Friday, August 1, 2025

Valtari, Joe


Sometimes I think that my life is boring. If I speak this thought out loud, there is usually a negative reaction to it from others. They tell me my life is most certainly not boring, and they say this because they are trying to protect me, because they fear the boredom, fear that this is me being self-deprecating. And maybe it is, but I'm not talking about boredom in a subjective way. I'm being objective here. If I say my life is boring then I'm comparing it to a film, maybe... that there isn't much in my life that would pop up there on the screen. Maybe Wim Wenders could turn my life into some mumbly film without any notable incidents, the type of movie that's gonna piss off my father-in-law if he ever saw it. You can say a lot about those types of films but you can also, technically, find them boring. And so when I say my life is boring, I'm just saying it's not exciting like a movie makes life seem exciting, which is fine. Boredom is normal, in this context.

I'm just tossing this idea around as I listen to Valtari, because I find that the music—or, more like sounds, tones, whatever synonyms you wanna use to sound like you're being a little dismissive—sounds to me more like a film soundtrack than a collection of songs made by a rock band that I would ever choose to listen to. I'm listening to Valtari as I go about my boring life, and I'm listening to Valtari as a film soundtrack, and so my life becomes the film, and my life is by and large very boring, and so the film soundtrack that is supposed to be soundtracking important, life-altering moments, so integral to the plot, is instead soundtracking my train ride to work, typing endless notes on a laptop, baking chicken breasts in the oven, clearing the living room of cheap scattered kids' toys, and it just doesn't work. "Varúð" hits a new high with two minutes left to go, and it feels unearned. My life is not a movie (or maybe).

I like framing my dislike of Valtari in this way because it protects me from the "it's just not for me" criticism, which is probably closer to the truth but makes life—you guessed it—even more boring. I'm never going to love the endless ambient falsetto noise, but I can at least get to the point where I appreciate this shit for what it is, and what it attempts to be. This is music meant to soundtrack the important moments. I like saying that my life is boring because that puts the impetus on me to say that it's my fault that I don't like Valtari. Maybe if I could work up the strength (or courage?) to change things on a Tuesday morning, to find myself in the middle of an incident after which things will NEVER be the same, like Act II of a movie, the incident that revs those plot engines, if I found my life there instead of finding it in boredom, maybe I would love this album for how it made those moments feel even more important, adding layers to it. 

I can make my life seem more exciting than it actually is. That's no problem. I do that all the time here. I wouldn't be able to write around 10,000 words a week for four years straight if I didn't have the capacity to take some of those boring aspects and refashion them into something extraordinary, even if it's mostly a ruse to fuel the words that comprise each blog post.

If I tell Pam—the love of my life and partner in all of life's endless boredom—that I feel sometimes that something is "missing," I think what I'm trying to say is that I keep listening to shit like Valtari, expecting my life to match that music, but it rarely does anymore. But what she hears is something else. She's quick to point out that I have a hobby that takes up a lot of my day, and she's confused because this thing here is the thing that's supposed to give my life that extra fulfillment. She has it backwards, though. The blog and everything connected to it—Record Club, Film Club, that kind of shit—is designed to filter life and find meaning in it. Those things don't create the meaning, they're just a filter. Occasionally, it's alchemy, i.e. creating meaning from nothing. Which is fine. The search has value. But an endless search does not an exciting life make.

And so what is music's role in all this? The good music is sometimes good because it distracts from the emptiness and boredom; it's so good that it temporarily makes you forget about the things that are bothering you. Other types of good music are deep and make it easier to perform the actions on that quest for meaning; what you feel is good and the way that it's presented is interesting and says something new to you, and later about you, and that makes it good. I don't think Valtari fits into either of these categories, so it's not good music. It's boring music that, even worse, does a really great job at reminding me how boring my life is. It doesn't tell me anything new about myself that I didn't already know. I already knew that my life was boring. Sigur Rós is just rubbing it in.

I would be fascinated to learn that I am the only person with a negative opinion about Valtari when the reviews hit. I would be fascinated because I am genuinely fascinated with optimism. The type of person who would love Valtari would be the type of person who would react strongly to my voicing of the sentence "My life is boring," I think. They cannot view their own lives as boring and thus they cannot view anyone else's lives as boring, and thus they cannot view Valtari as boring even if they tried, because they hear it and all they can hear is a soundtrack to their beautiful, exciting lives. I'm not disputing the idea of their lives being exciting—most people I know seem to have more exciting lives than I do. What I'm trying to say is that there requires a certain mindset to see the excitement in life at a consistent enough clip that you can then hear Valtari and appropriately hear a soundtrack meant for exciting movies. I'd call that optimism! I really would!

So maybe I'm not being optimistic here, I don't know... that doesn't feel right either. It's really just as simple as 1) I don't find my own life particularly compelling, plot-wise, 2) in listening to art that SAYS SOMETHING, I am able to find meaning in my own life, somehow, despite what I believe about it being uncompelling, 3) Sigur Rós is acting more like a mirror here, reflecting back my own life to me in their soundtrack-esque sounds, expecting me to add my own meaning to it instead of providing anything of their own, and 4) since I don't have anything and I'm usually seeking meaning through art, then Valtari feels particularly meaningless and vapid to me. You can see how it's my fault, like if I believe my life was actually rather exciting than maybe that's what I would see reflected back at me, but I don't, so I'm letting the negative self-image I see in the very beautiful, ornate mirror that Valtari gives me to tarnish the appreciation of the music. It's my fault, but if I'm supposed to be reviewing the album, then how can I give it a good grade? How can I say that I liked it if I didn't, regardless of whose fault that is?

And look, I know this is one of those times when I hear an album from a band for the first time and it's probably not the album I should be starting with. In penance for this album-of-the-week club allowing certain people to believe that Loaded was the end-all-be-all of the Velvet Underground, I am now listening to the Sigur Rós album that Stereogum claimed was the sixth-best Sigur Rós album out of seven (now eight), and lying all my thoughts about Sigur Rós as a whole at its feet. I was the kid who would take a pack of Dunkaroos and would put a microscopic amount of frosting on the first eight cookies, leaving all the frosting for those final two cookies, savoring that frosting bonanza finale all the more due to the fact that I suffered through all those bone-dry cookies at the beginning. I imagine that by forcing myself to suffer through Valtari twenty times in one week, I'll eventually get around to listening to Ágætis byrjun and be blown the fuck away.

But it doesn't even have to be that deep. All I need to do is wait for the right moment, and then when that moment arrives, strategically deploy Valtari one final time. I'm picturing some scene in the future when I'm, ah shit I dunno, maybe I get a desperate call from a loved one and I'm stuck in traffic and I leave my car right there in the middle of the street and run as fast as I can through all those cars to get to where I need to go, my hair blowing in the wind from my speed, tears in my eyes as I picture what will happen if I don't get to that loved one and help them in the way that they require, and in that moment, I see my life as cinematic, exciting as compared to a movie, and my headphones are in my ears as I run and I hear "Ég anda" playing and it becomes the soundtrack to this inciting incident in my exciting, cinematic life.

Until then—more chores, more bills, more typing on laptop keyboards, more quiet consistent love and peace and satisfaction that reads as boring as hell and that wouldn't make sense in any goddamn fucking movie.

GRADE: 1.5 pukes out of 5

2 comments:

Sarah said...

I think life-like-a-movie is potentially over-rated! Boring can be beautiful. Soul-making even?

Joe K said...

Just depends on what kind of movie, right? I'm certainly not living the movie that Sigur Rós want me to.