I. This is Jay Electronica's debut album, even though his first single was released on 2009. That is an insane gap between the start of one's career and the release of a statement via an album. You can interpret the wait from two different angles. One is that the pressure of releasing his debut got to him and made him procrastinate, so we should consider whether A Written Testimony lives up to the compounded hype? The other is that maybe the wait was purposeful, in which case we should consider whether A Written Testimony has a message worth relaying after so many years of (relative) silence?
II. Probably the most surprising thing about A Written Testimony is how prevalent Jay-Z is throughout. It was surprising because he was wholly uncredited. Why he's uncredited is probably up for debate, but I'd guess that he simply didn't want to upstage Jay Electronica on his own debut album. Which is another debate. I would probably argue that Jay-Z does a better job than Jay Electronica on every track he appears on (eight of the nine actual songs), but don't take my rap-ignorant ass's word for it.
III. And the reason why I like Jay-Z bars better than Jay Electronica's mostly has to do with subject matter, so YMMV on this one too. But it's pretty clear that Jay E. is really into his faith. He is a member of the Nation of Islam, and his rapping underlines that fact many times.
IV. First, a general thought: I don't necessarily take issue with a musician injecting their faith into their lyrics, but it's really just not something I'm interested in. I mean, you could conceivably compare Jay Electronica to any number of Christian Rock bands, right? Different beliefs, but the same in that those beliefs are front and center. I respect everyone's religious beliefs inasmuch as they are beliefs that perpetuate either goodness or at least simple introspection. I don't necessarily need to hear about anyone's beliefs, and certainly not as often as Jay Electronica wants me to hear them.
V. But that leads me to a more specific thought: is the belief system of the Nation of Islam one that radiates goodness and positive change? I wouldn't claim to know even 1% of what I would need to know to make such a judgment, but from what little I have been able to glean from cursory Wikipedia page-scanning, it seems like there is at least some controversy surrounding their beliefs in general, and the beliefs of their leaders.
VI. Specifically: Louis Farrakhan is not only praised a couple times on the album, but is also featured in the first two tracks. I'm less concerned about Farrakhan's so-called "anti-whiteness racism," and more concerned with the fact that this dude is definitely an anti-Semite. Like, outwardly so, at least according to multiple monitoring groups such as the Southern Poverty Law Center. And I don't think that Jay Electronica really deserves to be given any exception here, in so prominently displaying this man's words. I've always say that trump supporters might not be donning the white hoods, but their support of an outward racist is just as bad as being a racist. So whether Jay Electronica displays any obvious antisemitism in A Written Testimony is besides the point; his support of Farrakhan speaks volumes.
VII. If this is something that concerns you, it's probably best that you do your own research, and don't take my word for it, because, like I said, my own research was pretty limited, and I definitely am the type of person to jump to conclusions. But this whole thing definitely reminded me of what happened with the Eagles' DeSean Jackson last year, when he quoted Hitler. Intention doesn't really even matter in such a situation. You might not intend to be antisemitic, but that doesn't mean you aren't antisemitic.
VIII. (Oh yeah, and I tried to see if there was any connection between the Nation of Islam and the Black Israelites who (used to?) yell angry vitriol at passersby in Center City, mainly so I had an excuse to post one of my favorite things from recent Philadelphia history. But I dunno, if they are related, it's a distant offshoot.)
IX. All that aside (which for many is a big ask, I know), then I'm inclined to be interested, lyrics-wise, in the fact that Jay Electronica's bars just have so many words I don't know. I mean, this is the like the opposite of Innanet James' road head. It's dense, and absolutely requires notations (and many times, translations) to really "get." From a purely lexical perspective, consider me impressed.
X. The production is more hit-or-miss, but leaned more toward the "hit" side of things the more I listened to the album. Something like "The Neverending Story" seemed too lightweight and intangible on first listen, but eventually grew on me (the only song on the album produced by a guy named The Alchemist—hey, I guess I finally understand what Earl Sweatshirt meant in that verse on Danny Brown's Atrocity Exhibition... sorry, deep cut for all you Record Clubbers out there).
XI. And then something like "Shiny Suit Theory" or "Flux Capacitor" were busy, but almost too busy? Sometimes it felt like I was at a concert listening to live music while some random dude is standing next to me whispering in my ear about the church he goes to—it was just a little disorienting. Didn't help that Electronica seemed like he was a little off the beat sometimes?
XII. I'm mostly inclined to give the production the benefit of the doubt here. There's enough interesting moments throughout that I stayed invested throughout. Like the accordion on "Ghost of Soulja Slim," or the dragging synths / off-kilter rhythm in "Ezekiel's Wheel," it kept me off-guard in mostly good ways.
XIII. So we can return to the hip hop quadrant I talked about with The Lost Boy, even though maybe I've somewhat outgrown that. With A Written Testimony, we have mostly fascinating production, mostly skilled rapping that is outshone consistently by a A-list guest star, and lyrics that are compelling but only on a surface level. What to make of all this?
XIV. Maybe it's best to just ignore everything I said and focus on the fact that Jay-Z seems to make his conclusions about the infamously obtuse series ending to The Sopranos clear in his "Universal Soldier" verse: "I was trying not to end up like Tony in the restaurant." The implication being that Jay-Z believes that Tony Soprano was killed, and that's why the screen went blank. It is important to know where all our musical artists stand in this argument!! (And yes, it's possible that he is referring to Tony Montana in Scarface, as apparently there is a restaurant scene in that movie too, but I'm going to err on the side of The Sopranos, since Jay Electronica later on makes a True Blood reference, and I'd like to this that they are trying to stay consistent with the HBO shout-outs.)
XV. At least one full puke deducted, as always, for any references to Jimmy Fallon. Sorry, "The Blinding," ya fucked up. (Yes, I know Electronica's sister is named "Falon," and the line is a double entendre. Doesn't matter. You're still invoking Jimmy Fallon's name too, and that's a paddlin'.)
XVI. We could parse through these lyrics all day, which is part of the fun. But that might be the only part of A Written Testimony that you could describe as such. The religious weight is an albatross, the iffy connotations of the involvement of religious leaders is uncomfortable at best, and the production is occasionally sublime but mostly just messy. I thought separating my thoughts numerically might help. It didn't.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment