Monday, April 15, 2024

Epimemeology, Week #16: The Mannequin Challenge

by Pat

Wanna party? Wanna get high? Wanna smash the hottest stranger you can find? Well then you've come to the wrong place! We're here to talk about memes from eight years ago. 

The Meme:

The Mannequin Challenge, where participants stay frozen in place during a tracking shot. The typical soundtrack for the videos is "Black Beatles" by Rae Sremmurd.


Where You Might Have Seen It:

On October 26, 2016, a group of students at Ed White High School in Jacksonville, Florida, posted a short video of themselves frozen in place on Twitter.


According to an interview with Inverse, the meme started as a bunch of teenagers doing normal teenager stuff:


The beauty of the Mannequin Challenge was its simplicity. All anyone had to do was stay completely still for a few seconds. Unlike other internet challenges, the Mannequin Challenge did not require the risk of harm to oneself. There was essentially no barrier to entry. 

The challenge was quickly accepted by everybody. Basically every school in America did it. NFL teams did it. White Beatles did it. The White House and the Cleveland Cavaliers did it with the wrong music. 

I want to point out two particular instances. First, Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign posted their Mannequin Challenge the night before Election Day. 

Go campaign in Pennsylvania! What are you doing?!

Second, special shoutout to Alabama. Alabamans really went all out for this one, consequences be damned. It wasn't enough to post a shootout-themed Mannequin Challenge that led to a full blown ATF investigation. No, Alabama really went the extra mile by posting a Mannequin Challenge from a prison using a contraband cell phone. 

As a former prison employee, that is the funniest goddamn thing I have ever seen. "We could've used this phone to call for money, or drugs, or a fucking airstrike on the fence in the yard, but we chose to do a silly meme instead." Just a huge middle finger to the system. I hope they post that video in the Louvre some day. 

The Message:

"Eat a dick, laws of physics! We are the masters of time and space!"

The Source:

To get a better understanding of the Mannequin Challenge's appeal, I listened to the album that gave us "Black Beatles" in the first place: SremmLife II by Rae Sremmurd. Like with most things, I was not familiar with hip-hop duo Rae Sremmurd (pronounced "ray sh-rim-erd") before I listened. Holy shit, what a ride. 

Rae Sremmurd consists of brothers Swae Lee and Slim Jxmmi, who went from squatting in an abandoned house in Tupelo, Mississippi to having a Billboard #1 single just seven years later. Rae Sremmurd might be the hardest working musicians in the business. They will not turn down work. They have performed at events as prestigious as the AVN Awards, and as confusing and pointless as the NFL Pro Bowl halftime show. 

That boundless energy is reflected in their music. These guys fuckin' party. They're trap-pop's answer to Andrew W.K. Every song adheres a general theme of getting high, fucking, buying something expensive, getting high, popping bottles, inviting more girls to the party, and, of course, getting high. 

The opening track on SremmLife II is the dubstep influenced "Start a Party," which acts as Rae Sremmurd kicking open the audience's front door and screaming "It's time to fucking rage." Seriously. Slim Jxmmi is screeching the chorus, he's so excited. Now I don't think anyone would describe Rae Sremmurd as lyrical miracles. Their flow is good, even if the content of their verses is standard party-boy shit. If you're looking progressive, intellectual hip-hop, you took a very wrong turn to get here. Though, there was one Swae Lee line that got me: "If you don't smoke loud, be quiet!” OK, Mr. Lee. I'm all ears. 

The party starts and never stops for the rest of the album. Nothing else besides a good time matters to Rae Sremmurd. They are not hiding the ball here. "Real Chill," with its dreary, dreamy drumbeat, is perfect music for rolling and smoking a blunt. I shouldn't have to explain what they're talking about in "Shake It Fast," but I will. It's ass, obviously. The closest Rae Sremmurd comes to pausing the party and self-reflecting are the slowed down tracks "Now That I Know" and "Take It or Leave It." But even here they keep a laser focus on unbridled hedonism. Both the songs can be boiled down to: "Hey girl, you're really cool. I'd hate it if you left. That said, I am absolutely going to keep fucking everything that moves. Cool? Alright. Now that we've talked about it, you wanna take some ecstasy?” 

This is not to say that Rae Sremmurd is striving for the lowest common denominator. They like to rap about parties, but I don't think it's a cynical cash grab for two reasons. First, Rae Sremmurd is willing to sprinkle in some weirdness. I watched the music videos whenever available, and lemme tell you, I saw some shit. The video for the silly, playful "By Chance" features the standard backup dancers in bikinis, but also a fixation on pineapples, Slim Jxmmi dancing with a French bulldog, and an inexplicable shot of old white guy and Swae Lee releasing doves. 

Who is this for?

"Set the Roof" decides to fuck with the audience even harder. The various shots of women dancing all sexy is randomly punctuated by a dancer dressed in a full Xenomorph costume, dancing equally as sexy. Shame on you for thinking this would ever be explained. 


Not all of Rae Sremmurd's oddball instincts show up in the videos. Take Swae Lee opening lines in "Came a Long Way," which I'm not convinced wasn't ghostwritten by LFO:

"What a journey
All the broke shit don't concern me
Chinchilla hella furry
Catch me on a yacht eatin' curry."

But more than the casual strangeness, what convinces me of Rae Sremmurd's genuine love for the craft is how they incorporated their influences into SremmLife II. Rae Sremmurd's sound is descended from a long line of pioneering Southern rappers, and a bunch of them show up in guest spots. Academy Award winner Juicy J appears on "Shake It Fast." America's hype man Lil Jon lends his energy to "Set the Roof." And the meme song itself—"Black Beatles"—features none other than Gucci Mane. Gucci Mane is one of hip-hop's greatest living maniacs, and I was shocked to learn that "Black Beatles" was actually his first and only song to reach #1. 

Overall, I found SremmLife II to be enjoyable, if a little repetitive. The energy it exudes is too much for me to incorporate it into my daily life. I wouldn't play it while driving to the grocery store; I'd start kicking apart the produce section upon arrival. But if I decide to have a rager at my house in the near future, I'll definitely throw SremmLife II on the playlist. 

However, listening in full didn't really answer the question: why did "Black Beatles" become the soundtrack to the hottest meme of fall 2016? As best I can tell, the song is about the excesses of fame and/or throwing cash at a strip club. Thematically, it couldn't be further away from standing completely still.

According to one camp, the Mannequin Challenge was hijacked by marketers and turned into an engine for promoting SremmLife II. In a December 2016 interview with Complex, Gunner Safron of Interscope Records and online marketing firm Pizzaslime essentially took credit for the whole thing. The way they tell it, Safron and Pizzaslime instantly recognized the potential of the meme and arranged for "Black Beatles" to be used in Mannequin Challenge videos by specific influencers. It was astroturfing at its most cynical and devious. 

Personally, I think Safron and Pizzaslime are mostly talking out of their ass here. Maybe it's the dreamer in me. Maybe it's because for the whole interview, they talk in unbearable, vague corporate-speak that makes me think that they're simply taking credit for an organic phenomenon. I mean, it's not like "Black Beatles" was languishing in obscurity when the Mannequin Challenge started. It was #33 on the Billboard Hot 100 when the Ed White students posted the first video on October 26th. 

The "it was planned all along" narrative is also at odds with Rae Sremmurd's reaction to the Mannequin Challenge. While the brothers were delighted that their song went viral, they were apparently baffled as to why the internet had picked them specifically. Nice job talking to your client, Pizzaslime. 

That said, Gunner Safron does hit on an important point toward the end. 


It's unclear to me how often "Black Beatles" was being used in Mannequin challenge videos in the week-and-a-half between October 26th and November 4th. But whether it was an intentional ploy by advertisers, or just two twenty-somethings seeing a funny meme on Twitter, Rae Sremmurd posting their own Mannequin Challenge on November 4th certainly locked "Black Beatles" in as the default tune. 


If I can take one thing away from listening to SremmLife II, it's that Swae Lee and Slim Jxmmi seem like pretty genuine guys. They really seem like they wanna party. They look like they're good to hang out with. And when they do the Mannequin Challenge, it looks like they're doing it for fun, not as a way to plug their album. I guess that's the ultimate lesson of the Mannequin Challenge. Memes—especially memes that encourage creativity and skill—thrive when they're done for the love of the game. They die when they get co-opted by advertisers. I'm pretty sure once Hillary Clinton and James Corden posted their Mannequin Challenge videos, we all knew it was over. But we'll always have those memories, frozen in time. 

"Two can play at this game, Paul!"

Next Week: Pat celebrates 4/20 by... reflecting on Kony 2012? Bummer. 

No comments: