Prompt: "A song that mentions someone's astrological sign, either in the title or the lyrics"
Selected by Joe
"Semicircle Song"
The Go! Team
Semicircle, 2018
Thought about using Vampire Weekend's new tune "Capricorn" in this space, but then decided against it. I'm sure it's a great song. Let the record show that the reason I did not choose it is because I have not listened to it yet, or any of the advance singles, which is my m.o. for albums I'm excited about, I wait for the new album to be released before listening to any of the music on it, because I want to listen to it in full, as the artist intended, as an album, so that's why I'm not picking "Capricorn" by Vampire Weekend today...
...and it's NOT because of some other reason. But we can talk about some of those potential, hypothetical reasons, if you want. Or even if you don't want. That's never stopped me before.
Back in October, me and Sunny were chatting for a few minutes about MUNA, and I forget how this even came up, but he said something about "Ezra Koenig being soft-cancelled." That tidbit didn't make the MUNA review, partially because I didn't really know what he was referring to. And if I'm being honest with myself now, I purposefully didn't ask because I didn't want to know. I still haven't asked anyone or intentionally done any searching on the internet, but that kinda shit has a way of finding its way to you eventually. So it did last month, when Miranda Reinert—who unfortunately did not answer my email requesting that she write something for Yearlong Song Challenge—shared some thoughts about Ezra Koenig and the behind-closed-doors allegations. I assume this is what Sunny is referring to. I don't even know if Sunny himself knew what he was referring to, but if he does and this ain't it, then I'm sure I'll get it in the comment section below.
In the meantime, Reinert explained how she had read a personal essay by writer Tavi Gevinson about the time she spent intimate time with an older man (he was 30, she was eighteen) who, after further reflection, had pressured her into having sex, even though all the while telling her that she had the power to stop it any time she wanted, but creating a situation in which she didn't have that power, not really. The antagonist is unnamed in this nonfictional story, but according to the people who would have more information at their fingertips about this kind of shit than I ever would, the facts of the timeline make it pretty reasonable that this is Ezra Koenig who she's talking about.
No matter what else I type here, let's first stop and validate Tavi Gevinson's experience and the emotions she had and has about that experience (and also validate Miranda Reinert's reaction to it, and her reasons for that reaction to it). If someone is saying that they are feeling pressured, or are being harassed, or were at the victim end of a power imbalance, then I believe them. There is never a matter of "needing more proof." The proof is in the words of the person speaking about the experience. That's all anyone should need.
I have chosen—as always, I need to briefly stop here and reiterate that what I am about to say is a completely personal thing and has nothing to do with judging anyone who is faced with similar decisions and has chosen differently—to let these situations, and this type of proof, and this subject of truth, affect my decisions when it comes to selecting art to engage with. If someone says that they are a victim, and they speak out, and the perpetrator is an artist, then I am choosing to not engage with that artist any longer. I mean, it's not really a choice, as it would be personally difficult for me to listen to an album of good music when I know that an abuser made it, so, like, the truth of that situation would make it so that I could never choose that music again. But you get what I'm trying to say. There is no separation of art and artist when it comes to the real bad stuff. There can't be. In my opinion.
There have been plenty of instances in my life in which I make a choice to not listen to an artist anymore because someone indicated that they were a victim of this artist in some tangible way. The victim names the artists, states what they did, I believe them, and then I just don't listen to the music. I myself am NOT a victim. Was it ideal to say that I'm never going to listen to Arcade Fire again (the most life-altering example for me, relatively speaking)? No, it wasn't. And my decision to never purposefully engage with Arcade Fire's music ever again doesn't actually do anything. I'm not stopping further sexual assaults from happening because I deleted Funeral off my iPod. I'm not trying to paint myself as a hero. It might even be the opposite! The fact that I'm writing about this shit yet again on this blog might make me a terrible person, or at the very least an unbearably annoying one!
No matter what else I type here, let's first stop and validate Tavi Gevinson's experience and the emotions she had and has about that experience (and also validate Miranda Reinert's reaction to it, and her reasons for that reaction to it). If someone is saying that they are feeling pressured, or are being harassed, or were at the victim end of a power imbalance, then I believe them. There is never a matter of "needing more proof." The proof is in the words of the person speaking about the experience. That's all anyone should need.
I have chosen—as always, I need to briefly stop here and reiterate that what I am about to say is a completely personal thing and has nothing to do with judging anyone who is faced with similar decisions and has chosen differently—to let these situations, and this type of proof, and this subject of truth, affect my decisions when it comes to selecting art to engage with. If someone says that they are a victim, and they speak out, and the perpetrator is an artist, then I am choosing to not engage with that artist any longer. I mean, it's not really a choice, as it would be personally difficult for me to listen to an album of good music when I know that an abuser made it, so, like, the truth of that situation would make it so that I could never choose that music again. But you get what I'm trying to say. There is no separation of art and artist when it comes to the real bad stuff. There can't be. In my opinion.
There have been plenty of instances in my life in which I make a choice to not listen to an artist anymore because someone indicated that they were a victim of this artist in some tangible way. The victim names the artists, states what they did, I believe them, and then I just don't listen to the music. I myself am NOT a victim. Was it ideal to say that I'm never going to listen to Arcade Fire again (the most life-altering example for me, relatively speaking)? No, it wasn't. And my decision to never purposefully engage with Arcade Fire's music ever again doesn't actually do anything. I'm not stopping further sexual assaults from happening because I deleted Funeral off my iPod. I'm not trying to paint myself as a hero. It might even be the opposite! The fact that I'm writing about this shit yet again on this blog might make me a terrible person, or at the very least an unbearably annoying one!
I think when Sunny said the words "Ezra Koenig" and "cancelled" in the same sentence, I winced, because in that brief moment, I imagined my life without the music of Vampire Weekend. It's pretty important to me. But the sticking point here is that it is not the most important thing. There are other things more important than that. Trying and failing but still trying to be a kind and empathetic person is more important to me, and I just wouldn't be able to do that if I was listening to music made by an artist whose actions I don't agree with on a moral level.
Applying this argument to Vampire Weekend remains in the hypothetical, of course. The story is blurry. It comes into sharper focus through reading Gevinson via Reinert, but still pretty blurry. Here's something I need to write (or rewrite) about at this juncture. How these situations should be victim-centric. I've probably touched on this one too many times on the blog, especially because this was my argument vis-à-vis Phillies alumni and domestic abuser Odúbel Herrera. It does not matter what the abuser has or hasn't done before or since, or what the audience is or is not willing to forgive. None of that matters if we're not listening to the victim, and adhering to their wishes and intentions in this situation. Can abusers be forgiven? Can abusers find their way back into the good graces of the public at large? Of course. But that process has to start with and continue with the victim. It has to, or how can you even say you believe them in the first place?
Now I bring this side of the argument up to say that it is the victims who have the first and last say in these situations, and so we must apply that tenet to the Koenig situation too. We have to consider their (the victims') intentions throughout every step of the process, including the beginning. By "the beginning," I mean when this or any victim bravely professes their truth that they were abused in some way. There's a whole scale of "abuse," but it doesn't matter at what end of that scale the statement comes from. Someone says they were wronged in a tangible way by a perpetrator, and that's the beginning of the thing.
If we're using the Win Butler situation as an example here, then it was multiple victims, some of them on record and some of them anonymous, but they all made a decision to definitively say that Win Butler abused them in such a way. Their intentions, in this case, was to speak the truth, and turn truth into power. Typically, when you indicate that you have been a victim of something or someone, you are seeking to turn imbalance into balance. It's not the "this woman just wants to ruin this guy's career!" shit that I hear sometimes from bad-faith assholes, that's not what I'm talking about. More like, searching for... an apology, or compensation for emotional distress, or even simply to prevent it from happening to other people. We call victims "brave" because there is pushback, of course, but they speak the truth anyway. That really is brave. And so we must be brave too in response, and do what needs to be done to restore the balance that was stripped away in the act of the abuse. Again: justice doesn't happen often, I'm just saying here what should be.
