Thursday, February 18, 2021

Album Review: New Fragility


Clap Your Hands Say Yeah are a special band. I knew this back at the beginning, when their self-titled, through some weird turn of events, became a big fish in the unknown-sized indie rock pool, ushering in the short-lived "blog rock" era. Anyone could have told you they were a special band back then. I never thought, though, that I'd still be calling them a special band sixteen years later. Kinda wild.

I really do love this band, and I love all six of their LPs, this new one (New Fragility) included. I might not go as far as to say that they are one of my favorite bands, and only that debut album would be included in any sort of "favorite albums" discussion. But they are fucking special. I think this descriptor, "SPECIAL," comes to me for two different reasons.

One, all six of their LPs capture magic in totally unique ways, of which I'll do my best to describe below. I love bands that are able to... I dunno, maybe not reinvent themselves every album, but hang on to what's important throughout the discography while attacking each album in a noticeably new way. I don't discriminate in my appreciation for when bands do this—just a few weeks ago, I gave props to Weezer for doing the same thing, even though it was the only props given for that album.

Unlike Weezer, however, Clap Your Hands Say Yeah is able to make each outfit change meaningful in some way. My theory is that the weight of carrying the torch throughout the meteoric rise and subsequent crash landing of a made-up genre (blog rock) has affected and does still affect CYHSY's music throughout their entire existence. I am probably reading into shit way too much (and I missed an AMA opportunity to ask Alec Ounsworth about it the other day), but I just sense a pervading sense of sadness, or regret, or malaise, or whatever, across a lot of the post-Some Loud Thunder albums. 
 
I can't imagine what it feels like to find success for such a brief time, and then continue to do what you love and try to make a living and for some reason find progressively smaller and smaller audiences each time. That's the sort of melancholy that hits me pretty deep for whatever reason, and it's a melancholy that keeps bringing me back to CYHSY again and again. I'm probably making it up, for the most part—Ounsworth seems pretty content doing what he's doing, even if what he's doing is no longer playing even mid-sized stages, but instead intimate house parties and, once, a Philly Parks on Tap(?!)—but, like, I feel it anyway. I feel that connection, and that makes the music fascinating to me.
 
Clap Your Hands Say Yeah — 2005
 
This is the big one, and I don't blame you if you haven't had any interest in following the band past their landmark mid-'00s masterpiece. Maybe you don't think it was a masterpiece. Maybe you think that the internet blogs were just gaining enough power and influence to lift any album to ubiquity and that they chose this album at random. I don't believe that's true, but I could see the argument. For me, I see an album with hooks, with drama, with a uniqueness brought to you mostly by introducing the mercurial vocals of Ounsworth (might have overshot the point where I should mention that CYHSY is Alec Ounsworth at this point, and no one else, though it was a legit band in 2005). There's also a chance that this album just hit me at the right time, right around when I was getting the music-listening gears in my head going, and it just coincidentally became a seminal album for me via timing only. Fine, okay. But you can't really argue that this is an "important" album, even if you're being dismissive. And if you want to know what Clap Your Hands Say Yeah sounds like, you obviously start here.

Some Loud Thunder — 2007

This is the album that makes me consider the fact that maybe Ounsworth never really felt comfortable with fame in the first place. It's a classic "let's frustrate the audience we have built" move—everyone always remembers this album as the one that "sounds like shit," sonically. Again, fair. The recording process seems to have been purposefully muddled, to the point that Ounsworth often feels like he is singing through a tin can on a string. Otherwise, the hooks are still here—"Underwater (You and Me)" and "Yankee Go Home" especially are top-tier indie rock songs. Which means that the "difference" on Some Loud Thunder is that, while the self-titled was bright and poppy and easily digestible, this one is purposefully difficult. I love it for that, but I can't really blame anyone for bailing at this point (and millions and millions of people did bail).

Hysterical — 2011

And then, four years too late, we have the big swing-for-the-fences album. Better late than never, I say. Some of these songs are huge, more towering than anything that had come before it. Like, it starts off with the absolute monster "Same Mistake," and you get the sense that the band is finally playing toward the cheap seats like they could've in the mid-aughts... but now those cheap seats are empty. I'm intrigued by all of this. I love the idea that CYHSY knows exactly what they are doing, and they know those seats are empty, and so, these anthems just carry so much more weight. Mistake, or regret? This is the most underrated CYSHY album.

Only Run — 2014

So the debut worked, the follow-up purposefully didn't, and the third album fronted like it was trying but knew that it didn't (or couldn't). So the fourth album in the discography, Only Run, is an album of retreat. It's an album that exists in a dark corner. There's pain and regret, and there are no anthems this time to mask any of it. My favorite is the cameo by Matt Berninger, and not just because it's Matt fucking Berninger—more so because of the fact that it harkens back to the infamous gigs back in 2005 when CYHSY was opening for the National, and the crowd would leave after CYHSY was finished, leaving the National playing to empty concert halls. Like I said, Ounsworth knows exactly what he's doing, and by getting Berninger to sing on a song on Only Run, it's an explicit acknowledgment of how truly reversed their situations are, years later. So I see Only Run as not only an album filled with pain and regret, but also as an album of acceptance.

The Tourist — 2017

And so if we have acceptance, then there's not much more you can do but play the goddamn music. That's what The Tourist is. It's not a "return to roots" or whatever, because the hooks are a lot more low-key and less busy than they were on the debut. But the hooks are there, front and center, in all their fucking simple weirdness. I'd argue that The Tourist is special because it doesn't try to be special. It just tries to be a good album with good tunes. And it succeeds. Any acknowledgment of CYSHY's status or lot in life is this time implicit instead of explicit.

New Fragility — 2021

This album was released six days ago (finally!), and so I'm still somewhat soaking it in. But there are two things that are immediately evident in my dozens of listens this week. One, CYSHY motherfucking did it again—they managed to add a whole new layer to the classic Clap Your Hands sound. This time, the album is heavy on the strings, giving the album higher stakes than The Tourist, and matching the intensity of Hysterical but in a completely novel (for them) way. Two, this is the album where Ounsworth really starts leaning on the "sad nostalgia" aspect that, in my opinion, was always there, but may have been a bit obscured from view. There's even a song called "CYHSY, 2005," which, c'mon, is pretty obvious, even though the lyrics attempt to be coy. I hear in other songs the band returning to sounds from previous albums. The toy-piano plinking from the self-titled returns in "Mirror Song," the finale "If I Were More like Jesus" sounds like it was recorded during the Some Loud Thunder sessions, quality-wise.

So New Fragility succeeds in that it simultaneously travels in opposite directions: it manages to aspire to a new sound in general, but also poignantly calls back to what made the original sound so successful in the first place. Plus you have the tension between the two, how maybe Ounsworth will never be finished trying to escape that original sound, and how much he realizes that, no matter the orchestral strings or whatever the fuck else, he can never escape that shadow.

Like I said, Clap Your Hands will probably never be one of my favorite bands, but honestly, they might be the most fascinating band to me. Even if their albums weren't such fun for so many different, constantly changing reasons, I'd still never stop following them every step of the way.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments: