Saturday, January 6, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 4: Joe

Prompt: "Now that you've established those parameters: a song in between that best song and worst song, in terms of quality"

Selected by Joe


"Fearless"
Fearless, 2008

There's something kind of off-putting about disliking an artist because her hardcore fans are wholly unlikable. Maybe I've indulged in such opinions in the past, like when I was fifteen years old, or more recently. I'm comfortably past that stage now (I think). I totally get the impulse. It's called the Vocal Minority Fallacy. Most fans of any given artist are totally normal people who are completely content to enjoy that artist on their own personal time and find satisfaction from just listening in private. A small subset of those fans are rabid and deranged, willing to lay down their own lives for the artist they adore through some fucked up parasocial relationship, and those are the fans you tend to hear about. (Sidenote: it's a huge problem that we've normalized the term "stan," given its origins.)

No better case study in this phenomenon than Taylor Swift, possibly the most popular artist in the world today. I'm of two minds on this front. The first was covered in my RC album review of Midnights at the end of 2022—the music seems good but not as good as the biggest fans might have you believe. I think that's still true, but that's probably unfair to the music. And then the other side of the coin is that an artist can't reach this galactic level of popularity without having at least some good music, and so the hunt for those gems is almost guaranteed to be worth it to an extent, even if you manage to keep a level head about the affair.

One small 2024 goal I have, music-wise, is to familiarize myself with the Taylor Swift canon. This isn't one of those things where I'm out here trying to "learn" about something I "don't get" or whatever. I get it already. I don't live under a rock. I am familiar with enough Swift songs that I know that this stuff for the most part works as ultra-shiny pop music that at its best can make you feel great in the moment, like a pixy stix through the nostrils, and at its worst, boilerplate pop music I've already heard before. I don't need to walk away from this experience a changed man; I just want to hear some good music that I'm not already familiar with.

I started with Fearless last month, and will probably do one a month for the next six months, not necessarily in chronological order. (Before you ask: yes, I know about the Scooter Braun shit. I fully support artists who are making moves to get paid for their work, even the already mega-rich ones like Swift. Being one of the few people on earth left with a functioning iPod and an aversion to streaming services, I have the luxury of downloading the "Taylor's Versions" and pretending that they are the originals. I'm also ignoring bonus tracks, as always.)

Pretty much exactly what I expected! A bunch of pristine and occasionally immaculate pop songs, and a few decent deep cuts, covering exactly one theme (teenage love), but doing so competently and thoroughly. I don't really know if there is much else to say about the tunes. Songs like "Love Story" and "You Belong with Me" are exactly as good as advertised.

I don't think that Taylor Swift deserves any criticism for her fans' behavior. It's only partially her fault that her songs are good enough and manage to connect with its intended audiences strongly enough that some people go off the deep end, and I don't see much evidence of Swift encouraging any of the worst behavior, at least not explicitly. So I don't think that this should necessarily be a roadblock in enjoying a very good pop CD from the late '00s (especially if you steal it).

I also don't think that Taylor Swift needs any additional cheerleaders in her corner. Maybe that's the worst thing I could possibly say about Swift's music: the best music tends to inspire me to want to tell other people about it, encourage them to feel the same great feelings I do when I listen to it, and I get none of that from this music. Again, not really Swift's fault. It's more like, what more could you people actually want? Your music is the most popular and most profitable music on earth right now. Your goddess is on every tabloid and even some non-tabloid magazine covers. There's no motivation to do good work and spread the good word because every asshole under the sun already knows about Taylor Swift. Her popularity inherently sucks some of the joy out of the very act of musical discovery. Going through her discography, to me, feels somewhat enjoyable but also somewhat perfunctory, like I need to do it instead of wanting to do it.

As far as Taylor Swift on Puke on Your Birthday is concerned, I'm attempting to have my cake and eat it too. There's no doubt a bunch of worthy songs in this lady's albums, and I want to know them, but I also don't feel like I'm going to be writing about it too often. There's not much more to be said that hasn't already been said by any other fucking website on the internet. And Taylor Swift certainly needs no more exposure. It's a little too overwhelming already.

"Fearless" is a really good song surrounded by other really good songs. It's certainly not one of the worst songs, and it'll probably never be one of the best songs. But in between the best songs and the worst songs are millions and millions and millions of songs that are pretty good, and at least good enough that they are worth your time. That's the highest praise I will pay Taylor Swift at this time. After today, don't expect me to fill these Song Challenge blog posts with any other songs from this artist.

3 comments:

Joe K said...

Enjoy today's playlist of Taylor Swift songs.

Boober said...

I thought wow 3 tSwift songs there won’t be anymore… and I did a double take on the name…. Dammit Joe… you didn’t even pick Taylor’s version…

Joe K said...

I guess I should offer a clarification. As I'm making my way casually through the Taylor Swift discography, I'm listening to Taylor's Versions when available. However, I'm picky with how I label songs on my iPod, and I think the parenthetical (Taylor's Version) thing is stupid and tacky, and I refuse to do it. The video I embedded above is the rerecorded version of "Fearless." I've never heard the original. I just refuse to differentiate it from a version of the song I'll never purposefully listen to, and also kinda think at this point would be unethical to listen to in the first place?

But this is just my take on all this, and I'm not a Taylor Swift arbiter if anyone else deigns to choose one of her songs for this challenge.

Okay... NOW I'm going to stop writing about this artist.