Friday, December 16, 2022

RENAISSANCE, Joe


Every week spent with a mainstream pop album feels important to me and my personal development. It's just a different feeling, emerging from indie rock isolation and having to acknowledge the scale of something that is "popular" according to known metrics. It's occasionally been a struggle, I'm not going to lie. I've come a long way in the past four years, but still, even after all this time, there's this prevailing sense of discomfort when engaging with Billboard toppers. Pop music brings out my misanthropic tendencies. The thought process, unavoidably, becomes obsession with what that popularity means, and how something could not possibly be special, artistic, worthy, whatever, if this many people like it.

In many ways, Beyoncé feels like the the final boss at the end of this personal journey. She is the most. The most popular, the most talented, the most beautiful, the most creative, the most successful, the most likely to push boundaries, but also the most likely to irk me, the most antithetical to what I like most in music, the most challenging pop artist to engage with on a personal level, the most baffling in the context of what I assume pop music to be.

I could say toward the beginning of the review here that I like RENAISSANCE. I feel like that would be an understatement already. I like it a lot. I listened to it many times this week, and it never got old. I like it enough that I take no issue with the apparently universal consensus that it was the best album of the year (in that I don't agree that it is, but it's good enough that the assessment sits comfortably with me anyway). RENAISSANCE makes me feel good, honestly, which is the baseline that one should judge all music.

But I'd be lying to you if I called it "perfect." That's something that a insane person, who would call themselves a "member of the Beyhive," might say, and that makes me really uncomfortable. There's a lot on RENAISSANCE that makes me feel uncomfortable. Not necessarily the music, which is fantastic, but the context in which the music exists currently. If we're talking about my own personal journey (which may elicit eyerolls from certain readers, but c'mon, it's been 202 weeks now, you know at this point how I conduct myself in this space, and how I understand the idea of an album review), then I cannot discount the negatives, even if they may seem cursory, unimportant, too personal, or unfair.

I'm saying this now because I don't want you to read this review and get the wrong idea. I'm not talking shit because I'm building a case against Beyoncé. In fact, it's kind of the opposite. I'm talking shit because I'm trying to explain my process on how I was converted from talking shit to accepting the glory of the music. I read my old reviews sometimes and think that I come off as too negative; I know from my wife that sometimes that negativity gives the wrong impression. Don't get the wrong impression here, please. It's important for you to know that I like RENAISSANCE. I'm not scared of Beyoncé's stans. They can lemming their way off a cliff as far as I'm concerned. I'm doing this for me, and me only.

It's probably important, first and foremost, to sit with that initial idea of "too popular" for a paragraph or two. I already grappled with the idea a couple weeks ago when we talked Taylor Swift, and I feel the same way with Beyoncé. This is a flaw that I constantly have to address in the pop music reviews. The flaw is that I have this reflex in which I push away anything that everyone else seems to pull toward themselves. This is contrarianism in action. It's not fair to the artist, of course, that I would base at least a piece of my opinion on how the intended audience is already reacting to the music. The flaw is egotistical, for sure, because it means I assume that I am "special." I now know I'm not special, despite what my second-grade teacher told me. I'm just some fucking guy, and why should Beyoncé sacrifice her popularity to make me feel special? It doesn't make sense. And yet that instinct is so baked within my psyche that I can't shake it, even now.

This is the first way I find value in RENAISSANCE—it is good enough that it manages to disarm me. It's good enough that I feel comfortable joining in the chorus of praise. That's another aspect of the flaw, I think. It's that letting go of the armor you've built around yourself over the years is really hard to do. It's hard for me to address the defense mechanism before I get defensive. I listen to the music, I realize that everyone in America is listening to the music, and my knee-jerk reaction is to say "I'm better than this." I'm not! I'm just some asshole! The collectivism of RENAISSANCE helps me feel comfortable enough to get lost in the crowd.

I don't have to say that Beyoncé is popular. That's a given. I wonder sometimes why that is, though. The music is real good—innovative but approachable. But then so is a lot of music. Why Beyoncé? Well, she knows how to sell herself too. I think that's an issue I've taken with her music in the past, as well as many other artists who tend to lean on this particular subject matter a lot. It's, like, kind of lacking in humility? Sigh... I hate myself whenever I bring this up, but I always feel like I'm past this criticism, and then it sneaks up behind me and ensnares me again.

