Prompt: "The worst song on your favorite record"
Selected by Maeve
"Revolution 0"
boygenius
the record, 2023
Okay, so yes, I am typing this delayed and doing it simultaneously with the "best song" feature for tomorrow. This one stumped me. I was going to pick Rumours... but then, shockingly, my sister, who has a ton of shared memories and tastes, went with that album, and I'm nothing if not the older sister (a.k.a. refusing to copy her). If I was being true to myself, I'd say my other favorite album is probably My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. It was so seminal to who I am. But unfortunately, that is just going to be something I say and don't go into any further. It ain't worth the time nor effort.
So here I am, back doing my bit where I try and use all of the songs off the record during this yearly song challenge. I truly believe this, nay, *the* record is no skips. But if I had to choose, it'd be the Beatles-referencing "Revolution 0." It's the slowest and is certainly giving the most "solo Phoebe Bridgers" on the whole album. Which isn't a bad thing—it's just the slightest departure, which I guess is my reasoning for picking it for this prompt??
There seems to be a discourse online about whether this song is about Phoebe's love for Elliott Smith or about her failed relationship with Paul Mescal. Both fit the narrative if you look into it, although the idea of falling in love online does feel more adjacent to Paul. They met on Twitter and ended up briefly engaged. But honestly, I'd rather think about Paul Mescal all day (is it time for a quarterly Normal People rewatch yet?) over Elliot Smith. It just seems like the less depressive choice? Although, please refer to this meme.
I digress... this song is beautiful, haunting, and poignant. The lyrics of "If it isn't love / Then what the fuck is it? / I guess just let me pretend" hit so hard. There's never a way to know how someone else is feeling, but once you hear it's not how someone else is feeling... that is tough, my friends. Many a times, I've just wanted to pretend that what I'm feeling is mutual. But also, this song begins with addressing an "imaginary friend, who lives up in [her] head." We know from the jump that the lyrics are one-sided, depressing wish and prophecy fulfillment, begging them to tell her more, love her, as she writes this requested song for them, whether it's what they want or not.
There seems to be a discourse online about whether this song is about Phoebe's love for Elliott Smith or about her failed relationship with Paul Mescal. Both fit the narrative if you look into it, although the idea of falling in love online does feel more adjacent to Paul. They met on Twitter and ended up briefly engaged. But honestly, I'd rather think about Paul Mescal all day (is it time for a quarterly Normal People rewatch yet?) over Elliot Smith. It just seems like the less depressive choice? Although, please refer to this meme.
I digress... this song is beautiful, haunting, and poignant. The lyrics of "If it isn't love / Then what the fuck is it? / I guess just let me pretend" hit so hard. There's never a way to know how someone else is feeling, but once you hear it's not how someone else is feeling... that is tough, my friends. Many a times, I've just wanted to pretend that what I'm feeling is mutual. But also, this song begins with addressing an "imaginary friend, who lives up in [her] head." We know from the jump that the lyrics are one-sided, depressing wish and prophecy fulfillment, begging them to tell her more, love her, as she writes this requested song for them, whether it's what they want or not.
No comments:
Post a Comment