Tuesday, August 26, 2025

Song of the Day: "Movin' Out (Anthony's Song)"

A column about music, and about how the music informs our lives. Today's author is Joe. See the previous songs HERE.


"Movin' Out (Anthony's Song)"
Billy Joel
from The Stranger
1977

The Worst Songs, Part II

Purposefully left unmentioned in Part I of our brief reflections on the idea of "worst songs" was the entire discography of William Martin Joel, for which I am absolutely on record in hating, just utterly fucking despising. I didn't mention that jabroni's music because I wanted to give my thoughts on the matter some space to breathe here in another blog post. I don't know if I'm necessarily going to be able to explain anything new, though. It was more or less covered yesterday anyway. This is all supposed to be fun! Hating Billy Joel's music is intended to be a fun little thing that I do! I don't actually care! It's all good!

Like, I can live under the same roof as someone, i.e. my wife, i.e. my best friend and life partner, even though she is a noted Billy Joel fan, likes all the hits, would have no problem sitting down and listening to The Stranger in all its cloying glory. That's fine! I don't think any differently about Pam based on this. We're allowed to have different opinions regarding music. And certainly she's allowed to choose for us to watch Billy Joel: And So It Goes, a four-and-a-half-hour documentary about the guy. I'm not gonna balk over it. It was her choice, and I like spending time with her, and so of course I'll spend four nights in a row watching a classic rock artist talk about his life and perform some of his work. It's all in fun!

And I had a good time! I'm being sincere about this. I almost always enjoy watching music documentaries, regardless of who the subject is, or what I think about that subject's art. It's just cool to see someone who is good at something do that thing. Billy Joel, regardless of what you think about his music, is a good musician. Bonus points because he seems like a cool dude. I liked listening to him talk. He came across as real and down-to-earth. His words felt honest and humble. This wasn't a guy who was high on his own shit; he instead was careful to portray himself as just some fucking guy who worked hard and got some lucky breaks. I like that. I can relate to that.

But I hate the music. Oh my fucking god I hate this shit so much. We already talked about this. "The Piano Man" is a good song (and I have a specific memory from the summer of 2003, hearing it on classic rock radio in the back seat of a neighbor's truck, a neighbor who I'd never really interacted with before until my dad convinced him to give us a ride in his truck across town for reasons I don't quite recall, but you know how it goes with weird nostalgia shit like this). "Movin' Out" is fine, I guess, and I really only allow it to be grandfathered in because it was on that same sample disc that I mentioned in the Shaq review last week. I guess that battleship song that I learned about in YSC is decent, but seeing actual military men and women sing along in the doc kinda soured the experience for me. Other than that? Dogshit, all of it.

The interesting thing is that And So It Goes met this critical negativity head-on. I am not the first person in history to talk smack on the works of Billy Joel. Apparently this was a popular thing to do in the '80s and '90s, and it was interesting to hear Billy Joel himself grapple with his critical reputation. The doc was careful to trace it all the way to the mid-'10s, during his critical resurgence, rightfully capping off the doc by positioning him as one of the all-time classic rock giants, but I'm less interested in that. I liked hearing Billy Joel talk about how people hated Billy Joel. (One of the funniest moments of the whole five hours was an archived pic of a younger Billy Joel standing next to graffiti that read "BILLY JOEL SUCKS MY DICK.")

One hypothesis was that critics hated Billy Joel because he "lacked a strong identity." In other words, because he was able to tackle so many different sounds and styles throughout the years, critics lambasted him because he therefore lacked coherence. That may have been true, but I would personally distance myself from such an assessment. That's actually one of the things that I admire about Billy Joel, and any other artist that pushes themselves out of their own comfort zones. I like how one album is a serious synth-led ballad-fest and the next is an old-school rockabilly throwback. That doesn't make the songs themselves any more palatable to me, but I really do admire how he manages to make so many different styles of music sound so incredibly fucking lame.

"Lame" is probably hitting at the heart of the matter more for me than anything else. It's a loaded term to discuss, because it's so fucking subjective, and also depends heavily on who we're talking about. Here's my thing with "lame"—it's not a blanket criticism for me, but instead it really does depend on the artist. Lame can be cool in an ironic sense if the artist is small enough that they can pull off the irony. An artist of Billy Joel's stature just simply cannot do the same, due to how popular they are. They are popular because they are sincere. And that's lame. I'll admit that I probably would be more willing to engage with this guy's music if critics still hated him. That's just how it goes.

One of the more fascinating lines from doc, one that hit home pretty good for me, was Joel's long-time drummer (Liberty DiVitto) talking about how Joel outlasted his critics, and he says something like, "and all those dumb music critics, where are they now?!" Pam immediately made a joke like "they're typing on a blog."

She's not wrong, but neither is DiVitto. Billy Joel is one of the most popular and well-known rock artists of the last 100 years, and who the fuck am I? Just some fucking asshole with a blog, typing away to the few friends who are patient and kind enough to listen, just some fucking prick who will be forgotten in an instant, while Billy Joel's name will ring out for years and years and years after he passes away from this mortal coil. It made me happy for him, to acknowledge this reality. It made me feel sad about myself too, I won't lie. Wasn't this supposed to be fun?

A couple days after that, I was thanking Pam for making me watch the documentary, since, despite still hating this fucking music, I really enjoyed my time with the artist, and sincerely liked learning about him and about his life and thoughts about life. But Pam reacted poorly to that, and expressed sadness. Apparently she was hoping that I would learn to like the music after watching the documentary. Which caught me off-guard.

Because I thought we were just having fun, ya know? That's what we're supposed to be doing when we're talking about music that we hate. It's all in fun. I don't need to love everything. I need to be open to new experiences, but hearing the same moldy old hits of Billy Joel that I've heard a million times is not a new experience. The documentary changed nothing. I don't like his music. And furthermore, I should feel safe not liking it. He's not going to be personally hurt by my opinion. All these words about my dislike on this public blog will not move the needle one single iota on the subject of Billy Joel. I can speak with impunity here, without fear of harming anyone.

Since it's all in fun, then I feel the need to underline the fact that I'm not actually questioning why you like what you like, even if what you like is something putrid like "Scenes from an Italian Restaurant." I think it's really cool when someone likes something, unabashedly and wholeheartedly. Liking music is cool, even if the music you like is lame. Passion is cool. Defending what you like is also cool. Just generally being aware of music and caring about music and caring about what you like and dislike, that's all really fucking cool. I liked seeing all of Billy Joel's fans sing along to his music, even if I would never do the same.

It scares me that people think that this is actually important to me. This is what's important to me: that music exists, and that I continue to seek out good music, and that I am aware of the music that I do not like, and that I have the knowledge and ability to speak out about music that I like and dislike, and that there are people around me willing to engage in conversation with they agree and especially when they disagree. This is what's NOT important to me: whether you like what I like, or dislike what I dislike.

It's all in fun. Let me like what I like, and I'll let you like what you like, and we can meet in the middle and talk about it. No matter what, I think it's cool that you have an opinion. And no matter what that opinion is, I Love You Just the Way You Are.

No comments: