Friday, December 1, 2023

Loaded, Joe


I know "feeling cool" isn't really high on the priorities list when you're listening to music and investing your time and energy into this particular art form. It helps, but it's not really necessary. Mostly because music is—in my opinion, which is probably not the majority opinion, I'll grant you—a solitary experience. I sit on the train and I listen to an album of my choosing through my earbuds, privately. Doesn't matter if you think it's cool or not. "Cool" is an opinion that arrives externally.

The pessimistic way to look at the Velvet Underground is that the band started out a commercial failure, but has over the last six decades grown considerable social prestige, they being (to quote the famous quote about them) the band whose debut album sold 1000 copies but all 1000 people who bought it started their own rock 'n' roll band. But so now that they are extremely well-known to those who listen to rock music, because of that initial failure, it's easy for you to listen to this band and pretend that they are a secret that only you know about, even though that's not remotely true anymore, and hasn't been for 50 years. Pessimism says that the Velvet Underground are an easy exercise in self-deception.

But since I try to traffic in optimism around these parts, let's try to be optimistic—whatever their standing actually is in the great rock 'n' roll canon, it's undeniable that the Velvet Underground are worth investing in, from top to bottom. Quality begets coolness. Yes, you are cool listening to the Velvet Underground. I'm glad we are here today, the four-to-six of us, writing about this extremely cool band.

And we're listening to and writing about what is generally considered VU's worst album! Which is kind of insane, because this is going to be a positive review. How many bands can say that their worst album is this fucking good? Not many, I'd guess. I will say it's on the one hand very strange to be starting with Loaded in the context of Record Club, but on the other hand, maybe this will serve as a jumping-off point for VU neophytes who want to learn more. "You're saying the rest of their albums are better than this?!" and so on.

We're not here to talk about the discography, but let's do it anyway. My grand overarching VU theory is that their debut album, The Velvet Underground & Nico, is so great because it does a perfect job combining three separate sounds—harsh eclectic experimental rock, dark and soft and sorta twisted folk rock, and straight-ahead commercial rock—into one unholy piece of art, and then their subsequent three albums separate those sounds, and concentrate on just one of them in each album. White Light/White Heat is the bonkers noise rock, The Velvet Underground is gentle yet sinister soft rock, and Loaded is a classic rock 'n' roll sound with commercial appeal. This is why The Velvet Underground & Nico is the best VU album, and one's "favorite" VU album depends on where your proclivities lie.

I'm a White Light/White Heat fan myself, but maybe that has more to do with the "coolness" factor than anything else. I could tell you some cliché "discovering rock 'n' roll music" stories, if you wanted to hear them (you don't). Like, I recall playing WL/WH on my boombox after getting into bed at age like seventeen maybe, but not being able to go to sleep because I was absolutely riveted and kinda in awe of the seventeen-minute "Sister Ray," and I could say that maybe sitting there in the dark listening to the insanity has a way of changing the adolescent brain forever, were that not a stupid thing to say. I also recall hanging in my parents' basement, playing billiards and waiting for my mom and dad to go to sleep so that we could start drinking beers, and playing VU&N and me getting fucking roasted for "Sunday Morning" and thinking they just don't fucking get it like any good teen loser should.

The interesting thing about Loaded is that it strips away pretty much all of the weirdness that originally made the Velvet Underground so special, and it took me until this week to see that as it's own kind of weirdness. The story is that VU were faced with a make-it-or-break-it situation, that they needed some hits or else they would no longer be tenable as a band. The title of the album is a double entendre—yes, it's a allusion to "getting loaded" (the obvious take, since this is a band whose most famous song is called "Heroin"), but it's also a reference to the ultimatum handed to them: "this next album better be loaded with hits." Maybe it's a choice that your rock 'n' roll purists would scoff at, but it's nevertheless a choice. Straighten out the sound and try to get on the radio. This, from the Velvet Underground!!!

