I'm working my way through a list of movies I've never seen before. You can find the list HERE. I'm doing this shit alphabetically. Let's go.
The Blair Witch Project
1999
It's probably unfair to use "how much did this scare me" as a metric for how much we appreciate a horror movie. However, that was my first thought before popping The Blair Witch on the TV. Traditionally, I have never been "afraid" while watching a horror movie. This makes me sound like a dull person, but it's true. It's a combination of 1) knowing that fear is a primal response to the belief that you are in danger, 2) knowing that the act of watching a film could never actually put me in physical danger, and 3) knowing that the world is a coldly logical place and that the supernatural beings that exist in horror movies could never possibly exist in our own world, all adding up to say: There's nothing to be afraid of.
I'm talking about fear, specifically, though. This isn't to say that movies cannot evoke any emotional response from me. Of fucking course they do. There's empathy primarily, and then joy, disappointment, disgust, frustration, amusement, and so on (and not in that order). The fictional movies that we discuss in this column—the good ones, anyway—are able to trick you into feeling these very real emotions about subjects and characters that don't exist.
Horror movies can trick you into feeling a sense of fear. That's what a "jump scare" is, basically. For a split second, maybe because of a sudden movement or a loud noise or a surprising sudden reveal, you are sincerely scared for your life. Of course I've been frightened in this sense by many movies, but I guess my point is that I don't consider that a worthy emotion to feel while watching a movie. For one, it's not a lasting feeling; you feel fear for the briefest of moments before the safe reality of "I'm watching a movie" immediately returns. For another, it's cheap. Anyone can scare someone by making a loud noise. The emotion isn't earned. This isn't good filmmaking.
Other questions are way more important to me, both in movies in general and (for the purposes of this blog post) horror movies specifically. Do we actually give a shit about the characters/victims? Do we take joy in their joy? Do we fear for them (though not necessary with them)? Can we apply the lessons found in their struggles to the struggles that we face in our day-to-day lives? Is the movie memorable? Are the characters memorable? And so on. A movie can't win empathy for its characters through parlor tricks. It is hard-earned, and only certifiably good movies pull off the task.
All this to say that The Blair Witch Project did not scare me in the slightest, The Blair Witch Project intrigued me and made me feel empathy in ways I did not expect at all, and The Blair Witch Project was a certifiable good movie.
The story behind 1999's surprise independent hit film is almost as fun as watching the movie itself. Two guys—Daniel Myrick and Eduardo Sánchez—were watching scary true-life documentaries in the '90s, and realized that they were more scared when they watched those than whenever they watched actual fictional horror movies. They sought to bring that experience to a horror film. To achieve this goal, they hired three unknowns, taught them how to work cameras, and then let them wander in the woods for days.
There wasn't a script, but more so a guide as to how the movie should go. All the dialogue you hear in the movie is improvised, and many times the scares were real (that's the directors shaking the tent, unbeknownst to the actors). All the frustrations that come out in those tense "we're at the same log!" scenes were real emotions—the actors really were lost, and hungry, and yeah, a little scared. I know I've seen a million parodies of it in the past two decades, but man, when Heather gives that teary-eyed monologue at the end, it still sent chills up my spine. So fucking good!
Much is made in various retrospectives one can find on the internet (the 20th anniversary of this movie being only last year, there are a bunch) about how this may have been the first "viral" movie marketing campaign in history. Instead of movie posters, there were "Missing Persons" posters, alleging that The Blair Witch Project is an actual story, composed of real, nonfictional found footage, and the actors are legitimately missing.
It's a campaign that, because of the ubiquity of the internet these days, can absolutely never be repeated, but apparently, at the time, it was wildly successful. Asking Pam—who is older than me, and was in 9th grade when this came out—she claims that she and her friends really did believe the urban legend. This was fucking real. These three young adults were actually never seen again. And that made it so much more scary.
I personally didn't need to be fooled by a brilliant marketing strategy to appreciate the very real frights that can be found in The Blair Witch Project. The movie works best because it never really shows you what you are supposed to be afraid of. You hear creepy things, you think you might see something through the darkness, and the actors are so believable that you believe them when they say there is a reason to be afraid.
My first reaction was that of blue balls—after 80 minutes of ratcheting up the tension, there is seriously going to be no release?! But in the days since I've seen this movie for the first time, I think that lack of release has worked in its favor. I just have this gnawing sensation that I missed something, that there is more to this movie than I picked up.
I know there's not (i.e. this isn't one of those times when I think I'm too dumb to "get" the movie), but the fact that I feel it anyway, that creepiness around the edges of my life, speaks volumes about how fucking great this movie is. Like, I know plot-wise why Mike is standing in the corner at the end of the film, but something about it is still so mysterious and unsettling that I can't help but ponder about it, still.
There are movies that I regret having not watched when I was younger, but I don't think this is one of them. I'm glad I waited 21 years to see it. I think if I saw The Blair Witch Project when I was eleven (or fifteen, or nineteen, or whatever), I would've misinterpreted its brilliance. I might have even asked a dumb question like "Why don't we see the Blair Witch?" I'm old enough now to understand that that isn't the point. To show the monster would've been to ruin the movie magic.
I wish more horror movies would take after The Blair Witch Project's example. I know this makes me lame, but I really do think that monsters in scary movies are by and large hokey and dumb and not scary at all. But if you don't show the monster, then I can't judge. If you don't show the monster, then the scare isn't wasted—instead, it lingers. If we never see the Blair Witch, then how do we know she's not still out there?!
GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: Gonna be weird seeing Gene Wilder in anything other than Willy Wonka, but let's try it with Blazing Saddles.

No comments:
Post a Comment