Charles Mingus
1963
Aw, here we go with the jazz shit again. I've been really expanding my horizons in this genre throughout 2025. I don't know if I've made any progress, per se, but I am definitely not hating anything. So maybe that's the progress right there. Though "hate" is overstating things, because I've never really hated jazz. I've written about it before, there are receipts! I like the idea of liking jazz, it's just that liking jazz is usually out of my reach. I keep trying, though. I keep trying different combinations and different gimmicks, seeing if anything fits.
How did we end up here? I figured that it was time to check out a jazz album that was consistently rated highly on RateYourMusic. I don't always agree with the bullshit that the community there upholds—way too much experimental shit, way too many metal albums—but hey, why not jazz? Worth a try. I see Mingus all over the all-time charts over there. The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady is ranked as the #1 album of 1963. Here I am.
It's marked as "experimental," and we've tried experimental jazz before, to mixed results. I always think about Alice Coltrane in this regard, how batshit her experimental jazz was, both courageous and borderline unlistenable. But here's my theory: Universal Consciousness came out in 1971, and The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady came out in 1963, and the definition of "experimental" changed exponentially in those eight years. It's just a theory, because I still know very little about jazz. But I do know that music as a whole changed rapidly during this decade, and so why not jazz? I further theorized that maybe an experimental jazz album from much earlier in the timeline would actually be a really good fit for me, interesting before the idea of "experimental jazz" would go completely off the rails.
Without using hyperbole by saying something like "I love jazz now!", I'll simply say that Charles Mingus hits the mark I was hoping he would. This is jazz, so I'm at a half-arm's length still, but as compared to the jazz I "know," this is extremely interesting and enjoyable. It's accessible in that there are motifs that I can follow. It's clearly playing with standard jazz forms, by fucking with the tempo a lot, adding in discordant notes, and playing with overt non-jazz sounds like Spanish flamenco and ballet classical. So if it's fascinating by being weird-for-its-time, but simple in the way that only 60-year-old music can be, then Charles Mingus finds the best of both worlds for this jazz-ignorant asshole, which I, the asshole, appreciate.
This isn't the first jazz album in this column. I have no idea if it'll be the last. I do think, however, that I have enough experience with this genre to be able to tell you what works best. I think a jazz album can be good enough that it acts as a "good beginner's album" for non-jazz people. A Love Supreme was the ultimate example of this, a jazz album that teaches you about jazz while being extremely competent with all the jazz. The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady is a good next step. It's competent, it's accessible, but it also pushes the boundaries. This feels more "out there" than A Love Supreme. The timing doesn't quite work out, with A Love Supreme coming out two years later. But I'm not talking about true chronology, I'm talking about the hypothetical process of "getting into jazz." You don't start here with Mingus, but you move onto this album pretty quickly, and gain a lot of ground in the process.
That being said, it's still jazz, so if you are steadfast in your belief that this genre will never be for you, then I'm not sure what to tell you. I at least want to try, and in trying, I got to know this pretty good album. If you have it in you to make one last go at liking jazz, maybe this is your last hope.

2 comments:
I like the idea of “beginner albums.” The ones you picked are classic choices! Keep it up and you’ll be joining us for Jazz Fest next year, haha
I looked at the lineup for your festival this weekend. There were a surprising number of RC alumni at Jazz Fest this year! The Roots, Janelle Monáe, WILLOW. Hope you're having fun! I don't know how many straight-up jazz albums are going to show up in Record Club in the near future, but I'm definitely looking forward to continuing this jazz journey in some other corners of the blog.
Post a Comment