Monday, January 8, 2024

Epimemeology, Week #2: Spider-Man Pointing at Spider-Man

by Pat

Love for Spider-Man runs deep in my family. One of the first toys I remember having was this Spider-Man action figure.


His head is currently my son's favorite thing to chew on, just as it was mine 30 years ago (and occasionally today).

The Meme:

An animated image of two Spider-Mans (Spider-Men? Spiders-Man? I'm going with Spider-Men) pointing at each other accusingly. Occasionally a third Spider-Man is added. I've seen versions with as many as seven.


Where You Might Have Seen It:

The internet has been memeing old Spider-Man images since the early 2010s, but this particular image really exploded in the last five or six years after a rediscovery on Basketball Twitter. All these columns will eventually relate back to basketball. That's the PoYB guarantee.


Pointing Spider-Man reached its apotheosis (or, "really shot its whole web") in 2022, when Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, and Tom Holland reprised their respective roles as Spider-Men to create a live-action version.


The Message:

Originally, "Each of these parties are claiming to be the genuine article."


However, like with most things online, the meme has expanded to allow mockery, so now it's mainly used to illustrate "These two parties are equally at fault."


Occasionally, different characters in a similar situation are swapped into the same poses.


The Source:

For today's column I watched two full episodes of the 1967 Spider-Man animated series: Season 1's "To Catch a Spider / Double Identity" and Season 2's "To Cage a Spider." I will note that "Double Identity" is the source of the famous screenshot, so that will be the focus of the recap, with the other two episodes providing texture. Also, if I'm being honest, I watched "To Cage a Spider" accidentally, thinking it was the right episode. Cue the picture:


Right off the bat, the classic theme song kicks so much ass. It's jazzy as hell and you can probably hear some version in your head as you read this. Fun fact: "Spider-Man, Spider-Man, does whatever a spider can" was written by lyricist Paul Francis Webster, a three-time Academy Award winner for Best Original Song. To be clear, he won those awards before he wrote the Spider-Man theme. He was working up to this, and it shows.

Tragically, it seems they blew the whole budget on getting Webster, because the animation itself is famously low-effort. The costume is missing stripes, "typical teenage Spider-Man" is clearly voiced by a man in his 40s (I checked, voice actor Paul Soles was 37 when it premiered), and most dialogue scenes are simply a moving mouth on a completely stationary character. As someone who grew up watching Adult Swim, it was jarring to see a sincere use of Sealab 2021's animation style.

"Double Identity" begins with a red herring. Peter Parker (or so we think!) is on assignment taking photos of rare books. Suddenly we realize: it's not Peter at all! It's an impostor! He's stealing the rare book! You may ask, why impersonate Peter Parker—random teen photojournalist—instead of the book curator? Or how can you observe Peter Parker so closely that you can do a perfect impersonation, but still don't realize he's Spider-Man? I assure you, these are the wrong questions. I will not elaborate further. What's important is that Spider-Man shows up to foil the robbery, but is dispatched with a single punch by Brutus the henchman. Spider-Man takes a tremendous number of Ls in this episode and series at-large.

We come to find out that fake Peter is none other than renowned actor and master of impersonation, Charles Cameo! I have two theories about why the greatest living actor in the Marvel Universe has resorted to crime instead of, you know, professional acting. Either Charles Cameo did something so despicable that he was canceled in 1960s Hollywood (*shudder*) or he refused to name names to the House Un-American Activities Committee. At any rate, Cameo and his goon-butler Brutus are our villains of the week.

The next capers involves Cameo impersonating J. Jonah Jameson and the artist "Salvadori Fricasso," which is a name too specific to be dumb and too lazy to be smart. Real "the Princeton-educated scriptwriter is hungover" energy. Spider-Man shows up both times and gives chase, but unfortunately Cameo-Jameson knows the spider's only natural weakness: lead.


I watched three stories about Spider-Man for this blog, and he had a gun pulled on him in every single one. It is astonishing how different sensibilities were in the '60s. It was a simpler time, when men were men, women poisoned their husbands instead of divorcing, comic book villains packed heat, and children learned about death at every opportunity.

The final showdown—and our meme—occurs at the docks. Brutus knocks out a police officer and takes his uniform in order to steal priceless Renaissance tapestries being unloaded from some kind of treasure boat. When two Spider-Men show up to stop the robbery, J. Jonah Jameson and Police Captain O'Malley emerge from the shadows to arrest them both. Spider-Man and "Spider-Man" both accuse the other of being the fraud, all while Jameson implores Captain O'Malley to shoot both of them. There's a brief competition between the Spider-Men where Cameo reveals that he's duplicated the real Spider-Man's web powers, super strength and wall crawling. It's unclear why Cameo doesn't just patent this technology to make an honest living, or really even why he showed up to the scene at all. Brutus would've totally gotten away with that tapestry if there hadn't been all this commotion. Long story short, the episode ends with Charles Cameo and Brutus bound in webbing and under arrest. We also find out that Cameo's hair is a toupee, which he presumably wore under all the disguises.

The full context of that final scene gives the meme an added layer of meaning. I've come to understand that the image ultimately is not about making the correct choice; it's about the illusion of choice existing at all. Both are claiming to be the real Spider-Man, but it doesn't matter because J. Jonah Jameson demands that both be killed. Suddenly, this meme has gone from a silly picture of men in costumes to the internet equivalent of Robert Frost's "The Road Not Taken."

Watching the episodes in their entirety also gave me insight into why Spider-Man memes persist generally. "Spider-Man Pointing at Spider-Man" is merely the most well-known image out of dozens of Spider-Man screen grabs that float around the Internet.




The typical punchline of these images is that Spider-Man is rude, clueless, or otherwise disinterested in being a hero. Also known as "a regular person."

Media based on comic book characters is so ubiquitous that today's producers, writers, and directors possess at least a frame of reference for how the stories should be told, if not outright reverence. Not so with Spider-Man. The team tasked with producing the 1967 series didn't grow up with Spider-Man comics, and the creative team from Marvel wasn't involved. The first animated series had to forge its own path, and the writers had to bring their own sensibilities. What they landed on was a superhuman who did heroic things, but was also a dick. Just a real pain in the ass to be around.

Here's an example: in "To Catch a Spider," a nightmarish alliance forms between Green Goblin, Electro, Vulture, and the invisible Dr. Noah Body (fuck, I just got that). The gang is eventually destroyed, but not by last minute heroics or "great responsibility." No, it's destroyed when Spider-Man—no shit—starts hurling insults from the shadows, causing the villains to break down mentally and fight one another. He's a hater to the core, this one.

To me, this interpretation makes sense. For one, the head writer for Seasons 2 and 3 was Ralph Bakshi, director of the X-rated animated film Fritz the Cat.

This was never going to be a sentimental show.  But more generally, I think a dickish superhero is an honest take. I am of the opinion that most people, if given superhuman abilities, would not fall to the extremes of Superman (Selfless Hero) or Homelander (Power Crazed Monster). Most people would go on living their lives, but with substantial smugness about their talents.

This attitude is best captured in "To Cage a Spider." To set the scene, Spider-Man has joined forces with a bunch of prisoners to escape from jail (trust me, it was a ride to get here). When Spider-Man starts to crawl up a wall to reach a window, one of the prisoners accuses him of abandoning them. Spider-Man responds:

Prisoner: It's a double cross!

Spider-Man: Even if it were, what would you do?

Damn, dude. In an episode full of beatdowns, it's the truth that hurts the most. "I'm Spider-Man and you're not" is a brutal thing to say to our haters. The meme continues so we can say it by proxy.


Next Week: Pat risks life and limb to try The Lemonade That Kills You.

1 comment:

Joe K said...

I don't know if the script of a shitty Marvel movie can be considered an "official source," but if it can, then you were right, it's officially "Spider-men."