Wednesday, August 20, 2025

A Year of Blind Spots: Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge

Joe is working through a list of albums that he considers "blind spots," i.e. albums that he's never heard but feels like he should.


Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge
Mudhoney
1991

What 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die has to say about Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge by Mudhoney:

Because of Mudhoney's lack of commercial success compared to their Seattle peers, detractors called them the guys from Green River who did not join Pearl Jam. Their fans called them pioneers of grunge, and the raw, frenetic, and confident third album Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge supports the fans' argument.

With its whimsical lyrics and angry sound filled out with fuzz-infused guitars and heavy drums, Mudhoney sounded like a 1950s garage band on speed. Even a cursory listen indicates that theirs was a formula copied by a host of other bands. Songs such as "Thorn" show off the surf-rock capabilities of drummer Dan Peters and Fifties-style solo riffs of guitarist Steve Turned, while anticipating the angry sound of grunge just around the corner. The album's lead single, "Let It Slide," would become a minor grunge anthem, with its whining lyrics and quintessential Seattle mix of distorted guitars, hummable melody, and nihilistic tendencies.

The album persists in the memory as one long, smug sneer, from the irreverent title to the vocal delivery and lyrics. ("Into the Drink," a song about dumping a girlfriend into a river, features a repetitive gang shout of the song's title during the chorus.) They even find ironic use for organ and harmonica.

Mudhoney's musical approach never led them to platinum records, but Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge is a classic album, one of the best of the genre.

What Joe has to say about Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge by Mudhoney:

By my count, this is the ninth album in aYoBS that could reasonably be labeled "grunge." I've probably typed about this before, but Mudhoney really nailed it home for me today—I really don't know what grunge is. I do in that I can hear a song on Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge and say "that sounds like grunge," but the truth of the matter is that I hear this and I make a comparison to Bleach by Nirvana, and I know that Nirvana is grunge because, I mean, c'mon, but if you asked me to explain it to you, I am incapable of reasoning beyond that. But you can listen to this album too, and you'd tell me the same thing.

I am probably getting bands mixed up, but if you asked me about Mudhoney before this week, I probably would've said that I had heard that they were known as a sub-par example of the genre (when we eventually discover, accidentally, who I actually mean, I'll note it in this column). But that's not right. First, I actually thought this was a really fun, abrasive album, and I couldn't find any evidence of any widespread critical opinion to the contrary. Second, and more importantly, they are more... proto-grunge, I guess? That's probably overstating it too, but look. This came out three months before Nevermind. They hail from Seattle. They were on Sub Pop. And, crucially, they never really achieved commercial success. So this is one of those bands that other, more well-known bands derive from.

Mudhoney stuck around for a long time (the verbs on Wikipedia are in present tense, and their most recent album was in 2023), but are far from a household name. I think that makes sense. Nirvana was a freak thing, and burned out. Pearl Jam was a freak thing, and they survive only because they are a jam band now that has successfully capitalized on their commercial catalog. Mudhoney followed the extremely normal course of releasing some good music and being completely forgotten. Except for the book, which is doing its due diligence in document the IMPORTANT albums if not necessarily the BEST albums.

It may not be the best, but yo, I really enjoyed listening to Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge. I'd be a liar if I said that 1001 Albums' description of "a 1950s garage band on speed" wasn't helpful in this regard. "On speed" is a lame-ass way to say it, but the idea of a rock band from the era of Buddy Holly finding themselves playing something from out of their time was a good way to imagine it. Because this is how genres are created, right? Someone takes something from before them, and makes it new. They are playing to the future, not the past. Mudhoney sounds like the past's future on this album. 

I'm having trouble coming up with comparisons beyond Nirvana. At one point, during one song that always passes me by because I'm so entranced, I convince myself that there is a Violent Femmes influence in here. Maybe my confusion of the "what it sounds like" is that I'm trying to work backwards, Mudhoney being the influencer and not the influenced, but of course I'm moving backwards sometimes in my discoveries, and can't help but hear everything I know about grunge contained in these surprisingly varied songs.

In any case, you know what you're getting into at this point, so why don't you check out some grunge that you might not be familiar with yet:

No comments: