Friday, August 29, 2025

Song of the Day: "1000 Stars"

A column about music, and about how the music informs our lives. Today's author is Joe. See the previous songs HERE.


"1000 Stars"
Big Country
from The Crossing
1983

I use "pukes" instead of "stars" when reviewing something and giving it a grade. This has been bit long enough (and has been lampshaded enough times) that it's ceased to be noticed. It's normal. We're on Puke on Your Birthday. The grades I give are out of five pukes. Just a normal day.

I don't and have never forced anyone to use the "x pukes out of 5" system. The vast majority of reviews that come across my desk, mainly Record Club, don't feature any grade at all. And that's cool too. Maybe music shouldn't be graded. Maybe you get more of a sense of how the author feels without the grade. That's a valid argument.

My argument of pro-grading is twofold. One, having a grade at the bottom of the review actually relieves some of the pressure of having to make your feelings crystal clear within the review itself. If you really want to know where on the negative-to-positive scale I feel about this album, please feel free to see the grade; otherwise, enjoy this creative writing assignment. It gives me more freedom to write what I want, and have even the dumbest bullshit function as a "review," being anchored by that grade at the bottom.

Two, it gives me a really good sense about my tastes in music over a long period of time. Grades give me something quantitative to track. I can say that certain albums I liked better than others, but I can also say that certain time periods of my life had better music than others. I can say that certain years treated me better than others. I can get an average of every single RC grade that I've ever given, and then compare it to, say, the average of every movie I've ever reviewed, and wonder why the movie grade average is so much higher. It's cool to have the data available, if I ever wanted to explore it. 

With this in mind, I recently started to force people to give a grade for the movies they watch in Film Club. Just because I wanted that sense of satisfaction for other people too. It's fun to write creatively; it's also fun to have a shorthand in order to say "wow, I liked Mommie Dearest more than Love & Basketball" or some shit like that. Eventually, the grades Film Club members are forced to give will unshackle them from the chains of "I have to write a movie review" that so many members still feel. Let loose, write whatever you want, however you wanna write it, and let that grade do a lot of the talking.

Even then, there is so much variation between people with the numbers. A 3/5 means something different to everyone. Getting a sense of each person's own scale can only come with time and patience. The more grades a person gives, the clearer a person's tastes come into focus. It eventually gets to the point where you're like "oh wow, John is pretty grumpy when it comes to movies but he gave this FOUR pukes out of five, holy shit," or "yeah, Greg gave out another five pukes, but he does that for so many albums, it's tough to tell whether this is gonna be great or just good," that kind of thing. The more times you grade something, the more power you have to use shorthand and take the pressure off yourself to say everything you need to say in so many words.

I don't know if I could explain my own scale, and what that looks like. Mostly because it varies across the different grades. I.e. a 2.5 pukes out of 5 grade could mean three different things, even though, yeah, they are all roughly the same in terms of quality. I wonder if I tried to explain my scale, if I would be able to? Let me spend another couple hundred words attempting it, and then you can rest until my graded HAIM review is published at 7 AM.

0 pukes = really fucking bad, the worst of the worst, but also artistically bankrupt in some way, like I hate engaging with it but also wish it didn't exist so I didn't have to think about it

0.5 pukes = really fucking bad, the worst of the worst, but also maybe bad in a fun way, or bad in a way that is interesting to me (way more common than 0 pukes, since I just love talking about music, no matter the quality, and it's tough for me to imagine too many scenarios in which that would change)

1 puke = really fucking bad, but a couple redeeming qualities, a broken-watch-right-twice-per-day kind of situation, maybe one good song or one actor who is killing it or something like that

1.5 pukes = kinda bad, mostly boring, not much to talk about, disappointed that the artist couldn't make something better, but yeah, I do think the artist had it in them to make this better, it just didn't happen

2 pukes = I didn't like it but something about it suggests that this is my fault, not the artist's, but still, yeah, I didn't like it

2.5 pukes = it was fine, I didn't hate it, but I was kinda bored with it, even though it's easy to acknowledge the things that went well, and the disparate parts that I enjoyed

3 pukes = pretty good but in average ways, I enjoyed it but something is holding me back from saying that I really liked it

3.5 pukes = really good, I enjoyed it a lot, but it didn't make me feel anything special, it was more of a low-simmer love, with noticeable flaws that can be explained away but still clearly exists

4 pukes = loved it, thought there was a couple of misfires but they don't really matter in the grand scheme of things, this was really good and I'd recommend it, but I didn't feel butterflies in my stomach about it

4.5 pukes = really special, I really enjoyed it, maybe made me feel incredible but had one flaw that is easily explained away, or maybe I didn't feel that explosion of wonder and amazement when it ended, which either way means it wasn't perfect

5 pukes = more or less perfect, something that is made incredibly well back-to-front and also leaves me feeling elated, like I know I'm witnessing greatness as it's happening in real time, and that feeling is sustained throughout, and it excites me and makes me feel differently about the world almost immediately, and yeah is just enjoyable throughout

These descriptions don't apply to every single album or movie that has received such a mark, they are more just general examples. It also varies depending on the medium, as evidenced by the fact that there are a maybe a dozen movies that I've given 5 pukes to, and yet I've never given 5 pukes to any Record Club album (yet!). Probably because films can have an immediate impact on me, whereas the best albums usually need more than a week to grow into a 5-puker (and plus, any album that has grown into a 5-puker for me has probably already been written about enough on this blog that it would be ineligible for RC selection anyway).

Or, like, there was at least one movie that got 2.5 pukes, but only because half of it was absolutely perfect, and the other half was embarrassing racist dogshit. Shit like that is why I'll never be able to explain my personal 0-5 scale in one blog post even if I tried. It's only able to be explained over the course of years, and by stacking up hundreds of grades and writing about each piece of art and giving a general sense over time what grade means what and why.

My hope was that eventually, I'd get to the point where the grades actually mean something. But that could just be me taking myself too seriously. Ain't that usually the case.

No comments: