Thursday, March 7, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 30: Gilson

Prompt: "The best song on your favorite record"

Selected by Gilson


"Lover, You Should've Come Over"
Jeff Buckley
Grace, 1994

I assume that, for many other people in this project, the most daunting part of this and Day 29's prompt was to actually figure out what your favorite album is. I don't really think I did that though. Since I was probably eighteen, Grace has been the album that I think has stuck with me the most. I think my least favorite song on it is worse than my least favorite song on other albums, and frankly I don't listen to it nearly as much as I listen to Jawbreaker or the Get Up Kids or Pearl Jam. And I don't have the same visceral reaction that I get when I listen to, say, Gang of Youths or Gaslight Anthem or Old 97’s. But I still come back to this record because I think I view it as some sort of platonic ideal of music. 

An NFL writer and podcaster I very much loved, Chris Wesseling (RIP), once said that the reason he loves sports is because, at its peaks, it is a demonstration of what the human body is capable of. To me, Grace is a musical demonstration of the same thing. And this song song is, to me, a perfect song.

3 comments:

Joe K said...

This was on a mix CD that Pam made for me toward the start of our relationship, so it's always gonna be a special song for me. Good pick. Thank you once again for not choosing the Shrek-adjacent song. I'd rather go for a long swim in the Mississippi River than hear that song ever again.

Gilson said...

When I first started listening to Buckley, Hallejulah was my favorite. Objectively, this version is a fucking achievement. But real talk, I was listening to this album the other day and for the first time I skipped it.

Nate said...

When Meagan was in college she went to an open mic night and some kid playing on stage said "this one goes out to my man Rufus Wainright," then started plating "Hallelujah." Some other kid from the back of the room shouted up to the guy playing "That song is by Jeff Buckley!" That experience is a such a rich text, such a funny setup and punchline, that I a compelled to jack her story and share it here.