A while ago, there entered into our public consciousness a list. This list named 200 movies that Joe had never seen before. The list will be smited in alphabetical order. Read on to witness the next victim.
Chinatown
1974
I feel like Chinatown is one of those films that features a bunch of pieces that might theoretically appeal to me personally, but it just never really comes together in a way that makes me appreciate it as a whole. Not a bad movie by a long shot, but just not something I'm going to be enthusiastic about when writing about it (and especially not worthy, in my opinion, of being considered the 21st best movie of all time, according to any metric).
Probably my biggest frustration was the story. At times, it was fun, as noirs usually are (I feel like I've seen more film noir parodies in my life than actual film noirs, but that only speaks to how enjoyable they can be under any circumstance). At other times, it just made me aggravated. One of the biggest frustrations expressed by lead P.I. Jake Gittes was that he is surrounded by liars unwilling to speak plainly and truthfully. By the end of investigation, he's just tired, tired of never getting a straight answer, tired of having to slap the truth out of people. And I think some of that exhaustion and aggravation is transferred to the audience too, almost by osmosis. Gittes was rightfully frustrated with the double-crossing and oblique half-truths, but, like, so was I, and that doesn't particularly work for me.
I will give credit where it's due, however, and it's due for that ending. I don't know that I particularly liked the ending, but I don't think I was supposed to like the ending. I think that was the point, and if it was, then it was successful, on top of being fucking ballsy. Spoilers, obviously—Gittes learns that Evelyn Mulwray had been the victim of incestuous rape by her father back in the day, and so he helps her attempt to escape with her sister/daughter, only to witness Evelyn be gunned down by police. The treacherous daughter-raper steals his grand/daughter away, the murderous police shoo everyone away, Gittes is speechless, his partners shrug the whole thing off, and then... the film ends. YIKES. Like I said, I didn't like it, but I really can't fault it. Gotta leave the audience wanting more, I guess?
I also can't really fault the cast for doing well with the material. Anything off-putting I found in any of the performances were very clearly a Joe-specific thing, and not anything I expect anyone else to agree with. Like: man, it was just weird seeing Nicholson this young. He was supposed to come off as smooth and suave, and I just had trouble believing it. Something about that classic Nicholson voice, all weedy and molasses-like, seems incongruous with the character he was portraying. And Faye Dunaway, likewise, did good, but having just seen in Bonnie and Clyde what fun she could be on-screen, it was tough to see her portray a stuffy, frustrating, and broken well-to-do in Chinatown.
Here's something else that one might assume is going to be a bugaboo for me—the fact that Roman Polanski directed it. It took me till watching Chinatown to do even the most cursory of reading on what this dude's deal is, and so I did, and yeah, definitely, this dude is real bad. Sexually abused and raped multiple teenagers, and fled the country before being imprisoned for his crimes. There's the concern that this is the guy directing a film that itself features a plot detail of the ostensible villain raping his thirteen-year-old daughter. I guess that's a valid concern. Probably a two-fold concern: one, that this dude would be profiting off of me watching Chinatown (averted because it's not streaming on any of the services we have so I bootlegged it), and two, that Polanski might lack the ability to properly handle such a subject.
I dunno, I didn't see anything particularly Scorsesian about Chinatown's big bads. Noah Cross was a devious scumbag, and it was pretty clear by the end of the film that he was supposed to be a devious scumbag. There was nothing "ambiguous" about the turmoil or trauma that Mulwray had suffered. And so, re: Polanski, I don't think there are any particularly glaring negatives that we can pin on his directorship, and if there are any overwhelming positives, then we can simply ignore them, so as to not give a child rapist any credit. Alright, Pam, who seems to think I keep a running list of Me Too villains under my pillowcase?!
Probably the biggest surprise—in terms of my own mediocre experience with Chinatown, against high expectations—was the fact that the overall "point" of the film—if you want to call it that—rests comfortably within one of my favorite themes: "Capitalism=Bad" is probably the most succinct way to put it. In Chinatown, we have our protagonist uncovering a conspiracy of the highest order. The powers that be are diverting water away from the outskirts of L.A., buying the land cheap, then plan on bringing the water back, and selling the land after jacking up the price. It's a sinister plot—one based on a real story—and yet, even after overcoming the odds to uncover the plot, Gittes still is left to stand by wordlessly as the bad guys get away with it, and innocent victims fall by the wayside. In this way, Chinatown is kind of like Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid—the crushing fist of capitalism is unstoppable force and will eventually destroy your way of life.
I mean, I could talk about this shit all day, but the question remains: why didn't it land in Chinatown? For me, at least. And I'm thinking it's because there was just really no ray of hope through any of this. Get past all the frustrations of all the main characters being complicit and helping keep this plot and its various offshoots a secret from the likes of Gittes, only to arrive at the end point that sees yet more bloodshed, senselessly, and without reprieve. Maybe it was just tough watching this after Children of Men, whose trials and tribulations were comparable (in theme if not scale), but a finish line completely antithetical. Maybe I just want hope in my movies. Maybe Chinatown just caught me on the wrong day.
Like I said, it was fine. I didn't dislike it. If my complaints are too specific to my own predilections, well then, welcome to Puke on Your Birthday.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: It's pretty rare that I attempt to watch an adaptation of a book that I've read, but apparently A Clockwork Orange is a worthy one, so we'll see.

No comments:
Post a Comment