Sinéad O'Connor
1990
I try to hold some grace for the mistakes I've made in the past, but it's tough sometimes, to look back and find how many times I was on the wrong side of an issue, and how long it took for me to rectify those mistakes. I'm speaking generally here, I'm not specifically of Sinéad O'Connor. I was pretty young during the controversies that befell her at the commercial peak of her career, and so I didn't have an opinion one way or the other. But I think about it sometimes, how I would've reacted with I was, say, fourteen years old and I saw a video of someone tearing up a picture of the pope, and wonder if I would've made the same mistake that so many people at the time made. In this regard, I am pretty glad that I didn't even have the opportunity to express cruelty toward the artist in question. It's easier to know that, until this week, O'Connor was a blind spot. It's easier to know that I can discover it in my 30s, when I'm not a moron, when I am of a mature and deep-thinking mind, when I can know that Sinéad O'Connor was right the entire fucking time and not have to grapple with any previous life when I didn't believe it.
This informs my listening experience with I Do Not Want What I Haven't Got, but it doesn't eclipse it. I am fully invested in the narrative of Sinéad O'Connor's immense courage, and find myself admiring her music more than I would've, had she not been such a purposefully polarizing figure. From what I've read (which, sure, has probably been retroactively painted rose-colored in the aftermath of her death), she got shit for a lot of what she did and what she believed. The incident on the pro-child-abuse television program SNL was the pinnacle of society's disgusting behavior (the fact that Sinéad O'Connor was anti-child abuse prompted Joe Pesci, the following week's host, to claim that if he was the previous week's host, he would have assaulted her), but there were incidents prior to that, like when she refused to have the National Anthem played before a gig in the U.S. (which prompted Frank Sinatra to claim that if he ever met Sinéad O'Connor, he would assault her). It's easy for me to say in 2024 that she was RIGHT in these situations. And, because I am a coward and prefer when I don't have to grapple with my own morality, I am thankful that I didn't have to spend my week repenting for anything. Sinéad was right, her music is better because of it, and that's that.
I'm undecided whether I respect the courage to stand up for what she believed in because of the act itself, or only because she ended up being so painfully right and thus exposed a gaping wound in the soul of the American public. Probably the latter, right? There are plenty of people now who believe they are being courageous by standing up for what they believe in, and their beliefs end up being despicable. Still, and albeit probably because of that, I have mad respect for the her act of facing the pushback head-on. On "The Emperor's New Clothes," she says, "I will live by my own policies / I will sleep with a clear conscience / I will sleep in peace." I think it's easy to be against child abuse and child molestation by priests with the implicit consent of their leader, but I don't think it's easy to get on the national stage and say it despite the pushback from the despicable host of a despicable TV show saying he was going to assault you to the jeers of a despicable crowd of people gathered to watch that despicable TV show live in-studio.
I'm getting way off-track here (and probably letting my white-hot hatred of the racist television program SNL color my judgment). I guess I'm trying to paint a picture of why I feel like this album matters. I could talk about the songs too. Probably should at some point. Maybe say that "I Am Stretched on Your Grave" has one of the best musical moments on this or any album, when that Irish fiddle loop comes in toward the end (the rest of the song makes it make total sense that O'Connor eventually recorded with Massive Attack). Impeccable stuff here. I like "Nothing Compares 2 U," though it's kind of unbelievable that such a downer of a song was a #1 smash hit. I guess we can chalk it up to the early '90s being a different time. A time when slow and powerful but definitely real slow songs can become hits and people think that scumbag Frank Sinatra threatening to hit a woman somehow constitutes a voice of reason. Crazy times.
I can't help myself. Ugh, I just fucking hate Frank Sinatra so much, and I see what I need to see in art. This is one of my flaws. I hear a good album from a legendary (and infamously outcasted) artist and all I can think about is how much it justifies my opinion that Frank Sinatra is one of American history's biggest pieces of shit. It gives power to songs in which Sinéad O'Connor professes a strong belief, and gives reason to the slower songs that I might not listen to otherwise. I also like "You Cause as Much Sorrow" for just being a good song. Kinda reminds me of 10,000 Maniacs.
I'm undecided whether I respect the courage to stand up for what she believed in because of the act itself, or only because she ended up being so painfully right and thus exposed a gaping wound in the soul of the American public. Probably the latter, right? There are plenty of people now who believe they are being courageous by standing up for what they believe in, and their beliefs end up being despicable. Still, and albeit probably because of that, I have mad respect for the her act of facing the pushback head-on. On "The Emperor's New Clothes," she says, "I will live by my own policies / I will sleep with a clear conscience / I will sleep in peace." I think it's easy to be against child abuse and child molestation by priests with the implicit consent of their leader, but I don't think it's easy to get on the national stage and say it despite the pushback from the despicable host of a despicable TV show saying he was going to assault you to the jeers of a despicable crowd of people gathered to watch that despicable TV show live in-studio.
I'm getting way off-track here (and probably letting my white-hot hatred of the racist television program SNL color my judgment). I guess I'm trying to paint a picture of why I feel like this album matters. I could talk about the songs too. Probably should at some point. Maybe say that "I Am Stretched on Your Grave" has one of the best musical moments on this or any album, when that Irish fiddle loop comes in toward the end (the rest of the song makes it make total sense that O'Connor eventually recorded with Massive Attack). Impeccable stuff here. I like "Nothing Compares 2 U," though it's kind of unbelievable that such a downer of a song was a #1 smash hit. I guess we can chalk it up to the early '90s being a different time. A time when slow and powerful but definitely real slow songs can become hits and people think that scumbag Frank Sinatra threatening to hit a woman somehow constitutes a voice of reason. Crazy times.
I can't help myself. Ugh, I just fucking hate Frank Sinatra so much, and I see what I need to see in art. This is one of my flaws. I hear a good album from a legendary (and infamously outcasted) artist and all I can think about is how much it justifies my opinion that Frank Sinatra is one of American history's biggest pieces of shit. It gives power to songs in which Sinéad O'Connor professes a strong belief, and gives reason to the slower songs that I might not listen to otherwise. I also like "You Cause as Much Sorrow" for just being a good song. Kinda reminds me of 10,000 Maniacs.
I missed the boat in the '90s. I even missed the boat a couple years ago when the O'Connor tributes started pouring in (Joe Pesci was mysteriously silent after O'Connor's passing). But I think that's all for the best. You can see how my problem of being a keyboard warrior has a way of getting in the way with things like this. Here, in the quiet solitude of a Monday afternoon, 35-years-old and more than settled on what I feel is the appropriate belief system, it's just nice to listen to a good album by a great artist and know for certain that she was right.

No comments:
Post a Comment