as the audience can get the full monster experience. Still, though, if what I loved about this movie is the fact that it portrayed what would actually happen if a Godzilla attacked a city like Philadelphia, then a character doing something that I don't think anyone would actually do in that situation kind of takes me out of it.
So really, I guess our complaints are not really the same, and that probably has more to do with our respective tolerances for "cheesiness" in movies. If a movie wants to pretend that a monster is attacking a populated urban area and we're along for the ride, count me in.
I definitely enjoyed The Blair Witch Project comparison, and don't think it's a curveball at all, seeing as how these two films are probably the most popular found-footage films of all time (I was gonna say "only popular," but there are a few other ringers on the Wikipedia page that I haven't seen yet and might be up there in terms of popularity), on top of the fact that the Never Seen It column covered BWP a few months ago.
But probably the most interesting comparison, in my opinion, is the marketing that you mentioned, and how these two films sort of represent a beginning and an end of a particular period in American entertainment. I remember in my BWP research reading about all the different little things that the filmmakers did to build the "world" of the Blair Witch, mostly online. We're probably talking Geocities-type websites, featuring fake "police reports" about the actors being "missing, presumed dead," that kind of thing. Wikipedia states that it was probably the first film to ever be primarily marketed over the internet.
And I thought it was interesting that Cloverfield had a somewhat similar marketing strategy, though obviously on a bit larger of a scale—as you mentioned, the mystery of it building the anticipation. But I'm also talking about the online aspect of it. There were MySpace pages for all the main characters that mysteriously stopped updating on 1/18/08. There were online puzzle-type websites featuring a fictional Japanese drink company that was filled with "clues" to give answers about the film. All this shit.
Now, not being plugged-in at the time of either of these films' releases, I wasn't personally privy to any of this. But I will say that by the end of '08, I started a Twitter account, and in the decade-plus since, shit like Twitter has completely reshaped how we consume entertainment. Everything is hyped up like Cloverfield was, via the internet. Superhero movies not only get trailers, but teaser trailers, and those teaser trailers are "trending," and entertainment blogs dissect every little fucking thing, so much so that and sense of "mystery" that was cultivated by BWP and Cloverfield can simply not exist anymore, at least not in the same way.
So that's what I mean by the two movies being the beginning/end of that brief period of time. It was nine- or ten-year period when the internet was used enough that things could "go viral," but not yet so oversaturated and overcommercialized that "going viral" didn't fucking mean anything anymore. So maybe it's possible that this is what you are referring to, or implying, by saying that you wouldn't have enjoyed it as much now as you did then—I'll argue it doesn't have anything to do with age, and has everything to do with how the mass-entertainment complex currently functions, compared to 2008, and compared to 1999.
Anyways, T.J. Miller is a violent sexual criminal, right? But besides all that, it was definitely surprising seeing him pop up in this, and then have such a pivotal role. How grating you find Hud's "comedic relief" probably hinges on how grating you find Miller himself. Me, I could give or take it. (You were right that 80 minutes was the perfect length, for the reasons you mention, and also because more than 80 minutes of T.J. Miller would've crossed a line). You did inspire me to do like the most cursory of googling as far as his camerawork in the film. According to one interview, he filmed about one-third of the film himself. Definitely interesting though to think about, especially since me and Sunny talked about that some for Children of Men, a movie with insane long takes that required the cameraman to be on top of his game.
Otherwise, what do we think of the acting? I know you were a little dismissive, and I kind of am too. I am a big Ben Feldman fan, and was disappointed that he didn't have more to work with. Thought Rob was okay, and most of my qualms have more to do with the aforementioned absurd motivations of the characters than the acting itself. Was a big fan of Jessica Lucas in the mid-'00s One-Season Wonder Life As We Know It (also starring Kelly Osbourne!), so I was surprised to see her here and to learn that apparently this is her most famous role, and not some soap opera that apparently only I watched.
But maybe focusing on the acting is beside the point. Maybe the whole point was the mystery of it all. You were right that the movie succeeds because the monster is barely featured. In fact, I'll say that the part when we get a closeup of the monster right before he eats T.J. Miller is the worst part, despite the fact that it is a monster eating T.J. Miller. I'm even less interested in the extraneous "world building" that happened online (apparently that Japanese soda company sent a monkey into space, and that is what is crashing into the ocean at Coney Island?!). I don't care enough to know. I'd rather be left in the dark, because that's where the fun is.
So in that vein, I'll ask: have you ever seen any of the "sequels"? I have not seen 10 Cloverfield Lane or The Cloverfield Paradox. I am interested in seeing the former at some point, so for real no spoilers please, but I did kind of glance over how these movies are connected, and it seems pretty weak. I do like the idea of different movies being part of some overarching universe—like, I'm definitely interested in the MCU in theory, if not at all in practice—but I don't know if that's enough for me to get invested in the "Cloverfield Universe."
And yeah, I read that "Cloverfield" was: 1) the in-world government file name for the "incident that occurred in NYC on 1/18/08," and 2) the name of the street of Bad Robot's production company or some shit. I'm probably interested in this kind of stuff the same way I was interested Lost's Dharma Initiative... like, kind of, I guess? But I find all of J.J. Abrams' "mystery boxes" to be somewhat secondary to the characters, the story, that kind of stuff. Or else we'll find ourselves making this type of video for Cloverfield. But I'd love to hear if you are a big MYSTERY BOX THEORY fan.
Drew: Great point(s). Perhaps Cloverfield is the last entry in that films could still be marketed creatively online. It would be impossible to achieve that level of intrigue nowadays, wouldn't it? Hell, most modern trailers spoil the entire fucking movie.
Anyway, acting-wise I thought everyone did okay. Although weirdly, I think Rob, our main character, was the most forgettable of all of them. And I really didn’t give two shits about his relationship with Beth. Mike Vogel, who plays Rob's brother Jason, is someone I first saw in The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003), and I always thought he deserved a bigger career. Apparently he was the second choice for Captain America and only lost it to Chris Evans because he was too short or something... I did notice Ben Feldman played Beth’s new man—do we ever find out what happens to him? He must have been with Beth in the apartment building, so he died, right? Theo Rossi was also at the party, and he’s had a better career than half the main cast.
And I have seen 10 Cloverfield Lane—I really liked it! I won't spoil it, but it's worth a watch. And it came out eight years after the first movie, so no one was expecting it. I skipped Paradox, mainly because the reviews weren't good.
As far as the mystery box theory goes, I think it can sometimes be a great tool to keep the audience guessing, but I also think it has limits. Like eventually people are going to be reaching for clues and easter eggs that simply aren't there. J.J Abrams is the king of the mystery box, but he tried to slip those tendencies in Star Wars when he directed Episodes VII and IX (*tangent alert*) and I wasn't feeling it. We know nothing about who Rey is and how she fits into the story, so people were coming up with these elaborate theories about which original Star Wars characters she HAD to be related to, and it was so lame. Everyone expected a big mystery because of how Abrams tells his stories, and it backfired. In a nutshell, the mystery box works for the right project, but can be wrong for others.
Joe: Ben Feldman died on the way back to his home planet; oh shit I'm just reading now that Mike Vogel is a hometown boy, grew up in the same county as my Rockledge, PA; I haven't seen a new Star Wars movie since 2002.
But to wrap up, let's kind of zoom out a little bit. We can nitpick all day (and should, because it's fun), but I'm interested in your overall opinion of Cloverfield's value. Is this a movie worth remembering? Does it add anything to the idea of "film" as an idea? Or is it just a fun but forgettable little thing? Would you recommend it to anyone? Or just some people specifically? I've only been watching like 50% of the movies on the list with Pam these days, and I skipped this one with her, mainly because she has concerns whenever a movie could be "scary." But is that a decision worth regretting? Would someone with no motivation to watch this (not even blog-related motivation!) find value in this?
That might be the same question asked in like six different ways, but you get what I'm trying to ask.
Drew: Is it a movie you NEED to see before you die? Probably not. Is it worth a watch if you have 80 minutes? Absolutely. It benefited from the hype leading up to it, and while it didn't spawn a massively successful franchise, it's something different.
And it's only PG-13, it's not that scary! Maybe "intense," but not terrifying. I would recommend it to anyone who can handle a move shot with a relentlessly shaky camera. Seriously, some people HATE that stuff because it gives them motion sickness (and it can be hard to know what you're supposed to be looking at). I think it deserves to be remembered as a unique experiment, and there probably won't be anything made or marketed like it again any time soon (that's a compliment).
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: Let's see what The Color Purple is all about (and if Whoopi Goldberg is a good actor).

1 comment:
Just here to 2nd the praise and recommendation for 10 Cloverfield Lane
Post a Comment