2000
Gina Prince-Bythewood
Thanks to Group D for the great movie pick! See you all in the discussion!
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Brianna
Man, I really liked this one.
I guess with my last few Film Club watches being Grave of the Fireflies, Waking Life, and Dogville, a straightforward romantic sports movie (with a happy ending!) was exactly what the doctor ordered. The music was fun, the chemistry of the leading duo was palpable, and the story felt familiar in a classic kind of way. Plus, I'll take a Tyra Banks jumpscare over an Alex Jones one any day.
I especially liked the four-quarter format of the story. The audience catches our leads at the pivotal moments, often leaving the more tedious fallout behind the scenes. We didn't have to watch Monica continue to fight her way through college ball, for example, nor Q's rise/downfall into the NBA. We already knew, like her mama, that our girl was a fighter, and I think we could all see where Q was going, so why spend time on that? Worse movies would feel lacking in character development jumping forward like this, but it felt perfectly paced to me.
Maybe it's my on-vacation good mood, but in terms of weaknesses to the film, I'm having a hard time coming up with any. From themes to script to production, Love & Basketball is a classic in the sports movie HoF for a reason.
4.5 out of 5 pukes
4.5 out of 5 pukes
~~~~~~~~~~~
Sam
Let's give it up for genre! I guess this isn't a straight up rom-com (more of a rom-dram); regardless, it's hard to imagine this totally serviceable-to-good movie being made, released widely in theaters, and achieving a solid amount of success today. The history of movies is replete with love stories with solid actors that punch above their weight because of the time, thought, and talent put into them. That feels like a dinosaur today, as this movie would be straight to Netflix and forgotten about.
As it is, Love & Basketball exists as an enjoyable night at the cinema. Omar Epps and Sanaa Lathan work well on their own, but possess amazing chemistry together. Perfectly make that BFF to friends with bennies transition— all very believable and you are rooting for them.
Gina Prince-Bythewood writes and directs a structurally sound and satisfying movie. The four quarters work so well, as they can exist as moments in time, and we don't feel like we miss anything by fast-forwarding. Nothing flashy, but she knows what's she doing.
There's a bit of fat character-wise and plot. The dynamics from the parents are fine, but both moms are a bit one-dimensional. You sort of almost get there with Monica's mom and Q's dad (played by the President from 24), but it's a bit corny. As I often feel, it could have been 90 minutes.
The basketball is sick though. I imagine basketball sicko and producer Spike Lee wasn't going to let trash scenes happen. Shot well and the players are solid. The Lakers and Clippers stuff is fine, but I especially appreciated the rando Temple-USC game—I guess the Owls were cheap to get.
In sum, it's nothing extraordinary—just solid and enjoyable.
GRADE: 3.5
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Zach
This movie is a believable story cloaked in an unbelievable set of occurrences.
I can't believe that his mother would actually show him sex pics. I can't imagine, after all those years, they would just sleep together on the night of the dance. I can't believe the basketball scene at the end would ever actually lead to a broken engagement (with Tyra Banks!) and a shift in destiny. I can't believe the weird scene between Monica and her "prissy" mother—that's one place in the movie where the dialogue felt so unrealistic to me that it made me cringe a little.
It doesn't matter. I want to believe this movie's whole story just because it's so cute and heartwarming.
I want to believe that the two of them went for love and found it, with the only other person who actually understands them. I choose to believe that it's all true. And for me, it is. Because the feelings are true. Somehow, this movie managed to create a believable structure in an unbelievable world, and I loved that.
I also loved the 2000s nostalgia. The "whoop, whoop" during the dance really got me. I forgot how much I miss that. We need to stop taking ourselves so seriously. The world is fun! Let's live in it! The soundtrack here is top-notch. The wardrobes, the cheesily delivered lines, the acting that I don't even think was that good (Omar Epps was the best here though)—it all worked for me.
In terms of big society topics the movie explores, I'd say female beauty reigns supreme. I'd love to know what others thought in the comments on that one. I just felt bad for Monica, to have a mother who only cares about her external appearance and traditional female look (although she does reverse course at the end, although I'd argue not enough) and a college date who appears to be the same. Only Quincy really sees her. I'd be curious what the other USC players thought of beauty standards, but we don't really get to see that. Not a bad treatment of this topic, but could have gone even deeper I think.
This is a movie I'd probably only watch again with a girl leaning her head on my shoulder, but that's good enough.
3.5/5
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Sean G.
I joined my elementary school basketball team in the fifth grade and played for three years. I quickly realized that everyone else was better than I was, and playing made me anxious. I would throw up before practices, sometimes on purpose, because I didn't know how else to relieve my intense dread. I don't know why I kept playing; I scored 11 points in three years. Thankfully this isn't the case for anyone in Love & Basketball.
I really, really enjoyed this movie! It felt instantly rewatchable. Despite some drama between Q and Monica that resulted in them being separated for five years, it was refreshing that nothing so negative happened that it changed the outcome of the movie. What I'm trying to say is that I loved the breeziness of it and the sweet, happy ending. They were passionate about the something they love and they worked really hard to achieve their dreams. They made some mistakes along the way, and learned about themselves from those mistakes and were ready to love each other.
Many films deal with the struggle of giving your whole self to your art or passion while trying to also give your whole self to a person you love. I think Judd Hirsch's speech in The Fabelmans illustrates it perfectly. Love & Basketball makes an entire movie out of it. Your art, or sport, or passion vs your family. How do you balance the two? Can you? What compromises have to be made?
It's so important to consume art that tells a different story than our own. I'm extremely grateful to have seen Love & Basketball. This story of strong Black women, Black men, and their families was beautiful. The world would be a more accepting place if we all listened to the diverse stories only others can tell. We see what makes us different while also seeing how we're all the same really. We're human beings trying to connect with each other. We all have passions, struggles, make mistakes, fall in love, and get hurt.
Some remaining thoughts.
- This cast is stacked, and all of the performances were fantastic.
- I cried twice in this. The scene in the locker room with Monica and her USC team realizing how special their moments with each other are. Sometimes we're lucky enough to share something incredibly special with other people—sometimes just a feeling—and in a moment its gone. We all felt it, but its magic is indescribable. Also cried tears of joy after Q says "Double or nothing." How happy!
- I found this to be deep while also being breezy and fun.
- The sports scenes were exciting and were edited really nicely and shot well. Something many sports movies can struggle with.
- The scene between Monica and her mom talking about what being a woman means to them and what each of them find fulfilling was great. A lot of hard conversations had between parents and their children. Loved it.
4.5 pukes out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Joe
This is absolutely more so an indictment of me and my filmwatching habits than it is a comment on Love & Basketball: I don't know how many movies this white boy watches about Black characters that are not trying to make a point about being Black. Like, I could watch 12 Years a Slave, and that would have something specific to say about race, generational trauma, that sort of thing. Which is important for this white boy to see, and I welcome films like that. But I also welcome films that have something else to say. Love & Basketball has more to say about the human experience of love and innocence and passion, which is not race-specific. This is not a criticism or compliment, it's just an observation about my own tendency to gravitate toward Black cinema that Teaches me, and how sometimes it's just not like that. Am I making sense? I don't know if I'm making sense. This isn't the most important takeaway from this movie, just a idle thought.
Love & Basketball does one of my favorite things in movies. It presents the story in pieces, with many gaps in the timeline unseen, and it trusts the audience to fill in those gaps. The story of Monica and Quincy takes place over the course of twelve years, but the audience really only sees about two months total of that time. We are trusted to imagine what happens when they are in eighth grade, the last three years of college, etc. This also allows much of the tension to build in the background, only to explode on screen for the audience's pleasure. A scene like the fourth-quarter arguments between Monica and her mom might seem to come out of nowhere, except that we're led to believe that this is a fight that's been building for all these years we weren't privy to see. I like that. I think it's skillful when a movie is able to fill us in on what happened without clunky exposition.
I also appreciated the fact that we're kept off the court for a lot of the movie. The important stuff is happening on the sidelines and outside of the gym. Unlike your typical sports movie, which might put a lot of stakes on the outcome of the game, Love & Basketball features its characters gradually coming to the understanding that what happens on the court matters very little in real life. This could be the film meeting me where I'm currently at in my own life. I don't think there's been a time in my life that I've cared about sports in general less than I do right now. It just feels like there's more important shit going on, both in my small life and in the world at large, who gives a fuck how the Phillies are doing?? I don't think Love & Basketball was attempting to make this point, but it meets me there anyway.
But then there is a basketball game that matters in the movie, with real stakes. It's just that that game happens in the backyard. The outcome of that game ("for your heart") was not surprising, but the way the film slowly built up to that climax was masterful. I knew how it was going to end but I still felt that tension. I still choked up a little when we smash-cut to a few years later and saw daddy and baby on the sidelines while mommy played ball and knew for certain the outcome of that game in the driveway. Okay, I take it back—Love & Basketball somehow got me to care about a sports game again.
This was just a really lovely film. The acting was warm and natural, to the point where I cared deeply about these characters by the end of the film. Isn't that kinda nice? To care? I keep returning to this point, but it's important here. I feel like I'm going through something in my life right now where I am having trouble caring. I can feel myself becoming jaded about some of my passions. Love & Basketball features characters on a similar journey. Monica and Quincy share a passion in basketball, but by the end of the film, each character is questioning why they cared about basketball in the first place. I think what Love & Basketball is saying isn't that you should care about any specific thing, but it's saying that you should care about something. To care is to be whole. Monica and Quincy find that they care very deeply about each other. That feels good to me. That feels true.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
See you in the comments for an overtime discussion!
(NEXT TIME: I just read a Pynchon book for the first time, so now the moment is ripe for a Pynchon movie in Inherent Vice.)

4 comments:
Something I was curious about that Sean's write-up got me thinking about was whether you had to RELATE to the sports stuff for a sports movie to really hit. Can someone who hates basketball enjoy Love & Basketball? I would say: probably? Is this really about basketball? Or is basketball more a stand-in for art, passion, and.... uh... love?
I'm starting to think that the whole "slices of life through different moments of the timeline" conceit is one that I really enjoy for movies. I don't have a whole lot of examples though. Steel Magnolias is the only other one that I can think of with a gun to my head (and I fucking LOVED that movie). Any other examples (without spoilers or you're fucking dead to me)??
Pretty much everyone mentioned that this is just a nice movie that was nice to watch, and I definitely agree. Brianna brought up a good point that it was refreshing after some of the other movies we've seen in Film Club lately. I think I usually prefer something like Dogville, some visceral, perplexing shit that really sticks with you... but I'd burn out quickly if that was the entirety of my filmwatching experience. It felt amazing to just sit back and enjoy something like Love & Basketball without necessarily being challenged.
The most liked Letterboxd review:
"the cost of loving an ambitious person! the cost of ambitious people loving each other!"
Thinking about this a lot. About maybe what my life would look like if I had ambition. What my family would look like.
Reminds me of the ending of Friday Night Lights (spoilers) when Coach and Mrs. Coach's ambitions clash and Coach is like "it's your turn." I think about that so much. That mostly happens in this film too, when Q inplies that it's Monica's turn.
Post a Comment