197 weeks ago, I used Beyoncé's name to prove a similar point about Lizzo, how it wasn't a flaw to have a positive perception of self, but it was a flaw to have to flaunt that self-perception. And worse, to have to market it to consumers. Positive self-image as a brand, basically. I hate it. Lizzo is particularly shameless about the ploy, but artists like Beyoncé play into it as well. I wonder how many people were listening to RENAISSANCE this summer while sipping coffee out of their Boss Bitch™ coffee mugs.
 
It's better than one of the alternatives, of course. Letting the trolls talk sexist shit, being okay with negative and harmful and toxic self-images, doing nothing to build self-esteem in the audience. Obviously I'll take Beyoncé's name-brand and sweatshop-produced Feminism over any absence of Feminism. It still just makes me uncomfortable that we as a society can't have equity and positive self-worth without it being connected to the large-scale act of filling Beyoncé's coffers. Honestly, at times, I think I agree with bell hooks, who called Beyoncé's brand of feminism an act of "terrorism." Beyoncé, and many other pop artists, equate empowerment with capitalism. It makes me feel icky.

So credit where it's due regarding RENAISSANCE specifically—it felt sincere in a way that other Beyoncé releases never have for me. If I were to best guess as to why it's different this time around, I'd say that there was a great emphasis on the "we" over the "me" with this album. This time, her music feels like an invitation to join her in the tent, whereas before it was more "I am cool enough to enter the tent, and here's how you can be too, for just six easy payments of $19.99!"

And, on top of that, let's consider the fact that me implying that Beyoncé is a terrorist and bell hooks implying that Beyoncé is a terrorist are two completely different things. I am a white male whose self-confidence was born of his intense privilege. Who the fuck am I to say that Beyoncé's particular brand of self-empowerment, regardless of the capital involved, wasn't sincerely helpful to anyone in any particular situation? Right? So I had that thought while listening to RENAISSANCE.

But I also had the thought that maybe I was the one feeling out of place this time around, being really unfamiliar with house music in general, and so Beyoncé making this album felt to me like she was making this genre more accessible to people like me. I feel comfortable now. So if I work backwards, then that same theory can be applied to previous output that felt like it was "lacking humility." Obviously Beyoncé's music has connected with people all over the world, and we can logically assume that many of those audience members felt better about themselves after hearing Beyoncé talk highly about herself. It's an invitation to feel better either way. It's a net positive either way.

What I think RENAISSANCE does is forsake humility for pure joy. For the first time in a long time, I appreciate that decision. This, despite the fact that the album was framed as a "COVID lockdown album," which annoys the shit out of me at this point. It makes sense logically that an artist would get anxious while stuck at home, and would want to create something that evokes opposite feelings—communal release on the dance floor, and so on. But here in 2022, the description seems woefully out of touch, now that we're long past normalizing COVID deaths and as a country will never commit to any sort of lockdown ever again because we're all just fucking numb to the horrors of the rapid spread of disease. Plus, imagine being an insanely fucking rich person trying to pretend that what you experienced was anything like what me and my peers experienced. It's fucking insulting, honestly.

Again, RENAISSANCE is so good that I was able to kind of reframe this opinion as well. Even if the Lockdown Album narrative is based in truth, then that's not necessarily how I have to interpret the album. I can think of it in more general terms. This is an album about escape. Naming a specific thing to escape from (lockdown) was unnecessary. This is about escape, and about how you can find that escape when you let loose and have fun with the people you care about in an environment that is conducive to all those things. Again, specifically, the dance floor is named, but not necessary. It could be anywhere. RENAISSANCE could be an album for when you, say, step out into the fresh air for the first time in over three days of getting puked on by an infant. It could be an album for sitting around the dinner table with your family, and your two older kids actually finish their dinners for once, and you and your wife celebrate by drinking one single winter lager each. We escape when we feel comfortable in our own skin (i.e. cozy). That escape is set to a thumping disco beat.

If we're going with that theory, then that would mean anything specific about RENAISSANCE might seem like a negative to me, right? And that possibility doesn't sit right with me either. Like, the whole album is designed to emulate some very specific musical styles and themes—1970s Black dance music, arranged like a DJ mix. What, am I saying that I'm supposed to dismiss all that because I don't know anything about it?

Nah, of course not. Again, Beyoncé invites us into this world. The important thing here is that she's not just doing her own version of Black dance music, but she's inviting Black and queer pioneers under that tent with her, to guide her. In that way, she's a middleman—get legends like Grace Jones, an artist I have never heard of, to actually play on the album, and then because it's Beyoncé, an artist I have obviously heard of, the music is actually able to reach my ears in a way that it hadn't before. I'm not dismissing this genre is because I'm not familiar with it; I'm embracing it because I'm learning so much, and that's a worthwhile pursuit.

Whereas a couple years ago I'm dismissing something similar like Kaytranada, Beyoncé makes it palatable. More than palatable—she makes it really fucking enjoyable in a way that I never knew was possible with these genres. I'm not saying I was wrong, I was just ignorant. Beyoncé has shown me the way, and has inspired some more music listening along these lines in the future.

I think that's really what all of these concerns stem from, the being unlearned about something, and the being uncomfortable when you're in an unfamiliar situation. Or maybe not. Because I've been thinking a lot about RuPaul's Drag Race a lot these past few days, and I hear a lot of the music on the program in RENAISSANCE, at least in spirit. And I by and large hate the music that soundtracks Drag Race. At least the RuPaul originals, anyway (though some of the other stuff too).

I've spent a lot of time trying to justify that opinion, that it's not the show that I dislike, or the queens featured on it, and it's not in any way me being uncomfortable with the art of drag, or anything like that. I'm a big fan of the art, and I support anyone who chooses to practice that art. But the music RuPaul chooses is so fucking bad. Took me till this week to understand that it was because most of the music he creates is a pastiche of actual good music, i.e. the music that Beyoncé embodies here. This is good music, occasionally parodied by a bad musician (RuPaul). I think Ru might be in on the joke? Maybe?! Regardless, I could see in my mind some of my favorite drag queens strutting down the runway to the sounds of like "ALIEN SUPERSTAR," and for the first time in a long time, I didn't cringe.

The final challenge to me was a simple one: the length. Everything over an hour is going to test my patience, because I am a millennial who is addicted to his phone and needs everything now now now. Obviously that is a problem beyond the scope of Beyoncé, and it's not her fault. Like, I was all ready to come in here saying "it's good but it kind of slows down at the end." That's not even true though! RENAISSANCE stays strong pretty much till the very end. Like, on any other album, the intense 'AMERICA HAS A PROBLEM" would sound tired toward the back end. And then consider "PLASTIC OFF THE SOFA," the only song that one could reasonably call "slower." But even that has a thumping disco beat that doesn't let the energy drop. So yeah, anything over an hour remains tough, but RENAISSANCE once again manages to be an exception to the rule.

I hope I've done a satisfactory job of explaining where I'm coming from, and where Beyoncé has me going. There are real concerns here, concerns that I think literally any other album would be overshadowed by. But with this album, RENAISSANCE, all worries cease, or at least move far into the background for a little bit. For the braggadocio that manages to come off as communal joy, we have "COZY," which turns the first-person pronouns of "I'M THAT GIRL" into the third person: "she's a god / she's a hero." For any stupid concerns about popularity, we have "BREAK MY SOUL," a song that managed to be the most popular song in America while also being really fun (especially in the context of the album) and bringing something unique to the pop music table. For the now-cliché "lockdown album" conceit, the undeniable truth of the matter overshadows any potential banality—"ENERGY" and the line "Look around, it's me and my crew," and how much, yes, sure, energy comes from that type of situation; "MOVE" and the intense power that one can feel by letting loose on the dance floor. For the concerns about feeling left out, I'm learning something new about music, how songs like "CUFF IT" and "AMERICA HAS A PROBLEM" might sound samey on the surface but then in this artist's hands take that shared sound to opposite ends of the spectrum, horny disco for the former and hard-knuckled Miami bass for the latter. Fuck any concern I had about this thing going into the week.

This isn't "just another fucking pop album." Beyoncé and her legion of collaborators take real risks here. They respectfully plunder the niche music of yesteryear with its subculture's blessing. This thing is a beast, a great thumping thing that doesn't let up for over an hour and still never really overstays its welcome. I really like it.

I like it mostly because it's a mirror. I'm not saying it's humble, but I'm saying that it gives me the ability to assess my own humility, or lack thereof. My own flaws, I mean, both in life and in listening to and appreciating music. I really wanted to hate this album, and I maintain that there are many reasons why one probably could. But I cannot. I cannot hate RENAISSANCE. I cannot do anything but love it. Which is more than I've ever said about any pop album in Record Club history. So that's something.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments: