Monday, August 25, 2025

Song of the Day: "Home"

A column about music, and about how the music informs our lives. Today's author is Joe. See the previous songs HERE.


"Home"
Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeros
from Up from Below
2009

The Worst Songs, Part I

I don't get paid for this, and I write a lot, so I'm usually writing in advance, sometimes "too far" in advance, and that means PoYB is very rarely timely in its participation with the "discourse," which is a term that I loathe but nonetheless acknowledge the existence of, and acknowledge its position adjacent to any blogs like this one that happen to exist on the same internet. The "discourse" (I can't bring myself to type that word without the quotation marks, I'm sorry) three weeks ago involved the song "Home" by Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeros, and a bold claim that it was the "worst song of all time." (This "discourse" was more niche, more specific to our music-centric corner of the internet, than more recent "discourse" involving that actress and eugenics, a "discourse" that I hope no PoYB contributor will attempt to touch with a ten-foot blogging pole, thank you.)

If you're pretending that such a question as "worst song ever" isn't subjective, you're doing it wrong. All music criticism, positive or negative or even neutral, is subjective. Even if someone claims that something is "objective," then they are just twisting the definition of the word "objective" to make a hyperbolic subjective claim. It's fun, basically. It's fun to say someone is "right" and someone is "wrong" about some opinion, because within the framework of subjectivity, right and wrong are all dependent on individual perspective, so it's gonna be all over the board. If everyone can be right and everyone can be wrong, then no one is right or wrong, and conversations can thus stretch forever. This helps to pass the time.

If you're not having fun, then you are also doing it wrong. This isn't life-or-death shit that we're dealing with here. We're just talking about music. You're allowed to like what you want to like. You're allowed to hate what you want to hate. You're encouraged to discuss the matter when you like something that someone else hates, or hate something that someone else likes. Be a good sport about it, and we all get to live our best lives, and maybe even make a friend or two. 

For the sake of the discussion, I'll state my opinion of "Home" for the record. I dislike the song, and I have long disliked the song. I wasn't overzealous about my dislike or anything. I wasn't sitting online like a fucking loser watching their Tiny Desk Concert with steam coming out of my ears. I have very little written evidence on this blog to prove that I have disliked this song (Pam beat the "discourse" by a full year and half by writing about this song, and later that month, I listed it as one of the "worst songs" from that month of YSC, but that's it for me).

I've heard it more over the years than your average indie rock amateur music critic snob, since my wife has or had an affection for it, and would often play it on car rides. I don't typically make it a point to tell her specifically when I dislike a song that she is playing for just the two of us (or the five of us, depending on whether the kids are in the car and are letting us switch away from "Steve's Lava Chicken"). So this wasn't a thing where she was playing the song knowing that I disliked it.

If I'm being honest, the embers of my hate for "Home" did not burn all that brightly. It really wasn't that big of a deal. Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeros weren't that popular. Known for this song and for being proto-stomp-and-clap forebearers, predating Lumineers and Mumford, while adding a mild psych twist, they were and probably still are fated to be forgotten. It's not worth wasting my hatred on a band of their size.

Well, okay, there are two ways of looking at this. One is that it's more fun to dislike a band when they are big. Let the size of your hatred correlate to the size of the band's popularity. That's why you'll find constant references to my hatred of Queen and Simon & Garfunkel on this blog, but very little mention of my hatred of Edward Sharpe. The other way is to choose a niche band that no one really cares about either way, and focus all your hatred on them. That can be fun too, because in those cases, the joke is on you. It's not "why do you hate them?" but "why do you hate them?"

Neither of those situations applies to "Home." Especially not after the dogpiling of the song by the anonymous hoards on the internet. In fact, I'll say that something like this happening makes me dislike them less. I'm watching that Tiny Desk Concert that everyone seemed to agree was the most embarrassing thing of all time, and I'm thinking, ya know, it's not that bad (especially since they complete excise the whole "I was falling deeply, deeply in love with you" interlude, by far the worst part of "Home"). The lady that everyone assumes is high on heroin is probably not high one heroin, based on how well she stays on the beat and hits her notes.

I'm still operating under the assumption that "the majority can and will be wrong" when it comes to this shit. I'm still that contrarian teenager when we're talking about music. I dislike it... but wait, everyone else dislikes it too?! Well then never mind, now I like it. Take that!! This happens in both directions. If the critical consensus for Queen suddenly started turning, then my first reaction would be "I was here first!" and my second reaction would be "shit, I guess it's time to do a full run-through of the Queen discography to figure out why everyone is wrong." But if there was a critical resurgence of something that I felt alone in defending, maybe Black Eyed Peas' hits or something, and critics were suddenly like "actually, this is high art," then I would probably in turn be like "actually, I hate this shit."

Are other people's opinions affecting my own opinions too much? Almost assuredly. But that's all part of the fun. It's fun acting, and it's fun reacting. It's fun to have an opinion, to act like you're right, and it's fun when other people have different opinions and you get to act like they are wrong. If you're taking it too seriously, you're doing it wrong.

I don't need to hear "Home" ever again, though.

2 comments:

Gloria said...

I like this song and was really surprised when it was being called the worst song of all time. But I also bought “Up From Below” in 2009 when I was first starting college— I loved that album even though haven’t thought about it in years. It’s definitely dated; but it makes sense in the context of that early 2000s psychedelic folk revival— it was a very specific vibe in a very specific time

But maybe don’t listen to me, I would have listed Edward Sharpe as a favorite band around the same time I would have listed Coffee and Cigarettes as a favorite movie, haha

Joe K said...

I think a lot of the criticisms of this band and this song are borne of a certain brand of hipster cynicism that I believe that you lack, which is a very good thing, and something I admire about you. Don't let this world make you cynical about dopey-ass shit like Edward Sharpe!!!