Quadrophenia
1979
Franc Roddam
About the only similarity between Quadrophenia and the NSI movie coincidentally prior to this, Purple Rain, is that they are both derived from a single album of music, with both pairs of albums and films sharing the same name. To do a comprehensive compare/contrast would be boring, and probably unfair to Quadrophenia, which was seen second due to alphabetical reasons but was released five years prior. The least interesting thing about that compare/contrast exercise would be how I personally feel about either album. I'm barely making a case for anyone to care about the movies I watch today, let alone the albums I listened to when I was younger.
Still, let the record show that I've loved Quadrophenia for a long time, and it's been my favorite Who album for almost as long. It's been so long that I received it for Christmas on CD. Actually, strike that—my Mom Mom, bless her generosity, accidentally bought me the Quadrophenia film soundtrack instead of Quadrophenia the 1973 Who album (some overlap in songs, obviously, but even those songs are John Entwhistle remixes). It was a simple exchange at FYE, and the clerk knowingly smirked when I exchanged it. Though it was only in my possession for a few days, unwrapped, I can easily recall the protagonist Jimmy, played by Phil Daniels, as he slouches on the back cover, clearly a broken man. Took me a couple decades but I'm finally here to find out why Jimmy was so sad.
Still, let the record show that I've loved Quadrophenia for a long time, and it's been my favorite Who album for almost as long. It's been so long that I received it for Christmas on CD. Actually, strike that—my Mom Mom, bless her generosity, accidentally bought me the Quadrophenia film soundtrack instead of Quadrophenia the 1973 Who album (some overlap in songs, obviously, but even those songs are John Entwhistle remixes). It was a simple exchange at FYE, and the clerk knowingly smirked when I exchanged it. Though it was only in my possession for a few days, unwrapped, I can easily recall the protagonist Jimmy, played by Phil Daniels, as he slouches on the back cover, clearly a broken man. Took me a couple decades but I'm finally here to find out why Jimmy was so sad.
I spoke last week about the music film enhancing the music. I wouldn't say that's necessarily the case here, but I do think that it helped clear up one glaring misconception I've always held about Quadrophenia. One of the central conceits of the story is that the protagonist, Jimmy, has a split personality, split four ways. I've always taken that to be literal, and attributed many of the struggles that Jimmy faces throughout the lyrics of the story to his mental illness. But the film has a different take on it. The word "quadrophenia" is never mentioned, and not a single psychologist is shown. Jimmy's dad offhandedly mentions a history of schizophrenia in the family, but that's pretty much it. What the film instead does is consider the "split-personality" stuff to be a metaphor.
As in: teenagers and young adults are already mostly fucked up creatures. They don't need a mental illness to act completely differently in four different situations. The pressures of growing up, plus the drinking and drugs and sex and violence, are enough to make anyone go fucking nuts. I appreciated this grounded take on the story. Mostly because I've always thought the "quadrophenia" diagnosis was always the dumbest part of this rock opera, and rock operas are already kinda dumb to begin with. Amazing and incredible and fun and epic and totally worthwhile, yes, but also kinda dumb. Strip away the one fantastical element here, though, and you have a really sentimental and affecting tale of a wayward kid who's trying to find his place in the world.
I don't have an overarching thesis about this movie, more like a few spare thoughts, so let's lean into the ridiculous, and pretend that this blog had Quadrophenia, and use the fictional mental illness as a function for squeezing out another dumb blog post, and as a metaphor for how terrible of a writer I am.
Quadrant 1 / Roger Daltry: I thought a little bit about the idea of a "vanity project," and what that term means. I guess I would define it as art that is explicitly designed to raise the standing of, and/or praise, the artist who made it. I thought there might be a chance that we'd see Quadrophenia as a vanity project for the Who. And yes, there is a bit of Who worship here—"My Generation" soundtracks a party scene, and the main character seems to be a big fan, watching the band live on television and adorning his room with Who posters.
Despite these facts, I think that the "vanity" aspect was tastefully avoid. One, it's not like any member of the Who actually appeared in the film (especially Keith Moon, who was unavailable due to being deceased), and it didn't seem like the three living members had anything to do with the filmmaking aspect of it outside of the soundtracking. Two, there was a subtlety to the main character's fandom. Never once did he say anything like "I think the Who are the greatest band on earth!" or whatever. It was more like the character liked this type of music because it represented who he was and how he felt, and the Who just "happened" to be the example band used here. I don't even think he ever says "the Who" at all. Third, the original album is itself self-reflective. It's supposed to be about a Who fan. That's the story. The Who are already a sort of Greek chorus in the rock opera that they have composed. And this film is based on that album. It's kinda unavoidable, and has nothing to do with vanity.
As in: teenagers and young adults are already mostly fucked up creatures. They don't need a mental illness to act completely differently in four different situations. The pressures of growing up, plus the drinking and drugs and sex and violence, are enough to make anyone go fucking nuts. I appreciated this grounded take on the story. Mostly because I've always thought the "quadrophenia" diagnosis was always the dumbest part of this rock opera, and rock operas are already kinda dumb to begin with. Amazing and incredible and fun and epic and totally worthwhile, yes, but also kinda dumb. Strip away the one fantastical element here, though, and you have a really sentimental and affecting tale of a wayward kid who's trying to find his place in the world.
I don't have an overarching thesis about this movie, more like a few spare thoughts, so let's lean into the ridiculous, and pretend that this blog had Quadrophenia, and use the fictional mental illness as a function for squeezing out another dumb blog post, and as a metaphor for how terrible of a writer I am.
Quadrant 1 / Roger Daltry: I thought a little bit about the idea of a "vanity project," and what that term means. I guess I would define it as art that is explicitly designed to raise the standing of, and/or praise, the artist who made it. I thought there might be a chance that we'd see Quadrophenia as a vanity project for the Who. And yes, there is a bit of Who worship here—"My Generation" soundtracks a party scene, and the main character seems to be a big fan, watching the band live on television and adorning his room with Who posters.
Despite these facts, I think that the "vanity" aspect was tastefully avoid. One, it's not like any member of the Who actually appeared in the film (especially Keith Moon, who was unavailable due to being deceased), and it didn't seem like the three living members had anything to do with the filmmaking aspect of it outside of the soundtracking. Two, there was a subtlety to the main character's fandom. Never once did he say anything like "I think the Who are the greatest band on earth!" or whatever. It was more like the character liked this type of music because it represented who he was and how he felt, and the Who just "happened" to be the example band used here. I don't even think he ever says "the Who" at all. Third, the original album is itself self-reflective. It's supposed to be about a Who fan. That's the story. The Who are already a sort of Greek chorus in the rock opera that they have composed. And this film is based on that album. It's kinda unavoidable, and has nothing to do with vanity.
Quadrant 2 / Pete Townshend: The were some poignant truths here identity—how confusing it is as your growing up, how difficult it is to know yourself, the steps we take to define who we are as individuals and as part of a group. This is the story of the Mods vs. the Rockers. I liked how we followed a Mod and we saw him question the identity a few times, but not enough to feel anything about his Rocker friend. Confused, maybe, but there was no overnight metamorphosis or anything. Which felt more real to me. At one point, prior to the Rocker getting beaten, and way prior to the huge battle at the beach, our Mod protagonist Jimmy is told by his Rocker friend that "Mods and Rockers, they're all the same," and Jimmy responds, "I don't want to be the same, that's why I'm a Mod!" I don't know if he ever realizes until the very end how vulnerable that mindset makes him.
All of this kinda reminded me of an old neighborhood rivalry that we had going around these parts, years before I would've been old enough to participate in it (not that I would've participated, I'm just saying). The flashpoint for the Fox Chase vs. Abington rivalry was the murder of Eddie Polec, but even though that was by far the most violent outcome of any incident that happened in the ongoing fight, it was still maybe the middle incident. Abington kids killed a Fox Chase kid because Fox Chase kids had sexually harassed an Abington kid, and the Fox Chase kids harassed her because Abington kids had done something to them, and so on and so on, as far back as anyone could remember, two groups of kids fighting for reasons that none of them even understand, each incident escalating the previous one until all mayhem breaks lose. None of the Mods in Quadrophenia thought to question why they hated Rockers so badly, nor would they in real life. That's not how it works.
Quadrant 3 / John Entwhistle: I saw this film described as a "slice of life" film. I don't know if that aligns with how I felt about it, but it's definitely close. My favorite part about Quadrophenia was its propensity to just hang out with these characters, in the environments where they too were just kinda hanging out. I first noticed it at an early party scene—the famous Who song starts, and the camera slowly pans around the room, not focusing on any one character or one action, but more soaking it all in. It kept happening. There was the big dance scene, 500 kids juking and jiving to pre-Who oldies. There was the scene in the back room at Jimmy's job, where the camera found Jimmy and three coworkers playing poker and talking shit, none of it "important" to the plot, but still important in other ways, based on the way we linger there. Finally, there was our introduction to the Mod invasion in the beach town, when the camera pans left for what seems like forever, an endless array of Mod scooters and the Mods who are riding them and gathered in little groups and goofing off and feeling intimidating in their scale as a group. Nothing happens in this scene, per se, but with a panning of the camera that takes no-shit like three whole minutes, we are impressed as an audience how epic their size is, collective, and marvel at the damage they could do to such a town, if they so chose.
So yeah, slice of life, and this is a slice of it, since this is Jimmy's life, and we're assuming he's lived years before it and may or may not live for years after it. There is a rise and a fall to our protagonist, a rocket ride and the inevitable crash and then a few literal crashes. But even though there is very little driving action in the film (I mean figuratively—there is a lot of literal driving too), we still know this character, and know very well the characters that populate his life. That happens because the film is patient enough to just stand back and watch. I appreciated that.
Quadrant 4 / Keith Moon: And it was funny too! Sting plays one of the head Mods, and during the wild beach fight, the camera finds Sting's character, as he fights the police. I'll eat my fucking CD copy of Quadrophenia in its double-disc jewel case if that wasn't supposed to be a reference to Sting's band of origin.
Okay, that's fine enough for today. Now watch as I contemplate driving my scooter over a cliff to end the blog post.
Good movie.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: It's time for Rain Man, which, as far as I know, is not a rock opera featuring the music of the Weather Girls.

No comments:
Post a Comment