Do You Know Who You Are?
Texas Is the Reason
1996
The worst thing I could do here would be to damn with faint praise. I'm told this album is important to the genre and many genres that spawned from it, and I believe it. I also quite like Midwest emo, and never really tire of it no matter how many bands I uncover, and so I don't want to say anything untoward just because it may or may not live up to the hype of "UNIQUELY EXCELLENT" to my ears.
It's not "unique" to me because I've heard bands that sound like this before. The "importance" comes in because all of the bands that sound like this only sound like this because of Texas Is the Reason. They were the influencers, not the influenced, and my ears hear it backward due to my fault (it's a "blind spot," after all). For example, I've known Jimmy Eat World as "emo" only nominally, and I have up until now struggled to understand how they fit into that lineage musically. After hearing Texas Is the Reason, I get it. It's very clear that Jimmy Eat World was doing Texas Is the Reason but applying less scraggly vocals (and later, applying more facets of pop).
Some of its slower moments remind me of the cool-downs on American Football. Some of its harsher moments could easily have morphed into third-wave emo like My Chemical Romance (pretty easy to draw a line from here to MCR's debut, when the gothic theatrics were still a work in progress). Some of the catchier moments remind me of the emo-punk-leaning hits of the Promise Ring's Nothing Feels Good. For that latter band, it's more of a peer than an influence. The point remains, I think; it's not like anyone besides the true heads are espousing the virtues of either band even a fraction of the amount that we're talking about Jimmy Eat World (or were, in the '00s, but are currently, too).
I'm told by my wife that a PoYB contributor has a Texas Is the Reason tattoo, and I was tossing around the idea of putting her words in this column as well, before I found out she was out of the country leading up to publishing time. Hopefully I can eventually get her take on what I'm told is a seminal album for her (maybe shoehorned into a one-off Song Challenge entry), because I think that's important here. From my perspective, I'm thinking, damn, this is another great entry in the Midwest emo canon. But I'm struggling with how we can get from "really excellent" to "really important" without considering a soft version of the Elvis Theory.
That's okay! Seriously. It's okay to consider something "important," even if it's not. It makes sense in this context. Here we have a band who released a grand total of one album to very little initial fanfare, and then broke up, and then that album ends up influencing a lot of other music that had a lot more success, and so that album is simultaneously marked as both important to an entire genre, while also existing in a space where it could very reasonably be considered "a secret," which is nice because it feels personal to the listener, and thus more special. I totally get that, and I see how this is the perfect album for such emotions, and if I'm being honest, I'm pretty jealous that I don't get to feel that, having been blocked from such experiences by missing the boat and then only coming back around to it after it becomes well-known enough to be considered a "blind spot."
As it stands now, this is such a fun album, but only because I fucking love Midwest emo music, and am always hungry for more (and plus also I enjoy the lore—how there are multiple JFK assassination references, and the title of the album are the last words spoken to a dying John Lennon). As for the so-called "importance" of the album, I'm not there yet. But music has been known to gain weight and density over long periods of time. And so I wait. In the meantime, I enjoy.
It's not "unique" to me because I've heard bands that sound like this before. The "importance" comes in because all of the bands that sound like this only sound like this because of Texas Is the Reason. They were the influencers, not the influenced, and my ears hear it backward due to my fault (it's a "blind spot," after all). For example, I've known Jimmy Eat World as "emo" only nominally, and I have up until now struggled to understand how they fit into that lineage musically. After hearing Texas Is the Reason, I get it. It's very clear that Jimmy Eat World was doing Texas Is the Reason but applying less scraggly vocals (and later, applying more facets of pop).
Some of its slower moments remind me of the cool-downs on American Football. Some of its harsher moments could easily have morphed into third-wave emo like My Chemical Romance (pretty easy to draw a line from here to MCR's debut, when the gothic theatrics were still a work in progress). Some of the catchier moments remind me of the emo-punk-leaning hits of the Promise Ring's Nothing Feels Good. For that latter band, it's more of a peer than an influence. The point remains, I think; it's not like anyone besides the true heads are espousing the virtues of either band even a fraction of the amount that we're talking about Jimmy Eat World (or were, in the '00s, but are currently, too).
I'm told by my wife that a PoYB contributor has a Texas Is the Reason tattoo, and I was tossing around the idea of putting her words in this column as well, before I found out she was out of the country leading up to publishing time. Hopefully I can eventually get her take on what I'm told is a seminal album for her (maybe shoehorned into a one-off Song Challenge entry), because I think that's important here. From my perspective, I'm thinking, damn, this is another great entry in the Midwest emo canon. But I'm struggling with how we can get from "really excellent" to "really important" without considering a soft version of the Elvis Theory.
That's okay! Seriously. It's okay to consider something "important," even if it's not. It makes sense in this context. Here we have a band who released a grand total of one album to very little initial fanfare, and then broke up, and then that album ends up influencing a lot of other music that had a lot more success, and so that album is simultaneously marked as both important to an entire genre, while also existing in a space where it could very reasonably be considered "a secret," which is nice because it feels personal to the listener, and thus more special. I totally get that, and I see how this is the perfect album for such emotions, and if I'm being honest, I'm pretty jealous that I don't get to feel that, having been blocked from such experiences by missing the boat and then only coming back around to it after it becomes well-known enough to be considered a "blind spot."
As it stands now, this is such a fun album, but only because I fucking love Midwest emo music, and am always hungry for more (and plus also I enjoy the lore—how there are multiple JFK assassination references, and the title of the album are the last words spoken to a dying John Lennon). As for the so-called "importance" of the album, I'm not there yet. But music has been known to gain weight and density over long periods of time. And so I wait. In the meantime, I enjoy.

No comments:
Post a Comment