Prompt: "A song with a geographical location in the title"
Selected by Joe
"Point Breeze"
Marah
Kids in Philly, 2000
I like to think I know my city well. I have spent a decent chuck of time over the past decade of my life getting to know it intimately, on a street-by-street level, mostly because social work / child services is an in-person and never-ending job, and requires me to go to families' homes, and those families whom I visit could live and have lived in every corner of Philadelphia. But one thing I'll admit that I'm not all that familiar with, despite living in this city for the majority of my life (more than 50% as of last year, assuming you include those six semesters I squatted in La Salle dorms and off-campus houses using predatory loans), is that I really have no fucking clue when it comes to "neighborhoods."
Whenever we're driving through Philly, Pam will ask me "so what neighborhood are we in now?" Every time she asks it, I can feel my Philly bonafides grow thinner and thinner. It's a legitimate question, asked with good intentions (Pam did not grow up in Northeast Philadelphia but has made her home in Northeast Philadelphia, and wants to know more about it), but I seriously don't know what certain neighborhoods are called, or where the boundaries are located. Sometimes that makes me think that I'm a fraud, that I don't know my hometown as well as I say I do. Other times, it makes me think that maybe the idea of a "neighborhood" is so nebulous and arbitrary that no one really has any answers at all.
There are two general issues when it comes to discussions about neighborhoods. The first is that there is no higher authority making legal rulings as far as neighborhood boundaries are concerned. Calling a certain neighborhood and indicating where that neighborhood is located is just uh, like, your opinion, man. City council is too busy arguing about bay windows and outside seating at restaurants to govern on this crucial task. The Philadelphia Inquirer presents itself as an authority, but apparently refuses to acknowledge the existence of Lawncrest, a neighborhood I'm pretty familiar with, so I would question that authority on personal grounds. Neighborhoods as an idea are thus left up to those who reside in and around those so-called neighborhoods, and opinions obviously vary. You can look at novelty drawings that boomers who were too chickenshit to stay in Philly all apparently have in their finished basements' bathrooms, but those are artistic estimates and don't give clear rulings. You can ask any hoagiemouthed jabroni at the local pub and they have their opinions too. But none of the opinions line up! Neighborhoods are wherever the people who live in them want them to be!
There are two general issues when it comes to discussions about neighborhoods. The first is that there is no higher authority making legal rulings as far as neighborhood boundaries are concerned. Calling a certain neighborhood and indicating where that neighborhood is located is just uh, like, your opinion, man. City council is too busy arguing about bay windows and outside seating at restaurants to govern on this crucial task. The Philadelphia Inquirer presents itself as an authority, but apparently refuses to acknowledge the existence of Lawncrest, a neighborhood I'm pretty familiar with, so I would question that authority on personal grounds. Neighborhoods as an idea are thus left up to those who reside in and around those so-called neighborhoods, and opinions obviously vary. You can look at novelty drawings that boomers who were too chickenshit to stay in Philly all apparently have in their finished basements' bathrooms, but those are artistic estimates and don't give clear rulings. You can ask any hoagiemouthed jabroni at the local pub and they have their opinions too. But none of the opinions line up! Neighborhoods are wherever the people who live in them want them to be!
The second issue is that a neighborhood only exists if the people in them give a shit enough to give the idea of that neighborhood some sort of personality. There are some neighborhoods where you can easily be like "Oh yeah, this person acts this way because he is from this neighborhood." There are others that act more like blank slates. For example, from the ages of zero to fourteen, I lived in what many (including Wikipedia) would consider Lawndale. But "Lawndale" means nothing. It still doesn't. No one is saying "oh yeah, that dude is totally from Lawndale." That's probably why I identified more with the neighborhood of Burholme growing up. We drank beers under the Burholme water tower, and so it was easy to say "this is what it means to be in Burholme." We made that happen. But that was the doing of those who spent time there.
I feel like Fox Chase has an identity. I always felt that way, growing up, being a close neighbor, cutting my teeth at my first job there, and having a ton of friends from that neighborhood. You can trace the identity back to the Eddie Polec murder—the gruesome incident was so vivid to the people in the Northeast because of how sharply it contrasted with what was assumed to be the "real" Fox Chase: this was a family neighborhood. I don't know if that's even true or not, but it's the reputation. I'm sure that subconsciously I felt the pull of that reputation when we were selecting a location to raise our family in earnest; I pushed back because with "family friendly" comes the real risk of being homogenized, but still, three years in, and I can admit that this seems like a nice place to make a home.
The funny thing is that, when we moved in, we were told from multiple sources that the specific section of Fox Chase that we reside in is "actually" a completely different neighborhood. Its name (which I don't even remember at this point, so untrue was it) was given to it by the developers who put up these houses in the '50s. If I felt strongly about it, I could easily resurrect the name—I live here, after all, and it's my right to do that. But why would I? Fox Chase seems to fit this section of the city pretty well, as far as I'm concerned. We live in Fox Chase. End of story.
The problem in applying this logic to the rest of the city's neighborhoods is that I live in Fox Chase, and I don't live in any other neighborhood in the city, and so my knowledge about those other neighborhoods is going to be limited by design. I wouldn't know shit about Fox Chase if I didn't grow up adjacent to it and later force my own children to grow up in it. So when we're driving up Tyson Ave. and Pam asks me if we're in Rhawhurst or Torresdale, I have to admit that I have no fucking clue, because I never lived there, and never had the motivation to learn about those areas, at least on a personal/neighborhood level.
The problem in applying this logic to the rest of the city's neighborhoods is that I live in Fox Chase, and I don't live in any other neighborhood in the city, and so my knowledge about those other neighborhoods is going to be limited by design. I wouldn't know shit about Fox Chase if I didn't grow up adjacent to it and later force my own children to grow up in it. So when we're driving up Tyson Ave. and Pam asks me if we're in Rhawhurst or Torresdale, I have to admit that I have no fucking clue, because I never lived there, and never had the motivation to learn about those areas, at least on a personal/neighborhood level.
And that's not for me to know! Being a part of your neighborhood, and being proud of your neighborhood, is such a personal ritual. On the one hand, no one can take that away from you. On the other hand, no one else gives a fuck. I recall seeing a book on a coffee table one time (can't remember if it was my parents or my in-laws who had it there) that was billed as "stories from a group of friends in Mayfair," and it was literally that. A whole book collecting quotes from some oldheads from Mayfair, grouped into anecdotes about the "old" Mayfair that they experienced, growing up. I cannot think of book I'd like to read less.
We erstwhile kids from Lawndale / Burholme / Lawncrest / Fox Chase sit around these days and talk about the old days, for sure. Sometimes I'll even deign to write about it on this blog (lol, "sometimes"). But to assume that other people want to read about your neighborhood? That other people outside of your small circle would actually pay money to read it? I can think of no worse vanity. Pathetic, really.
I attempt to not be vain. I attempt to be humble. Here is my humility: I don't know shit about Philadelphia. I know there is a Point Breeze and I know I've been there and had great times there and I love getting a fun little peak at what Point Breeze looked like at the turn of the century according to the best indie rock album about Philadelphia that will ever exist. But I don't know Point Breeze. I don't know it because I never lived it.
I can easily, easily get around Philadelphia at this point, around any fucking neighborhood, sometimes with a blindfold on, and absolutely without the help of the fucking robot on the phone. But that's because I know Philadelphia's streets. I don't know about the people who live on those streets. I don't know most neighborhoods. I don't know where those neighborhoods are, and I don't know what they stand for. And that's okay.
I attempt to not be vain. I attempt to be humble. Here is my humility: I don't know shit about Philadelphia. I know there is a Point Breeze and I know I've been there and had great times there and I love getting a fun little peak at what Point Breeze looked like at the turn of the century according to the best indie rock album about Philadelphia that will ever exist. But I don't know Point Breeze. I don't know it because I never lived it.
I can easily, easily get around Philadelphia at this point, around any fucking neighborhood, sometimes with a blindfold on, and absolutely without the help of the fucking robot on the phone. But that's because I know Philadelphia's streets. I don't know about the people who live on those streets. I don't know most neighborhoods. I don't know where those neighborhoods are, and I don't know what they stand for. And that's okay.
1 comment:
Point Breeze resident here. Honestly no idea how these neighborhood names get stuck. I also hear this area (or part of it) called "Newbold" which is supposedly a newly coined title by local businessman & restaurateur owner of Sardine and SP Taproom who just by sheer force of will made it happen. Asked Google to put it on the map which is a sort of psuedo-official stamp in men's minds. Weird.
Post a Comment