Monday, December 4, 2023

A Year of Blind Spots: Moving Pictures


Moving Pictures
Rush
1981

Let's talk about Neil Peart.

I'm not as vocal about disliking Peart's drumming as I am Charlie Watts'. Like, there's no "Neil Peart Licks Butts" tag that I'm going to attach to this blog post. But I do feel similar, if less fiery, about Neil Peart's drumming as I do Watts'.

When I was growing up and playing the drums and getting into classic rock music at the same time, I considered the holy trinity of drumming to be: Ringo Starr, John Bonham, Keith Moon. The thing they all had in common, and the thing that I grew to consider "essential" to being an all-timer drummer, is the the fact that the three of them were not only really fucking great at drumming, but also looked like they were having a lot of fun while drumming. I came to know the "spirit" of drumming, and viewed the percussion world as binary—you either had the spirit or you didn't.

It's not a matter of technical skill. It's more a matter of using that skill to bring fun and joyfulness to the art of drumming. There are plenty of drummers who are better on a pure technical level than Ringo Starr, for example. But no one embodies the soul and wonder of drumming better than Ringo. Definitely not Neil Peart (which I found out this week was pronounced like "peer-t" and not "pur-t"—I do a terrible job of "knowing thy enemy," so take everything I'm saying today with a huge grain of salt).

He's known as one of the most technically proficient drummers in rock 'n' roll history, and I saw or heard nothing this week to prove that otherwise. His nickname, I'm told, is "The Professor," and I can assure you that he is not in the John Keating tradition. Watch videos of the "famous" Neil Peart drum solos, and you will see a man who plays the drums like he is writing his dissertation—concentrated, serious, and careful to suck all the joy out of the occasion. I get that the 360-degree drum set and electronic drum pads and all that shit are impressive, but if it's all in service of some fucking robot playing them, then I fail to see the point.

In order to make sure I wasn't full of shit, I did what every self-respecting music blogger would do in this situation—I watched old David Letterman videos on YouTube. Letterman, in the summer of 2011, had a couple different "Drum Solo Weeks," during which the final musical guest each night was a drummer who would play their heart out. And yes, it is true—of the ten solos I saw, Neil Peart's was the busiest and most skillful. But I would also argue that it was the worst drum solo featured. Stewart Copeland, drummer of the Police, is probably half the drummer that Peart is, skill-wise, but his drum solo was so fucking fun. Ya know why? Because the dude was having a fucking blast up there. Smiling, sweating, leaning into every groove, throwing his sticks up in the air in a celebratory fashion... fuck, man, this is true drumming. (Also: I was stunned by how hot Sheila E. looked playing drums in a short dress and high heels. New turn-on unlocked, I guess.)

So if I say that I think Neil Peart is a shitty drummer, then what I really mean is that I think he is good at drumming, but shitty at being a drummer. I've made this argument in the past (I'm pretty sure I recall promising Dave I would explain it in more detail after he chose "YYZ" for a song prompt). But here's something interesting that complicates the issue: I had no idea before this week that Neil Peart was also Rush's lyricist, and that all the songs on Moving Pictures—including the aforementioned "YYZ" and the well-known "Tom Sawyer"—were written by him. Hmm.

Here's what I'll say about this: I am not well-read enough to be able to confidently comment on Neil Peart's connection to Ayn Rand, so don't take this as me saying that I know what's right and Neil Peart was wrong and that's that. My ignorance complicates things. But I do get the sense that people (read: conservatives) who read Ayn Rand use her writings as justification for being selfish members of society. Libertarianism feels to me like the embodiment of selfishness. If you're not beholden to anyone but yourself (like Tom Sawyer: "No, his mind is not for rent / To any god or government"), then other people are going to suffer. But, like, that's not how society is meant to function. You're supposed to care about your fellow man. If you don't, then everything collapses. And so it seems that libertarians only look out for themselves, but then also depend on others to help them? I'll repeat something I heard a while ago: libertarians are like house cats, in that they proclaim rugged individualism, but are dependent on a system that they don't even care to understand exists.

And Neil Peart, at least in the 1980s, was focused on these themes. He is widely known as a follower of the Ayn Rand beliefs, and as one of rock 'n' roll's premiere libertarians. Parsing through just a few of the lyrics on Moving Pictures will reveal this to be true. Which makes me uncomfortable. However, complicating things further in the other direction, thank god, is the fact that Neil Peart distanced himself from Rand's work late in his life: "Oh, no. That was forty years ago. But it was important to me at the time in a transition of finding myself and having faith that what I believed was worthwhile." Also, consider that before his death, he was critical of the U.S. Republican Party—"absolutely opposed to Christ's teachings"—and saw the Democrats as a "lesser evil." While I roll my eyes at anyone who sincerely brings up the name of Jesus Christ when making an argument, I am also forced to appreciate that my views on Peart's political views are way more complicated than "libertarian bad." (Plus... the dude is Canadian...)

It's pretty easy to ignore all that when you're listening to Rush, too, if it's not your speed. Ignore the icky politics and ignore the lifeless drummer and you have what basically amounts to nerdy prog rock. Some complicated rhythms, some anthemic vocals, some two-part rock suites, it's all pretty boilerplate as far as these things go, and that's not necessarily a bad thing. I do think that some people like Rush because it makes them feel smart, and to that I'll roll my eyes harder than I would at a someone who invokes the name Jesus Christ. That's also easily ignorable. Forget what everyone else thinks about this shit, and just listen to the guitar solo on "Red Barchetta." It ain't that deep.

There are some days I can ignore all this. On those days, I listen to Rush. There are other days when I can't fucking stand the selfish stain on rock 'n' roll music and drumming. On those days, I keep my distance. Peart's been dead for almost four years now, and every day he's been gone, it gets easier for me to swallow the bullshit I need to swallow to get to the sweet riffs. But your mileage may vary.


No comments: