Follow along in the book HERE. Today's song is at #39 and is featured on pages 253-258. See the full list of their Top 100 Beatles Songs HERE.
"Tomorrow Never Knows"
Revolver
1966
Critic Josh Terry brought up a good point when he ranked his personal favorite Radiohead albums (didn't think I'd be rope that band into a goddamn Beatles column during Radiohead Week, did ya?), something that maybe I wouldn't have even noticed if he hadn't mentioned it in the OK Computer blurb. He notes that Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band used to be the consensus pick for Best Beatles Album (I've written about my own experiences with that album a bunch of times, most recently HERE), but in recent times, and all of a sudden, Abbey Road and Revolver seem to be the new consensus picks. And so the underlining question is: why? Is this just something that the tastemakers woke up one day and decided was true? Or are new tastemakers coming to prominence and influencing how we as a society value these pieces of art in a comparative way?
That's not really any of my concern (even besides the fact that The White Album is their best album), since we're not really in the business of tastemaking here on this blog. Writing about the tastemakers, maybe, but definitely no pure tastemaking. But I thought a lot about what Terry pointed out, and how true that was, and wondered whether the same phenomenon has influenced what people "generally" view as the "best" Beatles song? Not only is that kind of why we're fucking here in the first place, and not only is "Tomorrow Never Knows" the final song on the aforementioned Revolver, but I think the conversation is relevant here because I feel like the consensus opinion has shifted toward crowning "Tomorrow Never Knows" as the Best Beatles Song. I will cite no sources in this observation, but I think if you tried to look up recent lists, you'd see this song at or near the top in most cases.
The specific point today is that the very existence of the ability for the "consensus" to shift in this way might go a long way in explaining why "Tomorrow Never Knows"—in my personal opinion a lock for Top Five, and good enough that I understand why it's the consensus pick these days—is hovering down at motherfucking #39 on this list we've been using as source material. According to Stephen Spignesi and Michael Lewis, there are 38 Beatles songs that are better than "Tomorrow Never Knows." This is insane, but also, let's let cooler heads prevail and point out the fact that this book was published in 2004, twenty years ago. That's more than enough time for a cultural shift.
As to why the cultural shift toward "Tomorrow Never Knows," to that I am less qualified to answer. I think there's two factors here. One is that, due to no small part social media and the general idea of living our lives online, there's been a even more broad shift from sincerity to irony, just in the way we present ourselves. Heartfelt and wholesome is uncool, and smart and sarcastic and removed is cool. Weird is normal, too, which is maybe closer to the point here. "Tomorrow Never Knows" is not corny in the way "All You Need Is Love" is corny, or even in the way "A Day in the Life" is corny (if sincerity is indeed corny). It is weird, with a tough groove. It is certifiably cool. It's not talking about love. It's talking about death. That's cool too. It's a song that feels more "of the times." Maybe even musically too—Lennon's vocals are fed through a Leslie speaker and come out sounding distant and robotic and disconnected, and that gestalt fits right in with the perpetually online generations.
The second factor that I'm hypothesizing about is that this book was published before Don Draper heard the song. I didn't rewatch the episode in preparation for this blog post, so I'm stretching back and trying to remember from my only viewing of it in 2012. If I recall correctly, Draper is dating his younger and hipper second wife Megan, who understandable loves the Beatles. Draper is losing touch with pop culture, which is a moral sin for the top man of an ad agency. So he attempts to listen to "Tomorrow Never Knows" at the end of the episode, and it starts diegetic but then ends up soundtracking the montage at the end of the episode (including Rory Gilmore wanting to fuck Pete), before turning diegetic again as Don cuts the song off in disgust.
It's important in the episode because, at this point in the series, we're watching Don Draper become "old," and witness him gradually get overshadowed by the next generation rising up to challenge him. The fact that he doesn't "get" this Beatles song is a big sign of his ultimate (probable) demise. We as the audience are supposed to think he is not cool in this moment, and thus, we are supposed to think that the song itself is very cool.
I don't want to overstate the cultural reach of Mad Men. It was popular but comparatively so. I don't know if it had the power to move this particular cultural consensus toward this one song just by simple virtue of including it at the end of an episode. I will say that, personally, it felt big to me, to hear a Beatles song, especially this Beatles song, on this prestige TV drama. Also factor in the hilarious bit in the middle of the episode where the heads at Sterling Cooper are like "we can't get the Beatles! they're too big for us to land for our commercial! it could never be done!" and then it turns out that Mad Men itself is able to land that big fish, become that rare entertainment to significantly use a Beatles song for its own ends. I gotta assume I'm in the minority here, as far as Beatles fans are concerned, but even so, I'm probably not alone either—"Tomorrow Never Knows" feels bigger and cool and culturally significant and more of a consensus pick for best song due to this television show featuring it on this episode.
For the record, regardless of the reasoning, I agree with the consensus, if there is one. Not that it's necessarily the best straight-up, but that it's absolutely one of the best, and coolest, and more important. And I don't think that we can necessarily blame Spignesi and Lewis in this particular case for getting it so wrong. 20 years is a long time. They could not have predicted the future.
BEATLES TRIVIA: I find it difficult to comprehend that this was the first song on Revolver to be recorded. It just seems so much like a turning point in the road, so far beyond anything that the Beatles had done up to that point, that imagining what it was like to then go back and fill out the rest of Revolver (not that any of the songs here are simple by any means, but comparatively so, maybe) is almost impossible to imagine.
BETTER BEATLE: Not to give too much away for when I finally get through all of these songs sometimes before the year 2027, but I think there's a very good chance that this is going to be considered my favorite. Maybe not. Might depend on how I'm feeling on that day, whenever it arrives. For the purposes of this blurb, I'll say that "...Me and My Monkey" has a good shot at challenging this song, and maybe even winning that challenge. A few other songs too, but we'll keep 'em close to the chest for now.
NEXT TIME: "Across the Universe" at #40
No comments:
Post a Comment