Tavi Gevinson very purposefully did not include Koenig's name in any sort of allegation or accusation. Could be that this is because Gevinson knows what happens to women who are brave enough to come forward about being abused in this cruel and uncaring and dangerous world. It just as likely could be that she understands that she was in an unfortunate situation but has been able to process it in private and was able to restore the balance on her own terms. It could just be that she's choosing not to think about it at all anymore. But the point here is that it's not for us to say, and it's not for us to assume anything. That's not our role. Our role is to believe the victim, and aid in restoring the balance that is due unto them. In this specific case, we have a victim, and I believe her, and she's not saying anything (yet?) about the perpetrator or how she feels about his continued existence. If she says that she was abused, I believe her, but if she doesn't want to say who abused her, then I believe her then too. I believe in her reasoning. I believe in her agency as an adult human being.
I'm not holding my hands on my ears and screaming la la la. I'm here to listen, and then to act accordingly. I am completely and utterly willing to turn my back on any artist who is revealed to be abusive in any way. The music of Vampire Weekend means a lot to me, maybe more than most other music that exists in my lifetime, but if someone told me that its frontman abused them, then I would have no qualms junking that shit for the rest of my life. It would suck, but I'm not the victim in that situation, and it would be pretty pathetic to make it seem like I was.
Applying this argument to Vampire Weekend remains in the hypothetical, of course. The story is blurry. It comes into sharper focus through reading Gevinson via Reinert, but still pretty blurry. Here's something I need to write (or rewrite) about at this juncture. How these situations should be victim-centric. I've probably touched on this one too many times on the blog, especially because this was my argument vis-à-vis Phillies alumni and domestic abuser Odúbel Herrera. It does not matter what the abuser has or hasn't done before or since, or what the audience is or is not willing to forgive. None of that matters if we're not listening to the victim, and adhering to their wishes and intentions in this situation. Can abusers be forgiven? Can abusers find their way back into the good graces of the public at large? Of course. But that process has to start with and continue with the victim. It has to, or how can you even say you believe them in the first place?
Now I bring this side of the argument up to say that it is the victims who have the first and last say in these situations, and so we must apply that tenet to the Koenig situation too. We have to consider their (the victims') intentions throughout every step of the process, including the beginning. By "the beginning," I mean when this or any victim bravely professes their truth that they were abused in some way. There's a whole scale of "abuse," but it doesn't matter at what end of that scale the statement comes from. Someone says they were wronged in a tangible way by a perpetrator, and that's the beginning of the thing.
If we're using the Win Butler situation as an example here, then it was multiple victims, some of them on record and some of them anonymous, but they all made a decision to definitively say that Win Butler abused them in such a way. Their intentions, in this case, was to speak the truth, and turn truth into power. Typically, when you indicate that you have been a victim of something or someone, you are seeking to turn imbalance into balance. It's not the "this woman just wants to ruin this guy's career!" shit that I hear sometimes from bad-faith assholes, that's not what I'm talking about. More like, searching for... an apology, or compensation for emotional distress, or even simply to prevent it from happening to other people. We call victims "brave" because there is pushback, of course, but they speak the truth anyway. That really is brave. And so we must be brave too in response, and do what needs to be done to restore the balance that was stripped away in the act of the abuse. Again: justice doesn't happen often, I'm just saying here what should be.
Tavi Gevinson very purposefully did not include Koenig's name in any sort of allegation or accusation. Could be that this is because Gevinson knows what happens to women who are brave enough to come forward about being abused in this cruel and uncaring and dangerous world. It just as likely could be that she understands that she was in an unfortunate situation but has been able to process it in private and was able to restore the balance on her own terms. It could just be that she's choosing not to think about it at all anymore. But the point here is that it's not for us to say, and it's not for us to assume anything. That's not our role. Our role is to believe the victim, and aid in restoring the balance that is due unto them. In this specific case, we have a victim, and I believe her, and she's not saying anything (yet?) about the perpetrator or how she feels about his continued existence. If she says that she was abused, I believe her, but if she doesn't want to say who abused her, then I believe her then too. I believe in her reasoning. I believe in her agency as an adult human being.
I'm not holding my hands on my ears and screaming la la la. I'm here to listen, and then to act accordingly. I am completely and utterly willing to turn my back on any artist who is revealed to be abusive in any way. The music of Vampire Weekend means a lot to me, maybe more than most other music that exists in my lifetime, but if someone told me that its frontman abused them, then I would have no qualms junking that shit for the rest of my life. It would suck, but I'm not the victim in that situation, and it would be pretty pathetic to make it seem like I was.
But what I'm saying, I guess, is that there is nothing here that is forcing my hand in the matter either way. Other people have claimed that Ezra Keonig was abusive toward this one individual, but the individual in question hasn't said his name once. And I'm going to respect that decision by not forgoing Vampire Weekend as of yet.
Miranda Reinert probably found the right middle ground in her own essay. That maybe in some cases it's not so much a binary of worry-free listening vs. a moral compulsion to never listen again. Maybe it's just something to mull over while you listen. That's probably where I'm at with Pinegrove, albeit for the completely opposite reason. I still listen to Pinegrove and I still hold Cardinal close to my heart, but there's always going to be this slight twinge of regret or confusion or disappointment or something. The wounds are healed but with a scar. Now, I'm listening to Pinegrove because the victim voiced her concerns (against her will, but that's a whole different subsection of the sordid tale), and the frontman of Pinegrove and perpetrator, Evan Stephens Hall, took those concerns completely seriously, and made amends to the full extent that the victim required to balance the universe. With Vampire Weekend, maybe it's that the victim doesn't voice her concerns at all, and so there's technically no concerns for anyone in VW to respond to. If that changed, then things would be different.
But as it stands now, I am okay with the idea of just kinda having all this stuff in the back of my mind while I listen to music that I like, including "Capricorn," the new single from Vampire Weekend, which, again, I haven't heard yet, but NOT for any of the reasons I have speculated upon at any point in between this paragraph and the first paragraph. Maybe Vampire Weekend music is pocked from now on, just a little bit, just a slight deflating of previous excitement, knowing what other people seem to know. I don't know. I don't know how I'll feel about it until I sit down and listen to it, which is not today, but not because of the reasons you might assume, I swear.
In the meantime, enjoy the Go! Team's second-best song. Hi, I'm Joe, and I'm a Sagittarius!!!!! Even though I'm told that Sagittariuses are not like this!!!!! However you choose to describe "this" based on the blog post you just read!!!!!!! Sorry again!!!!!!
Miranda Reinert probably found the right middle ground in her own essay. That maybe in some cases it's not so much a binary of worry-free listening vs. a moral compulsion to never listen again. Maybe it's just something to mull over while you listen. That's probably where I'm at with Pinegrove, albeit for the completely opposite reason. I still listen to Pinegrove and I still hold Cardinal close to my heart, but there's always going to be this slight twinge of regret or confusion or disappointment or something. The wounds are healed but with a scar. Now, I'm listening to Pinegrove because the victim voiced her concerns (against her will, but that's a whole different subsection of the sordid tale), and the frontman of Pinegrove and perpetrator, Evan Stephens Hall, took those concerns completely seriously, and made amends to the full extent that the victim required to balance the universe. With Vampire Weekend, maybe it's that the victim doesn't voice her concerns at all, and so there's technically no concerns for anyone in VW to respond to. If that changed, then things would be different.
But as it stands now, I am okay with the idea of just kinda having all this stuff in the back of my mind while I listen to music that I like, including "Capricorn," the new single from Vampire Weekend, which, again, I haven't heard yet, but NOT for any of the reasons I have speculated upon at any point in between this paragraph and the first paragraph. Maybe Vampire Weekend music is pocked from now on, just a little bit, just a slight deflating of previous excitement, knowing what other people seem to know. I don't know. I don't know how I'll feel about it until I sit down and listen to it, which is not today, but not because of the reasons you might assume, I swear.
In the meantime, enjoy the Go! Team's second-best song. Hi, I'm Joe, and I'm a Sagittarius!!!!! Even though I'm told that Sagittariuses are not like this!!!!! However you choose to describe "this" based on the blog post you just read!!!!!!! Sorry again!!!!!!
1 comment:
This was the drama I was thinking of back when, and despite/because of my prev stated policy of never reading more into things, I hadn’t read more into it.
I still haven’t listened to Time Crisis since, and was hesitant on “Capricorn” for no reason I can really pinpoint. But reading this post, it does a good job in circling the square, thank you. though I’m still not going to read more into things more except at puke on your birthday dot com
Post a Comment