Thursday, March 7, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 30: Joe

Prompt: "The best song on your favorite record"

Selected by Joe


"Party Pit"
The Hold Steady
Boys and Girls in America, 2006

Another reason that Boys and Girls in America is my favorite album—sorry, I guess I'm just gonna go ahead and consider this blog post a continuation from the last one, with no new introduction needed—is that I know every inch of this thing. Home, like Noplace Is There—whose tenth anniversary I have by this point celebrated, listening to that damn thing countless times over a weekend, and shedding more than one tear—is still, all things considered, a bit of a mystery to me. I feel strongly about it because I can reach out and touch and know its unknowns, but I wouldn't be able to describe them. I feel a kinship with it that I can't quite explain yet. That I feel like it's a mystery probably means that I am a mystery to myself, and that feels right too. Figuring this shit out is a lifelong process. I'm not there yet. Don't know if I'll ever be. And I don't know if not understanding the Hotelier's masterpiece means that I can't live it in the same way. I don't know! But I do know Boys and Girls in America. I know it well. And so for today, we are here.

A running theme through all the Favorite Albums of my life—and maybe this is the case for everyone—is that they were, at one point or another, albums that felt like mine. Like a secret. Maybe not a solo endeavor, but more so a secret that we shared. Just the small group of us. Friends and internet strangers, the chosen few who loved this piece of art and spoke in hushed tones about its wonders. When that illusion is broken, it feels weird. You go to a concert or you dive into the comment sections or message boards, and you realize that you are not unique, that are tens of thousands of people who are just like you, and who feel the exact same way that you do about this particular album. It was always pretending, having that secret, but still, when the glass is shattered and you understand in the cold light of day that you are not the main character and instead you're just some fucking dude in an endless sea of countless other dudes, it has a way of affecting the art, or at least your perception of it. The shine is dulled, just a little bit.

The Hold Steady's Boys and Girls in America feels like an exception to this rule, and that's because there was never any semblance of secrecy in this affair. The album—and by extension, the band—was always about community. Not literally like your local neighborhood and its boundaries, but more so the ideals that you share with the misfits from every neighborhood across the country. How these feelings, as they are presented on a rock album, are universal, and how we are all connected. We're connected especially to the bard who is putting these feelings into words, an ironically older man who incredibly manages to speak credibly to the experience of the younger generation. Or, now that I'm thinking about it, maybe that emotional camaraderie stretches across generations too, the drinkers of post-WWI Hemingway connected to the drinkers of countercultural Kerouac connected to the drinkers of the disillusioned Gen-Xers in the mythical Twin Cities connected to us, the millennial drinkers in the woods of Burholme Park.

Yes, "drinkers." That isn't the point of Boys and Girls in America either, but it's a function of the overall story here. How humans of a certain age find freedom in testing boundaries, both those imposed upon by society and those imposed by our own mortal vessels. It would be disingenuous to say that this wasn't a focus, thematically speaking, when I first discovered Boys and Girls in America in the mid-aughts, at the tail-end of high school, just when my idea of "binge drinking" and my idea of "community" were both about to expand significantly. But it wasn't just the drinking, and it wasn't just the freedom of youth through the context of drinking. It was more about... shared pain and shared joy, I guess, and how we often found both, but only when we were together, and yes, more often than not when we were drinking.

Throughout this album, the camera zooms in and it zooms out and it zooms in again on various situations, communal and personal, that its fictional (barely) characters find themselves in. Young people who feel stuck where they are while at the same time feeling like the world is theirs. People making mistakes and brushing it off and pretending its nothing or that it's normal out of some inherent need to fit in or stand out. Large gatherings where everyone comes together and some hard-to-believe insanity is happening on the fringes.

When I say (or said, but definitely say too) that I can relate to the characters in these songs, I don't mean it literally (mostly). I don't visit the horse races, let alone have any friends who are good at betting on horses, but man, have I known some people who seem like they are skating by and living their best lives, and have I for sure felt a pull toward those people, both wonder and contentment, wanting to get a piece of how simple life must seem from that angle. I don't smoke and so I've never made a pipe from a Pringles can, but I can close my eyes and I can picture those can't-miss nights where something weird happens, like pot being smoked from a dented can or an apple core and a thousand other un/forgettable moments that flash by like cars on a highway.

There's a balance on the best songs here. A balance between those universal emotions and the vivid and occasionally bizarre details that carry the weight. This is why "Same Kooks" is the worst song on Boys and Girls in America. The details are too specific, and they lack a higher meaning. The hook of "It was those two same kooks from that one stupid photo shoot" means nothing to me, beyond the fact that its from the hardest and toughest punk rock song on this album. But then you might consider a song like "Massive Nights" as a counterexample. "Massive Nights" means a lot to me, and not just because it was on the mix CD that was stuck in my parents' minivan for a while. This song is all personally grown pathos and "I've been there" memories. "We had some massive nights! / Every summer night!"—perhaps no truer words have ever been written for any chorus before or since. But, if I'm being honest with myself (and too harsh by design), I'd say that maybe that sentiment is too cliché, lacking in any distinguishing details that make the best Hold Steady songs truly the best.

"Party Pit," the song that I've chosen today as my favorite song from this album (though that could change tomorrow, and also recall that the actual best song, "Stuck Between Stations," was ineligible for this exercise by my own self-imposed no-repeats-ever rule), is my favorite song because it strikes this balance the best. It doesn't go overly hard but manages to feel fucking epic. It's a little sad and a little hopeful. And the details are frighteningly specific and real and vivid, and yet the song uses those little details and gathers 'em up and uses their collective weight to give an immense force and forward momentum to maybe the best shout-along-required chorus on an album full of them: "Gonna walk around and drink some more!!!"

You bet your ass that this was shouted at the top of our lungs during that Hold Steady concert in 2018. You bet your ass that this was shouted at the top of our lungs during those many, many sojourns in secluded corners of the neighborhood, growing up. You're at a keg, and that's all you can do. Walk around and drink some more. As it's presented here, it's a little sad, the implication that you're drinking alone, but also a little nostalgically content too, that you're drinking and walking with a destination in mind. The community aspect to it here isn't the act itself, but the fact that we, the listeners, hear the sentiment and can relate. We've all been there, walking around and drinking some more. It's melancholy and bittersweet to hear it now, all these years later.

But see, that's what I was saying last time about rediscovering Boys and Girls in America as my favorite album. It only became my favorite after I found that I was no longer living those moments or a part of that scene (or "scene"). I love it now more than I ever have because there's enough time and space in between who I am and who I was then, enough room that I've been able to process it, pour over it, understand that those were the good times and these are too, that it's not all temporary or fickle, that both can be true at once, that those moments that eventually flowered into lines like "gonna walk around and drink some more" are now a document, proof that we lived those moments, and proof that we can still find community when we hear about them through song and think back to when they existed in the present instead of the past.

As long as I love myself, and as long as I love who I am, and as long as I love where I came from, and as long as I love how my past shaped my present, and as long as I love the intense power that still glows from the embers of a past life, then I will still love the Hold Steady's Boys and Girls in America.

2 comments:

Maeve said...

I love this album so, so much. And as always, really loved reading about it.

Gilson said...

Getting sober has meant looking at a lot of art through new eyes for me, but I am glad that no level of sobriety will ever make me feel above shouting "I'm gonna walk around and drink some more" while this song plays.