Allow me to begin with a question for you, dear blog readers.
When reviewing a piece of art or entertainment, which should play a bigger role in deciding an ultimate "score"? The technical mastery on display? Or the enjoyment of the observer/listener?
Eschewing the debate on whether art/entertainment even should be given scores (that's a different thing), I have to admit that I struggled with listening to Sigur Rós's Valtari. I gave it a couple listens, and I don't think it's necessarily bad. I just feel unable to connect any songs on this album in a way that makes me want to revisit them, or even remember their individual titles.
My main source of familiarity with Sigur Rós comes from their cameo in a 2014 episode of HBO's Game of Thrones. I knew that they were Icelandic, and that might have given me the expectation of them sounding like Of Monsters and Men.
Valtari does not sound like Of Monsters and Men.
On paper, I could see how I'd have higher expectations to enjoy this music. Wikipedia shows that this album had a tie-in film project, which sounds awesome. And I do like snippets of some of the songs on this album. "Ég anda" has some admirable qualities, for example. But then I can't get into "Ekki múkk" at all. I bring up the film project because most of these songs sound like they belong as part of a film score, and as someone who listens to film scores for ambience sometimes, that's pretty cool, and a goal I can applaud as successful.
My issue, though, is the repetitive nature of this album. A lot of the songs are tough to distinguish from each other, even on multiple listen-throughs. Add the fact that all of the songs, except for one, are over six minutes long, and it all starts to bleed together into noise. "Varðeldur" is probably the worst offender.
Again, I like long songs (I recommended a thirteen-minute Iron Maiden song on this blog recently). I like film scores. I don't need English lyrics.
And yet, and yet, and yet...
I can't pinpoint what exactly is stopping me from loving, or at least liking, Valtari, but I need to still note that I can appreciate what it's doing. So, no, I didn't enjoy this album. However, that doesn't mean I can't recognize it as "good."
Stand out tracks: "Ég anda," "Varúð," and "Dauðalogn"
Rating: 3 out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment