Thursday, March 7, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 30: Maeve

Prompt: "The best song on your favorite record"

Selected by Maeve


"Cool About It"
boygenius

Just a brief lil tl;dr from my "worst song" post, since they might come out in reverse order: I was going to pick Rumours... but then shockingly, my sister, who has a ton of shared memories and tastes, went with that album, and I'm nothing if not the older sister (a.k.a. refusing to copy her). If I was being true to myself, I'd say my other favorite album is probably My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. It was so seminal to who I am. But unfortunately, that is just going to be something I say and don't go into any further. It ain't worth the time nor effort. 

Keeping up with the bit, I'm trying to write about every song off the record, and this prompt makes sense, since it's a truly no-skips album. I've already written about "Not Strong Enough," "True Blue," "Without You Without Them," "Letter to an Old Poet," "$20," and "Revolution 0." This leaves only six songs, and unfortunately, I love them all. Picking the "best" option is truly tricky. I thiiiink I'm going to have to go with "Cool About It." Granted, I did write about this song during my album review last year. 

At that time, I wrote: "'Cool About It' is perfect (to me), and absolutely cuts me like a knife. I can't remember the last time I've stopped in my tracks listening to the lyrics of a song and been hit so hard. It's like listening to an emo song of yore, but over a Simon & Garfunkel melody." I stand by that. And I would say, they almost hit even harder than before, when the boys harmonize singing, "I can walk you home and practice method acting." Woof. Did I ask a guy to walk me home last summer and was turned down!! Imagine if he had softened that rejection blow and practiced method acting?! I certainly would have not been as hurt. 

Also, I feel like it's a pretty universal experience to casually hang out with someone from your past and deeply feel the lyrics, "I'll pretend being with you doesn't feel like drowning / Tellin' you it's nice to see how good you're doing / Even though we know it isn't true." Ugh, Yearlong Song Challenge! Don't make me feel my feelings!!

2 comments:

Joe K said...

What's better, in your opinion, the actual best song on the record, or the best song on Rumours? or the Chris Rock monologue about Kanye teaching his girlfriend how to have sex better???

Galia said...

Totally agree about My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy!!