"Laughing Song"
Black Country, New Road
from Live at Bush Hall
2023
***trigger warning for, I dunno, general unfortunate circumstances and violence in the real and hypothetical, some child abuse, that sorta thing***
I'm finding recently that I have a tougher time taking things seriously, even when the context surrounding the situation calls for seriousness. I noticed it recently when I first heard about the hoax at Villanova's opening weekend. It's possible that there's been an update to the story that I didn't care enough to read about, but from what I gathered at the story's breaking, someone made a false claim that there was an active shooter situation at Nova, which caused mass panic and probably some trauma for the freshman who were orienting themselves to college life. I saw a headline about this, saw that no one was hurt, kinda forgot about it for a little bit, until Pam mentioned it, and I giggled.
"It's not funny!" she said. And she was right. It's not funny. It's fucked up and it caused undue mental stress and harm and it was careless and it does damage by sanding down a very real danger of gun violence in the U.S. and it might've caused panic enough that stampede injuries might have occurred, and how would I have liked it if my first weekend at La Salle I was told that someone was trying to shoot me, and so on and so on. But I still laughed a little bit.
I dunno, man, it's not like anyone was hurt. It was Villanova, right? Fuck that school! It was a suburbs, the place where people go because they are too afraid of Philadelphia. It felt like a cosmic joke of sorts, at least to me, a guy who defends my city's reputation and gets pissed when people imply that the suburbs are somewhere you can go to be "safe" from the so-called "danger" of the city, that people who actually believe that shit might run to Nova with their tails tucked between their legs and then are immediately faced with an active shooter hypothetical. And no one was hurt! This blog post wouldn't exist if there actually was an active shooter, because it wouldn't be funny!
The way I articulated my explanation about the giggling over the news headline was that, ya know, look at the world around us. Too much outrageous injustice that we gotta swallow every fucking day, too much class warfare that's resulting in untold deaths, and who knows, maybe we're next. And so I'm consciously choosing to laugh in the face of the danger that feels safe to laugh at. If I don't choose some headlines to laugh at, then I'm going to go fucking insane. "Hoax directed toward Villanova students" feels like a good one to laugh at, so I'm going to laugh.
That's what I told her, and I think it's mostly the truth, but there is also the possibility that I am leaving out a crucial piece of the explanation. The other piece being that I'm damaged in some way. Either damaged at birth or gradually worn down and made numb by the constant reminder of the shittiness of the world that we live in. Possible that it's not a choice, but rather a lack of choice, that I cannot help but be the way that I am because of nature and nurture. Something is wrong with me, that I would see this particular headline and laugh.
I think about this a lot when it comes to my job. The nature of my job involves me hearing about some gruesome shit, and I've been doing this for eleven years now, so I feel like I'm at the point where I've heard it all already, and will hear it all again tomorrow morning. This is fine. I can deal with it. I'm not "scarred" or anything. Far from it. Maybe the way I am, the nature and the nurture, actually make me perversely fit for this job.
The problem is when other people ask me about my job, and I forget that other people are not already worn down about this kind of thing, and I say some casual detail about my work and the person I tell recoils in horror. You saw what? they might say, and then my mind clicks back into place and I realize like, oh shit, this might actually be traumatizing for someone else. I try to play it cool, but the cat's already out of the bag. They already think I'm a monster for having no strong feelings about the thing that I said happened.
I forget if I've written about this particular incident on the blog before—probably in passing—but it's my go-to example when I'm talking about this phenomenon, this idea that social workers get their perspective all twisted in both harmful and self-protective ways, just through constant exposure. It was the morning of Super Bowl LII. I work on Sundays, and my specific role on Sunday mornings is to investigate reports of child abuse that need to be handled in a timely manner (i.e. before the intake department returns on Monday morning). This shit doesn't stop because the Eagles are hours away from winning their first Super Bowl in history.
One of my reports was: child is a Patriots fan, and mother is an Eagles fan, and child stated that he asked to wear his Patriots jersey to school on previous Friday, and mother responded by punching child in the face.
Now, I've told people about this report, and the only time I've been greeted with giggles is from other social workers. Anyone else I've told has been aghast that I'd be telling them such an anecdote with a smirk on my face. I get it. Child abuse isn't funny. An eleven-year-old getting punched by his mother is not funny. I agree!
It's not even funny when I try to explain the context surrounding it. First, that most of the reports I get are bullshit, and of fucking course I went out to that house and talked to the kid and of course the punch never even happened, and he looked at me all sad because his teachers at his school misinterpreted what he had said and took it too far and made a dumb child abuse report. Second, that this plays into the infamous Philadelphia reputation of being violent, and that there's irony in me fighting back against that reputation so incessantly but then also having to investigate whether a Philly mom punched her Patriots fan son. Third, that everyone in Philadelphia, every single person who frowns when I tell them about this report, was also out there on the fucking streets that very same night hollering about how we should punch Patriots quarterback (and name on the back of that kid's jersey) Tom Brady in the motherfucking face.
None of that makes it funny, but witness me typing it all out in that paragraph and laughing under my breath about it all, still. I suppose I'm still laughing about it because no one was actually hurt, but on my darkest days, I wonder if I'd still be laughing a little bit even if the kid was actually punched in the face. Probably not. Maybe a little. Maybe more in a "the world is absolutely fucked and I'm turning into the Joker" sort of way.
Out of the thousands of reports that I've dealt with over the last decade-plus, exactly one of them has actually caused some tangible trauma. Like more in a "I think about this report all the time and it makes me sad" sort of way, which is different than the non-traumatic reports that I immediately forget about. I'm not saying that it keeps me up at night or gives me panic attacks or anything. It's just on my mind sometimes, and it hurts whenever it pops up.
The report that I'm talking about involved a kid who traveled to Wildwood, NJ with his family, and arrived at the hotel they were staying at, and was really excited to see his cousins, and him and his cousins were all happy and jumping around and running around while the adults unpacked, and this kid slipped and hit his head and drowned in the hotel pool.
Obviously, I'm not laughing as I write that one out. I actually got a little choked up as I typed it, which means the (mild) trauma is still there. Child mortality is about the most unfunny thing I could possibly think of. Tie in the fact that this is the sort of situation that could easily, easily happen to my own family. The situation in which the kids are excited to see cousins and get a little wild and the parents lose sight of the supervision during their own greetings? I'm in that situation constantly. That's probably why this report is constantly on my mind.
The humor (if you can even call it that, and if you can, it's a dark twisted humor) that I could possibly mine from this is the humor directed inward, the self-deprecating kind, the same kind of humor that one might find in your third car crash, a sort of situational irony. How many kids are traveling from Philadelphia to Wildwood and dying in a way that would require Philadelphia child welfare's involvement? How many reports specifically like this could there possibly be in one lifetime? What are the chances that the one single asshole who constantly visits Wildwood with his own children and constantly writes about Wildwood on his stupid-ass blog is the guy who is assigned that one single report? Also, do you understand how hungover I was on that Sunday morning when I investigated this report? A cosmic punishment for every time I abused substances in Wildwood, pressing down upon me as I sat there in a deathly silent living room with a mother who was living through the worst tragedy she'll ever face and now has to exist in the same room as this sick asshole who is sweating gin out of every pore. None of this is funny, but it kind of is, if you think I deserve to feel this way. Maybe I do.
But now I'm just getting off-track, because my original point was that I need to laugh at incidents in which no one gets hurt, and obviously this Wildwood child abuse report doesn't fall into that category. Maybe the fact that I felt the need to bring up that report means that I'm not over it, and that a lot of the laughter that I discover coming out of my mouth is a defense mechanism, that I have trouble dealing with how terrible the world seems sometimes, and I think subconsciously that if I laugh, it'll heal me in some way.
Most headlines that I see are depressing as well. I feel hopeless and helpless most of the time. Let me just laugh at the Villanova kids a little bit. I'm not making a big deal about it. I don't revel in their suffering. I just think that a shooter hoax is like the least worst thing that I've heard in a while, and I don't have the capacity to get all that upset for these Nova kids, or else I'm gonna fucking snap. Let me giggle. It's a little funny.
No comments:
Post a Comment