This is at once an appreciation post for a Christmas album that I have grown more fond of over the past couple years, and also an appreciation post for my wife's undying enthusiasm for that same Christmas album. Yes, of course, I am speaking about It's Christmas All Over by the Goo Goo Dolls.
I'll admit that I like the album. I didn't when I reviewed it two years ago for Puke on Your Birthday, but opinions can change, especially with holiday music. The more you hit Play, the more they become associated with some of the best moments of the year. I can now say that when I hear the Goo Goo Dolls covering a Tom Petty Christmas song, it makes me feel good, and it makes me happy, due mainly to its strong bond with my annual seasonal elation.
Pam, on the other hand, knew it from the start. She'll be quick to tell you that her favorite Christmas album of the 21st century is It's Christmas All Over by the Goo Goo Dolls. My appreciation for her love of this album is twofold. First, I love when Pam loves something. It's infectious. Her joy brings me joy. Second, I really appreciate a good bit, and though she'll never admit it, I think she knows too that heaping any inordinate praise on a band like the Goo Goo Dolls, here in 2022, is fucking hilarious. Loving this album can simultaneously be the absolute truth and absolutely humorous.
Pam, on the other hand, knew it from the start. She'll be quick to tell you that her favorite Christmas album of the 21st century is It's Christmas All Over by the Goo Goo Dolls. My appreciation for her love of this album is twofold. First, I love when Pam loves something. It's infectious. Her joy brings me joy. Second, I really appreciate a good bit, and though she'll never admit it, I think she knows too that heaping any inordinate praise on a band like the Goo Goo Dolls, here in 2022, is fucking hilarious. Loving this album can simultaneously be the absolute truth and absolutely humorous.
I guess there's a third fold, too—I think it's really swell to be able to talk about music with my wife. Discussing music makes me feel unalone, and I appreciate the opportunities I get to do that through Record Club, but it's a sincere joy to be able to do it at home as well, in person and in the small moments of otherwise silence throughout the day. That's not a seasonal thing—I appreciate it all year 'round, this gift my marriage provides—but I really appreciate it during the Christmas season, when music seems especially poignant and important, and inspires the music critic deep within us to come to the surface and drop some strong opinions.
All this to say that there's a time every year between Thanksgiving and my birthday that I find myself sitting at the dining room table discussing the merits of the Goo Goo Dolls' Christmas album from 2020. I love it, and I always will—the discussion, I mean, though the album itself is pretty good too.
No comments:
Post a Comment