I saw a theory this week that Loaded is a "parody" of rock music, since it really leans into being "normal" (as compared to the previous three albums). I don't think that's true. That seems like a fan grappling with the fact that the most psychologically deranged psych-rock band of the '60s put out an attention-seeking pop album with three-minute ditties ostensibly designed to reach the Top 40. It's not that deep. The Velvet Underground often sought to "break the system," but they existed in that system too, and were privy to its demands. Loaded is the sound of the limits of making art within the structures of capitalism. Lou Reed wasn't trying to trick you; Lou Reed was trying to pay his motherfucking utility bills.

What I'm finding this week is that I'm extremely comfortable with Loaded and the reasons why it exists. There is artistic value here. It works in conversation with the rest of the VU discography. It's almost like anti-art, which is itself art. It's also pretty much the opposite of Yoko Ono's album from last week. YO/POB existed for the sake of art only, and stripped everything else away, including any noticeable hooks or melody. Loaded exists for the hooks, and purposefully eschews higher statements of art. The ying and yang of Record Club.

Apparently, in the immediate aftermath of Loaded, Lou Reed claimed that, after he quit Velvet Underground toward the tail-end of the making of Loaded, the album had been "re-edited and resequenced" without his permission. Doug Yule (who hilariously made another VU album after Loaded that pretty much everyone on earth seems to ignore completely) was basically like, "No, Lou was there through the whole thing, no one did anything behind his back." I obviously wasn't there and can't say for sure who's right, but I tend to think that Reed's pushback was a reaction to, well, losing some coolness and cred, basically. A natural reaction, maybe. Loaded is great but in a completely new and honestly somewhat unsavory way. There's a difference between wanting to make art and feeling like you have to make art. Or something like that. I'm just speculating.

If you forget about all this for a second and just listen to the goddamn album, then maybe what you hear is a really nice rock album with some catchy tunes. It's that too, and there's value in that too. If I had played Loaded in my parents' basement for my pals while we played pool and counted down the clock until sobriety ended, then it probably would've gone completely uncommented on, cool straight-ahead rock music for the background of a good night. When you're making a playlist for a gathering, and you'd like to include Velvet Underground, Loaded has your only viable choices. Tough to find something that isn't going to stick out or cause the proverbial record scratch on any of the other VU albums.

The big "hits" (which is in quotation marks because, I should've mentioned earlier, despite the efforts, VU did not find success, and mostly disbanded after Loaded) are "Sweet Jane" and "Rock & Roll." There are people in my life who only know these two songs, and I think that's okay. They are great songs. The latter especially acts as one of those excellent "here's great music about why music is great" exercises that I fucking adore. Everything else is catchy and uncomplicated. "Lonesome Cowboy Bill" is one I see derision for the most, but hey, man, can't deny that this hokey-ass pseudo-country tune is fucking catchy as a motherfucker. "New Age" is the closest that gets to the old/weird VU, but due to the context, doesn't really soar like it could've if it was on, say, the self-titled. Songs like "Cool It Down" would probably be the best, catchiest song on your typical mid-level rock outfit's best album, but here, on this album by this band, it seems just pretty fucking good and maybe a little rote.

This is the point I keep returning to. Anything bad you might say about Loaded is only said because of the context of "this is one of the greatest rock bands in music history," and has nothing to do with the quality of the album in a vacuum. And the fact that this is an incredibly uncomplicated album that somehow manages to greatly complicate the legacy of an overly complicated band is itself an artistic statement. How there is so much to think about but those thoughts have almost nothing to do with the text itself and have everything to do with the context and the subtext. How that probably does a disservice to the RC member who is attempting to "review" Loaded, and shines light on the unspoken fact that what we're doing here ultimately can't be described as "album reviews." How I'm so glad that my least favorite Velvet Underground album was chosen for this assignment, since any of the other three albums would have resulted in too glowing and effusive a review, and that would betray the unspoken fact that the Velvet Underground would lose the coolness factor if we all admitted that everyone likes this shit and that its large and still-growing popularity means that we are eventually going to have to admit that this band isn't all that cool anymore.

No. Shut up. It has nothing to do with being cool. I'm not a teenager anymore. I love this band and I love Loaded and one doesn't negate the other. I love this band and you will too, and one doesn't negate the other there either. 

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5 

No comments: