Tuesday, August 26, 2025

Never Seen It #245: Batman

Batman... Batman... Can somebody tell me what kind of a world we live in, where a man dressed up as a blog gets all of my press? This town needs an enema! And also needs to watch 400 movies they've never seen before!


Batman
1989
Tim Burton

I try to go into every movie with an open mind, but I struggle to do that with superhero movies. I'm just tired of hearing about them. I'm sure there is a version of Joe somewhere in the multiverse who loves superhero movies and would totally be down to enjoy the original Tim Burton Batman film, but here on Earth-616, I'm already so fucking tired before the opening credits even hit. Maybe I can get Superman to fly around the earth really fast again, ya know, in the opposite direction, in order to go back in time and kill Kevin Feige and allow my tired adult bones to rest in peace without being pestered with superhero "content" every week for fifteen years of my adult life, and let me just sit and relax and watch a children's movie from 1989 without worrying about annoyance through overexposure.

It's not that I wouldn't be interested otherwise, it's that I have a finite amount of interest. And if a new Superman movie in 2025 is going to be just zeitgeisty enough that I am generally aware of what it's about and what it does and what people thought about it, then there's going to be very little left in the tank for when I actually sit down to watch a goddamn superhero movie for myself. Honestly, at this point I'd rather just let some dumb fanboy sit me down and talk at me about Batman for five minutes than sit down by myself and watch Batman for 130 minutes. Get it over with.

It's also not that I don't care, and couldn't care about comic book lore or whatever. For example, I knew enough to know that, according to most of the Batman canon throughout the character's history, the Joker had nothing to do with the murder of Bruce Wayne's parents, unlike what this film stated. I knew just enough to know that the guy who killed them had a name and a place in the myth, but I had to look up his name. So I spent like five minutes reading the Wikipedia page for Joe Chill, and all about the different variations of the character, including a 2016 story in which Batman visits Joe Chill at the hospital and forgives him for his parents' death before Chill dies of cancer. I really am interested sometimes! Just in small amounts. Maybe a movie is too much for me.

I know what happens in the movies too, more or less. I'm the guy googling "avengers spoilers" right after the newest movie lands in theaters, because I really don't imagine that I'd ever see these movies, but they are interesting enough that wasting three minutes of my time reading the plot description feels worth it to me. I'm not denying anyone else their fun. If watching superheroes destroy cities and drop quips is a good time for you, then that's great, keep doing you. Let me just protect myself by staying out of it for the most part, okay?

I did read about the newest Superman, of course. Something that was praised a lot about the plot was that they dropped you right in the middle of the mythos. Superman already has a handle on his powers, he's already dating Lois, she already knows he's Superman. In other words, this isn't an "origin story" movie, which is good. I don't need to see any more origin stories, since they are mostly all the same. So let us praise Batman for not falling into that trap either. Audiences both today and in 1989 were already well aware that Batman was a billionaire whose parents were murdered in an alleyway and that Batman is seeking to avenge their deaths in a metaphorical and emotional sense by using his vast wealth and knowledge to stop crime. And it was clear that the film knew that they knew it, based on the fake-out in the opening scene. We see a couple and their young son traveling through an alley, and attacked by thieves. They want you to think this is the Waynes. Instead, Batman, already established as a masked vigilante, drops out of the sky and gets the bad guys. This is fine, I don't mind this.

I didn't mind much of the movie, especially when you examine each individual scene. I just get tired when I zoom out and think about the whole thing all at once, and think about the fact that I'm watching another one of these stupid fucking superhero movies. I liked watching Jack Nicholson, for example, but I've already seen the Joker. I've seen a good Joker and a bad Joker and a transcendent Joker. Maybe all of them spawn from the work done by Nicholson here, I'm not denying that. But I haven't seen this Joker until now. And I've seen it before. That's me having movie history backward, which I'm acknowledging, but let's also acknowledge that my experience with this movie would be muted because of that.

A lot of my issues with Batman had to do with the fact that I'm watching a superhero movie, but there were some other issues that I'm confident I would've felt even if this was my first superhero movie ever. Michael Keaton's performance was stiff, for example. Was this on purpose? Was he supposed to be so uncharismatic while in Bruce Wayne form? I don't know why that would be a choice. The city of Gotham also felt really small to me. Every scene felt like it was set on a stage. That took me out of it. Gotham should seem huge and imposing, but in this film, it felt three blocks long. 

That stuff aside, I'll admit that it's not fair to bring baggage to a movie like this. I should be judging it for its own merit, not for having the audacity to inspire dozens and dozens of similar films to pop up forty years later and lie like a smog over the commercial film industry. But I can't help it. I can't remove parts of myself before I watch a movie. I bring baggage, it's unavoidable. I can say that I saw the original Batman now, and move on.

I think the idea of "adapting comics into movies" just took a long time to figure out. And maybe that's a process that's still ongoing. In 1989, they were at the stage where it was just an achievement to get it onto the screen at all, the movie magic allowing for Michael Keaton to jump off of buildings and for the Joker to have a twisted smile just like he does on the page. That was the barrier to entry, and they cleared it. Maybe the barrier is just higher for me now. Like, we know they can adapt comics into movies at this point, but how do you make it INTERESTING? How do you make a major motion picture as interesting as sitting on your computer and reading about Joe Chill for four minutes?

Funny enough, the day after I watched Batman, the Family Movie Night pick (Martha's choice this time) ended up being a superhero movie too. It was 2023's Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse. And let me tell you this: it was FUCKING AWESOME. If the question is how to make the jump from comics to movies exciting and interesting, then this movie proves the answer: make it look like a comic book. The least exciting thing to happen in Across the Spider-Verse was more exciting than the most exciting thing that happened in Batman, and I'm not exaggerating.

It was everything—the look, the feel, the colors and lights, the creativity, the heart. It was all there in the cartoon Spider-Man movie, and all of it was missing in the 1989 film Batman. But that just says to me that this is all a process. Movies in general, but also superhero movies specifically. We built off of what comes before us. I just get impatient when that process is shoved in my fucking face during every waking moment, and I get impatient when I have to go back in time and experience an inferior product, just because it's "important."

Anyways, this was fine.

GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: The Wise Guys Zoom is tonight, at 9 PM! And then come back to this space on Thursday to chat some more about it!

No comments: